Abstract
The Ringelmann smoke chart was used in the United States to assess smoke emissions in the early twentieth century. In fact, it may have been the most important method for measuring air pollution between the late 1800s and the environmental era. However, the popularity of the Ringelmann chart stood in stark contrast to its lack of precision, which smoke abatement experts recognized and discussed among themselves. However, the critique of the Ringelmann scale rarely left the circle of experts and never jeopardized its use. This article discusses the reasons for this striking phenomenon, pointing out that the Ringelmann chart had strong practical and symbolic advantages: it allowed smoke abatement to be conducted in a public and transparent way. With that, the history of the Ringelmann smoke chart is an instructive model for the social construction of measuring techniques.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Assembly of the State of California: 1953, Report of the Subcommittee of the Assembly Interim Committee on Governmental Efficiency and Economy Relative to a Study and Analysis of the Facts Pertaining to Air Pollution Control in Los Angeles County.
Azbe, V. J.: 1930,‘Smoke abatement progress’, Power Plant Eng. 34, 1102–1104.
Bailey, E. G.: 1910,‘Smoke Abatement in New England, 1910’, E.G. Bailey Papers, Box 2, Hagley Library, Wilmington, Delaware, Accession 2092, p. 1.
Barkley, J. F.: 1951,‘Air-pollution prevention in the United States’, Mech. Eng. 73, 284–288.
Barr, W. M.: 1901, A Catechism on the Combustion of Coal and the Prevention of Smoke: A Practical Treatise, N.W. Henley & Company, New York, 349 pp.
Benner, R. C.: 1912a,‘The smoke investigation of the Industrial Research Department of the University of Pittsburgh’, Ind. World 46, 1270–1273.
Benner, R. C.: 1912b,‘Smoke Abatement in Pittsburgh’, in. Coal Smoke Abatement Society (ed.), Papers Read at the Smoke Abatement Conference March 26–28, 1912, London, pp. 81–83.
Benner, R. C. (ed): 1913, Papers on the Effect of Smoke on Building Materials, Mellon Institute of Industrial Research and School of Specific Industries, Smoke Investigation Bulletin No. 6, Pittsburgh.
Breckenridge, L. P.: 1907, How to Burn Illinois Coal Without Smoke, University of Illinois Engineering Experiment Station, Bulletin 15, Urbana.
Bundesgesetzblatt, 1997, part 1, p. 498.
Chambers, J. W.: 1980, The Tyranny of Change: America in the Progressive Era, 1900–1917, St. Martin’s Press, New York, 280 pp.
Christy, W. G.: 1949,‘Let’s make air pollution control effective’, Am. City 64, 78–79.
Christy, W. G.: 1960,‘History of the air pollution control association’, J. Air Pollut. Control Assoc. 10, 126–137, 174.
Citizens’ Smoke Abatement League: 1926, Minutes of Meetings 1926–1934, Executive Committee Meeting, April 30, Scrapbook File, Missouri Historical Society, St. Louis.
Committee on Fuel Supply of the Boston Chamber of Commerce: 1910, Smoke Abatement, Boston Chamber of Commerce, Boston, 11 pp.
Davis, H. N.: 1931,‘The air pollution problem’, Natl. Electric Light Assoc. Proc. 88, 103–106.
Feldhaus, G. and Hansel, H. D.: 1971, Umweltschutz. Luftreinhaltung, Lärmbekämpfung. Rechts- und Verwaltungsvorschriften des Bundes und der Länder mit einer systematischen Einführung (Cologne).
Filene, P. G.: 1970,‘An obituary for‘The Progressive Movement’, Am. Quart. 22, 20–34.
Flagg, S. B.: 1912, Smoke Abatement and City Smoke Ordinances, US Bureau of Mines Bulletin 49, Washington.
Gibbons, J. O. G.: 1928,‘Does the public really want smoke eliminated?’, Power Plant Eng. 32, 792.
Hebley, H. F.: 1947,‘Factors rarely considered in smoke abatement’, Mech. Eng. 69, 281–287.
Hebley, H. F.: 1948, 1949,‘Technological factors in relation to some legal aspects of smoke control’, Univ. Pittsburgh Law Rev. 10, 505–510.
Hodges, J. M.: 1939,‘The Ringelmann Chart Method of Determining Smoke Violations’, in: Smoke Prevention Association, Proceedings of the Thirty-Third Annual Convention, Milwaukee, Wisconsin, June 13–16, 1939, pp. 114–119.
Hünemörder, K.: 2001, Die Frühgeschichte der globalen Umweltkrise und die Formierung der deutschen Umweltpolitik (1940–1973), Ph.D., University of Kiel.
Illinois Manufacturers’ Association: 1962, Statement, Special Joint Technical Committee, Chicago Association of Commerce and Industry and Illinois Manufacturers’ Association, December 31, p. 6, box 106, folder 20, Chicago Historical Society.
Illinois Manufacturers’ Association: 1966, Illinois Manufacturers’ Association to Members of the IMA Clean Air and Water Committee and Other Interested Parties, May 10, p. 4, Box 108, Folder 2, Chicago Historical Society.
Illinois Manufacturers’ Association: 1968, Statement of Orville V. Bergren, Secretary, Illinois Manufacturers’ Association Before the Committee on Health, Chicago City Council, February 16, p. 5, Box 109, Folder 1, Chicago Historical Society,
Illinois Manufacturers’ Association: 1970, Statement Pertaining to Proposed Chapter II, Rules for Controlling Existing Pollution, and Chapter III, Rules for Control of Emissions from New Equipment, Air Pollution Control Board Public Hearing, Chicago, April 7, p. 4, Box 109, Folder 3, Chicago Historical Society.
Johnson, A. J. and Auth, G. H. (eds): 1951, Fuels and Combustion Handbook, McGraw-Hill, New York, 915 pp.
Kudlich, R.: 1936, Ringelmann Smoke Chart, US Bureau of Mines Information Circular 6888, n. l.
Lamping, F. H.: 1935,‘Standardization of Measuring Atmospheric Pollution’, in: Smoke Prevention Association, Proceedings of the Twenty-Ninth Annual Convention, St. Louis, Missouri, June 4–7, 1935, pp. 72–75.
Landesanstalt für Immissions- und Bodennutzungsschutz des Landes Nordrhein-Westfalen: 1968, Landeshauptarchiv Koblenz Bestand 930, No. 10320, Schulungsprogramm “Immissionsschutz” 1968, p. 2.
Link, A. S. and McCormick, R. L.: 1983, Progressivism, Harlan Davidson, Inc., Arlington Heights, pp. 149.
MacLaurin, R. D.: 1929,‘Abating black smoke will not solve the problem of atmospheric pollution’, Am. City 40, 135–137.
Marsh, A.: 1947, Smoke: The Problem of Coal and the Atmosphere, Faber and Faber, London, pp. 306.
Meldau, R.: 1926, Der Industriestaub: Wesen und Bekämpfung, Berlin.
Meldau, R.: 1929,‘Übersicht über Stand und Aufgaben der Staubmeßtechnik. Bericht an den Fachausschußfür Staubtechnik beim VDI’, Die Meßtechnik 5, 66–69.
Mitteilungen aus der Praxis des Dampfkessel- und Dampfmaschinen-Betriebes: 1903, 26, p. 159.
Monnett, O.: 1923, Smoke Abatement, US Bureau of Mines Technical Paper 273, Washington.
Monnett, O. et al.: 1926, Smoke-Abatement Investigation at Salt Lake City, Utah, Bureau of Mines Bulletin 254, Washington.
Monnett, O.: 1941,‘Smoke ordinances’, Ind. Eng. Chem. 33, 839–840.
Obermeyer, H.: 1933, Stop That Smoke!, Harper & Brothers, New York and London, 289 pp.
O’Connor, J. J., Jr.: 1913a, The Economic Cost of the Smoke Nuisance to Pittsburgh, Mellon Institute of Industrial Research and School of Specific Industries, Smoke Investigation Bulletin No. 4, Pittsburgh.
O’Connor, J. J., Jr.: 1913b,‘The smoke investigation of the University of Pittsburgh’, Ind. World 47, 132–133.
O’Connor, J. J.: 1915, letter to W. F. M. Goss, December 10, Archives of Industrial Society, University of Pittsburgh, 83:7 Ser. I FF 21.
Randall, D. T.: 1908, The Burning of Coal without Smoke in Boiler Plants: A Preliminary Report, United States Geological Survey Bulletin 334, Washington.
Ringelmann, M.: 1898,‘Méthode d’estimation des fumées Produites Par Les Foyers Industriels’, La Revue Technique 19, 268–271.
Rodgers, D. T.: 1982,‘In search of progressivism’, Rev. Am. History 10, 113–132.
Rooney, M. A.: 1915,‘Ordinances for smoke abatement’, Am. City 13, 316–317.
Smoke Prevention Association: 1915, Proceedings of the Tenth Annual Convention, September 8–10.
State of California, The Resources Agency: 1969, Air Pollution Control in California: 1968 Annual Report – Air Resources Board, January 1969.
Stern, A. C.: 1945,‘Atmospheric pollution due to smoke’, Heating Ventilating 42, 67–70.
Strong, W. W.: 1911/12,‘Über die wissenschaftliche Behandlung der Rauchfrage’, Rauch und Staub 2, 65–66.
Stradling, D.: 1999, Smokestacks and Progressives: Environmentalists, Engineers, and Air Quality in America, 1881–1951, Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, 270 pp.
Straub, A. A.: 1914, Some Engineering Phases of Pittsburgh’s Smoke Problem, Mellon Institute of Industrial Research and School of Specific Industries, Smoke Investigation Bulletin No. 8, Pittsburgh.
Tucker, R. R.: 1945, 1946,‘A smoke elimination program that works’, Heating Piping Air Conditioning 17, 463–469, 519–523, 605–610, 605–610; 18(1) 99–105; 18(2) 102–104.
Tucker, R. R.: 1949, letter to J. C. Kimbrough, June 27, Raymond R. Tucker Smoke Abatement Collection, Series 3, Box 1, Folder “Kingsport, Tennessee,” Washington University Archives, St. Louis.
Transactions of the American Society of Mechanical Engineers: 1990, 21, 97–99.
Uekoetter, F.: 1999,‘Divergent responses to identical problems: Businessmen and the smoke nuisance in Germany and the United States, 1880–1917’, Business History Rev. 73, 641–676.
Wallin, J. E. W.: 1913, Psychological Aspects of the Problem of Atmospheric Smoke Pollution, Mellon Institute of Industrial Research and School of Specific Industries, Smoke Investigation Bulletin No. 3, Pittsburgh.
Whittaker, H. A. et al.: 1948,‘Air pollution’, Am. J. Public Health Nation’s Health 38, 761–769.
Wiethaup, H.: 1963, Schutz vor Luftverunreinigungen, Geräuschen und Erschütterungen. Immissions- schutzgesetz Nordrhein-Westfalen, Herne and Berlin.
Zeitschrift des Bayerischen Revisions-Vereins 7 (1903), p. 15.
Zeitschrift des Bayerischen Revisions-Vereins 7 (1903), p. 15.
Zellner, K. J.: 1915,‘The smoke nuisance’, Natl. Municipal Rev. 4, 97–98.
Zimmermann, E.: 1931,‘Messung von Flugstaub in Rauchgasen’, Zeitschrift Vereines Deutscher Ingenieure 75, 481–486.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Uekoetter, F. The Strange Career of the Ringelmann Smoke Chart. Environ Monit Assess 106, 11–26 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10661-005-0756-z
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10661-005-0756-z