A randomized controlled trial of intensive referral to 12-step self-help groups: One-year outcomes
Introduction
Twelve-step self-help groups (SHGs) are recognized as important to the system of care for substance use disorder (SUD) patients. By providing continuing support and structure, SHGs serve to reduce rates of post-treatment relapse and subsequent treatment utilization (O’Brien and McClellan, 1996). The American Psychiatric Association (1995) recommends referrals to SHGs for patients with SUDs, and large proportions of active 12-step group members first initiated meeting attendance because of a referral from a SUD treatment program (Thomassen, 2002).
This study implemented and evaluated procedures to help clinicians make more effective referrals to 12-step SHGs. SUD outpatients were randomly assigned to a standard referral or an intensive referral-to-self-help condition. We examined whether intensive referral, compared to standard referral, increased patients’ SHG attendance and involvement (e.g., having a sponsor) over two consecutive six-month follow-up periods. We also determined whether patients who received intensive referral had better substance use outcomes over the year. Further, we determined the extent to which more 12-step SHG attendance and involvement were related to better substance use outcomes.
Although most formally treated SUD patients are referred to SHGs (Humphreys, 1997), under usual referral, patients often do not attend or drop out of these groups quickly (Chappel, 1991, Humphreys et al., 1999, Littrell, 1991). An early study of individuals with alcohol use disorders (AUDs) and spouses of such individuals found that all 10 clients in an intensive referral condition attended SHGs (Alcoholics Anonymous [AA] or Al-Anon) over four weeks, compared to none of 10 clients in the standard referral condition (Sisson and Mallams, 1981). In intensive referral, the client called a SHG member during a counseling session to arrange to go to a meeting together. In standard referral, the counselor provided a description of self-help, a meeting schedule, and encouragement to attend SHG meetings.
Project MATCH found that outpatients in a 12-week Twelve Step Facilitation (TSF) treatment condition, which encouraged AA attendance, had more AA attendance and involvement during treatment, and at one- and three-year follow-ups, than did clients in a Cognitive Behavioral (CB) Therapy or Motivational Enhancement Therapy condition (Carroll et al., 1998, Project MATCH Research Group, 1998, Tonigan et al., 2002). Consistent with Project MATCH, the VA Multisite Evaluation of Substance Abuse Treatment found that, at a one-year follow-up, SUD patients in TSF or combined TSF/CB programs were more likely than patients in CB programs to have attended SHG meetings, and were more involved in self-help (e.g., were more likely to talk with a sponsor, and to read AA and/or Narcotics Anonymous [NA] literature) (Humphreys et al., 1999). In contrast to Sisson and Mallams’ (1981) intensive referral condition, TSF was much more than a referral to AA (Project MATCH Research Group, 1997), but the intensive referral and TSF were broadly comparable in that both encouraged participation in SHGs. Based on these and preliminary findings from the sample of SUD patients studied here (Timko et al., 2006), we expected that intensive referral to self-help, compared to standard referral, would result in more 12-step SHG meeting attendance and involvement at both six months post-referral and six months after that.
Preliminary findings on this sample also indicated that, compared to patients who received standard referral, those who received intensive referral had better alcohol and drug use outcomes at six months. In this paper, we extend this work by examining the effects of referral condition on SHG attendance and involvement and SUD outcomes at one year, and considering the extent to which involvement mediated the association between referral condition and one-year outcomes. With regard to mediation, among cocaine-dependent patients, higher scores on an index assessing both 12-step group involvement and endorsement of 12-step philosophy partially mediated the positive relationship between receiving outpatient counseling that encouraged participation in 12-step groups and more improvement on drug use outcomes during a six-month follow-up period (Crits-Christoph et al., 2003). Another study of cocaine-dependent patients found that 12-step SHG attendance did not predict subsequent drug use, but more 12-step SHG involvement in a given month predicted less cocaine use in the next month (Weiss et al., 2005). These results underscore the distinction between attendance and involvement and the need to consider the role of involvement in improved SUD outcomes over time.
To summarize, this project used a randomized design in which patients entering outpatient SUD treatment were assigned to either standard or intensive referral to 12-step SHGs. Patients were followed at six months and one year to determine whether intensive referral resulted in more 12-step SHG attendance and involvement and in better substance use outcomes. We also examined the extent to which 12-step involvement predicted better substance use outcomes above and beyond SHG meeting attendance, and mediated between referral condition and substance use outcomes.
Section snippets
Sample
Patients were included on the basis of the following criteria: (1) entering SUD outpatient treatment at a Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) program, and (2) clinically judged by program staff to be cognitively able to understand the study's questionnaire and interview procedures. The 28-day treatment program had a combined CB/TSF orientation that explored the interpersonal consequences of substance misuse. Treatment was abstinence-based with patient activities (e.g., therapy oriented toward
Patients
Fig. 1 summarizes the flow of patients through the trial. Of the 384 patients who were assessed for eligibility, 345 were randomly assigned. Excluded were 39 patients because of refusal (n = 37) or cognitive impairment (n = 2). In all, 164 patients were randomly assigned to the standard referral group (146 [89%] were followed at one year) and 181 to the intensive referral group (161 [89%] were followed at one year). (For patients’ attendance at outpatient sessions and its association with SHG
Discussion
We found that the intensive referral intervention was more effective than standard referral at promoting regular 12-step group attendance. In addition, the intensive intervention, with the key elements of connecting patients to 12-step volunteers and having counselors follow up with patients on agreements for attendance with the aid of a 12-step journal, was associated with increased 12-step involvement and more improvements on alcohol and drug use. Increased involvement occurred even though
Acknowledgements
This project was supported by the Department of Veterans Affairs Office of Research and Development (Health Services Research and Development Service, IIR 20-067 and RCS 00-001). We thank Peter Banys, Ruth Cronkite, Kristyn Dixon, Keith Humphreys, Louis Moffett, Rudolf Moos, Cassie Sandino, and Jill Sempel for help with this project.
References (50)
- et al.
Alcoholics Anonymous affiliation during early recovery
J. Subst. Abuse Treat.
(1998) - et al.
The relationship of pretreatment Alcoholics Anonymous affiliation with problem severity, social resources, and treatment history
Drug Alcohol Depend.
(1998) - et al.
Does Alcoholics Anonymous involvement predict treatment outcome?
J. Subst. Abuse Treat.
(1995) - et al.
Myths about the treatment of addiction
Lancet
(1996) - et al.
Performance measures for outpatient substance abuse services: group versus individual counseling
J. Subst. Abuse Treat.
(2003) - et al.
Narcotics Anonymous participation and changes in substance use and social support
J. Subst. Abuse Treat.
(2002) - et al.
The effect of 12-step self-help group attendance and participation on drug use outcomes among cocaine-dependent patients
Drug Alcohol Depend.
(2005) - et al.
Are patients at veterans affairs medical centers sicker? A comparative analysis of health status and medical resource use
Arch. Intern. Med.
(2000) Practice guidelines for the treatment of patients with substance abuse disorders
Am J Psychiatry
(1995)- et al.
The moderator-mediator variable distinction in social psychological research: conceptual, strategic, and statistical considerations
J. Pers. Soc. Psychol.
(1986)
Group psychotherapy in the treatment of addictive disorders: past, present, and future
Examining the effects of alcoholism typology and AA attendance on self-efficacy as a mechanism of change
J. Stud. Alcohol
Drug/Alcohol Policies and Services in Treatment Programs: Current Status, Interrelationships, and Impacts on Outcome
Internal validity of project MATCH treatments
J. Consult. Clin. Psychol.
The use of Alcoholics Anonymous and narcotics anonymous by the physician in treating drug and alcohol addiction
What is Alcoholics Anonymous affiliation?
Subst. Use Misuse
Mediators of outcome of psychosocial treatments for cocaine dependence
J. Consult. Clin. Psychol.
Assessing the validity of randomized field experiments: an example from drug abuse treatment research
Eval. Rev.
Ethical and practical randomized field experiments
Alcoholics Anonymous: what is currently known
After drug treatment: are 12-step programs effective in maintaining abstinence?
Am. J. Drug Alcohol Abuse
Is attendance at Alcoholics Anonymous meetings after inpatient treatment related to improved outcomes? A 6-month follow-up study
Alcohol Alcohol.
Clinicians’ referral and matching of substance abuse patients to self-help groups after treatment
Psychiatr. Serv.
Reduced substance-abuse-related health care costs among voluntary participants in Alcoholics Anonymous
Psychiatr. Serv.
Encouraging posttreatment self-help group involvement to reduce demand for continuing care services: two-year clinical and utilization outcomes
Alcohol. Clin. Exp. Res.
Cited by (134)
Self-help group (SHG) attendance and treatment outcomes among older adults in the US
2024, Psychiatry Research CommunicationsSelf-help and mutual-aid groups for people with mental health, addiction, and other behavioral health conditions
2023, Encyclopedia of Mental Health, Third Edition: Volume 1-3Augmenting substance use treatment in the drug court: A pilot randomized trial of peer recovery support
2021, Journal of Substance Abuse TreatmentTherapeutic efficacy of environmental enrichment for substance use disorders
2020, Pharmacology Biochemistry and Behavior