Abstract
This contribution compares entries on Friedrich Froebel and the kindergarten in German and United States’ histories of education from 1857 to 1933. In the American histories, Froebel appears as the great “hero” of education of the 19th century, whereas in the German histories, Pestalozzi is the “hero.” This difference in the perspectives goes back to fundamental differences in the political culture and political traditions of the two countries, which differed greatly as to the shaping of the public and private spheres. Consequently, there were also different views on public education. In the immigration society of the United States, it was important to integrate children with various language and cultural backgrounds. As families could not do this alone, public kindergartens were needed. In Germany, in contrast, Froebel’s idea of the kindergarten was seen as an attack on family ties, and Pestalozzi was highly esteemed, because he made home education central. The American interest in “making citizens” produced Froebel as the hero; the German interest in leaving the education of young children to mothers and in the family lauded Pestalozzi. This case study of the reception of Froebel in Germany and the United States illustrates the high context-dependence of the construction of educational “heroes.”
Similar content being viewed by others
References
A.T. Allen (1989) ArticleTitleKommt, laßt uns unsern Kindern leben. Kindergartenbewegung Deutschland und in den Vereinigten Staaten, 1840–1914. Zeitschrift für Pädagogik 35 IssueID1 65–84
A.T. Allen (1991) Feminism and motherhood in German University Press New Brunswick: Rutgers
A.T. Allen (1995) American and German women in the kindergarten movement,1850–1914 H Geitz J Heideking J Herbst (Eds) German influences on education in the United States to 1917 University Press Washington, DC and Cambridge 82–102
A.T. Allen (2000a) Feminismus und Mütterlichkeit in Deutschland Beltz Weinheim 1800–1914
Allen, A.T. (2000b). Kindergarten. In J.D. Chastain (Ed), Encyclopedia of revolutions of 1848. Ohio University. Available on the Internet at http://www.ohiou.edu/∼Chastain/ip/kinderga.htm.
M.S Baader (1995) Die romantische Idee des Kindes und der Kindheit Luchterhand Neuwied
Baader, M.S. (1998). ‘Alle wahren Demokraten tun es.’ Die Fröbelschen Kindergärten und der Zusammenhang von Erziehung, Revolution und Religion. In C. Jansen & T. Mergel (Eds), Die Revolutionen von 1848/49 (pp. 206–225). Göttingen: Vandenhoeck.
Baader, M.S. (1999). Die Politisierung des Fröbelschen Kindergartenprojektes durch die Revolutionen von 1848/49. In H. Kemnitz, H.J. Apel & C. Ritzi (Eds), Bildungsideen und Schulalltag im Revolutionsjahr 1848 (pp. 51–64). Hohengehren: Schneider.
Baader, M.S. (2002). Die romantische Idee der Kindheit. Friedrich Fröbels Kindergärten als politisch und finanziell bedrohte ‘Oasen des Glücks’. In H. Schmitt & S. Siebrecht (Eds), Eine Oase des Glücks. Der romantische Blick auf Kinder(pp. 57–73). (o.O): Henschel.
H.C Bowen (1893) Froebel and education through self-activity Charles Scribner’s Sons New York
P.R. Cole (1918) Froebel P. Monroe (Eds) A cyclopedia of education Vol. II The Macmillan Company New York 718–723
E.P. Cubberly (1904) Syllabus of lectures on the history of education EditionNumber2 Macmillan New York
E.P. Cubberly (1920) The history of education Houghton Mifflin Company Boston
Ch Darwin (1996) The origin of species by means of natural selection Oxford University Press Oxford:
T Davidson (1901) A history of education. Charles Scribner’s Sons New York
J Dewey (1899) The school and society The University of Chicago Press Chicago
F Franks (1997) The kindergarten system A. Sonnenschein London
F Froebel (1826) Die Menschenerziehung. A. Wienbrack. Leipzig
F Froebel (1888) The education of man. Translated and annotated by W.N. Hailmann D. Appleton and Company New York
Froebel, F. (1889). Autobiography.Syracuse: C.W. Bardeen.
F Froebel (1895) The songs and music of Friedrich Froebel’s mother play Appleton & Co. New York
F Froebel (1899) Pedagogics of the kindergarten. Appleton & Co. New York
F Froebel (1905) Education by development. Appleton & Co. New York
F Froebel (1933) Erneuung des Lebens fordert das Jahr 1836 Quelle und Meyer Leipzig
F Froebel (1982a) Die Menschenerziehung. In Herausgegeben von E. Hoffmann, Ausgewählte Schriften. Cotta Stuttgart
Froebel, F. (1982b). Entwurf eines Planes zur Begründung und Ausführung eines Kindergartens. In Herausgegeben von E. Hoffmann (Ed) Ausgewählte Schriften. (Vol. I, pp. 114–125). Stuttgart: Cotta (Original work published 1940).
H Geitz J Heideking J Herbst (Eds) (1995) German influences on education in the United States to 1917 Cambridge: University Press Washington, DC
G.S. Hall (1911a) The pedagogy of the kindergarten. In educational problems Appleton. New York 1–41
G.S. Hall (1911b) Educational problems Appleton New York
G.S. Hall S Mansfield (Eds) (1893) Bibliography of education Heath & Co Boston: D.C.
W Halsey (Eds) (1968) Collier’s encyclopedia Macmillan New York
Heiland, H. (1982). Froebel. Reinbek: Rowohlt.
H Heiland (1999) Froebel und das Jahr 1848 H. Kemnitz H.J. Apel C. Ritzi (Eds) Bildungsideen und Schulalltag im Revolutionsjahr 1848 Schneider. Hohengehren 11–50
H Heiland K Neumann M Gebel (Eds) (1999) Friedrich Froebel – Aspekte international vergleichender Historiographie. Beltz Weinheim
A.H Heinemann (Eds) (1893) Froebel’s letters Lee & Shepard Publishers. Boston:
R.E Hughes (1902) The making of citizens. A study in comparative education Walter Schott London and New-Castle-on-Tyne
Johann Gotlieb Fichte (1762–1814).
B Marenhotz-Bülow (1877) Reminiscences of Friedrich Froebel. Lee & Shepard Boston
B Marenholtz-Bülow (1896) The child and child nature Swan Sonnenschein & Co. London
Messer, A. (1930). Geschichte der Pädagogik.Dritter Teil: Vom Anfang des 18. Jahrhunderts bis zur Gegenwart. (2. erweiterte Auflage). Breslau: Hirt.
Missouri (1869–1877).
E Michaelis H.K. Moore (1896) Froebel’s letters on the kindergarten C.W. Bardeen Syracuse 1838–1852
P Monroe (Eds) (1908) A brief course in the history of education Macmillan & Co London
P Monroe (1915) A text-book in the history of education The Macmilan Company New York
P Monroe (Eds) (1918) A cyclopedia of education The Macmillan Company New York 598–606
H Nohl (1930) Friedrich Froebel und die Gegenwart. Beiträge zur Bildung der Persönlichkeit Quelle und Meyer Leipzig
H Nohl (1963) Die pädagogische Bewegung und ihre Theorie Schulte-Bulmke Frankfurt
H Nohl L Pallat (Eds) (1933) Handbuch der Pädagogik Julius Beltz. Berlin
F.V.N. Painter (1896) A history of education D. Appleton and Company. New York
F Paulsen (1921) Geschichte des gelehrten Unterrichts de Gruyter. Berlin
K.v Raumer (1857) Geschichte der Pädagogik vom Wiederaufblühen klassischer Studien bis auf unsere Zeit Samuel Liesching. Stuttgart
E Rausch (1914) Geschichte der Pädagogik und des gelehrten Unterrichtes Deichertsche Verlagsbuchhandlung Leipzig
Regener, Fr. (1912). Skizzen zur Geschichte der Pädagogik.Langensalza: Beyer & Söhne.
Schmid, K.A. (1901). Geschichte der Erziehung vom Anfang an bis auf unsere Zeit, 5 Volumes. Stuttgart: Cotta.
L Seely (1899) History of education American Book Company New York
D.J Snider (1895) Froebel’s mother play songs; a commentary Sigma Publishing Co. Chicago
D.J Snider (1900) Froebel’s mother play songs; a commentary Sigma Publishing Co. Chicago
N.C. Vandewalker (1918) Kindergarten P Monroe (Eds) A cyclopedia of education The Macmillan Company. New York 598–606
K.D Wiggin N.A Smith (1896) The republic of childhood Houghton, Mifflin & Co. Boston
R Wollons (2000) Kindergartens and cultures: the global diffusion of an idea Yale University Press New Haven
Ziegler, T. (1923). Geschichte der Pädagogik mit besonderer Rücksicht auf das höhere Unterrichtswesen (5. erweiterte Auflage). München: Becksche Verlagsbuchhandlung.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Sophia Baader, M. Froebel and the Rise of Educational Theory in the United States. Stud Philos Educ 23, 427–444 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11217-004-4453-0
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11217-004-4453-0