Summary
The issue of discrimination in physically demanding employment, such as police, firefighters, prison guards and military personnel, is contentious. In terms of oxygen transport, the ‘action limit’ (calling for personnel selection or task redesign) is a steady oxygen consumption of 0.7 L/min, while the maximum permissible limit is 2.1 L/min. Note is taken of the commonly expressed belief that public safety duties are physically demanding, calling for personnel with an aerobic power of at least 3 L/min, or 42 to 45 ml/kg/min. The actual demands of such work can be assessed on small samples by physiological measurements (using heart rate or oxygen consumption meters), but the periods sampled may not be typical of a normal day. A Gestalt can also be formed as to the heaviness of a given job, or a detailed task analysis can be performed; most such analyses of public safety work list distance running and other aerobic activities infrequently. An arbitrary requirement of ‘above average fitness’ is no longer accepted by courts, but a further approach is to examine the characteristics of those currently meeting the demands of public safety jobs satisfactorily. Young men commonly satisfy the 3 L/min standard, but this is not usually the case for women or older men; in the case of female employees, it also seems unreasonable that they should be expected to satisfy the same standards as men, since a lower body mass reduces the energy cost of most of the tasks that they must perform.
A second criterion sometimes applied to physically demanding work (a low vulnerability to heart attacks) is examined critically. It is concluded that the chances that a symptom-free public safety officer will develop a heart attack during a critical solo mission are so low that cardiac risk should not be a condition of employment.
Arbitrary age- and sex-related employment criteria are plainly discriminatory, since some women and 65-year-old men have higher levels of physical fitness than the average young man of 25 years. Neither laboratory nor field tests offer a satisfactory means of distinguishing such individuals, and the only equitable basis of selecting personnel for physically demanding work seems a probationary period of employment.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Allen CL, Brown TE, O’Hara WJ. Aerobic fitness and coronary risk factors. In Allen (Ed.) Proceedings of the First RSG4 Physical Fitness Symposium with Special Reference to Military Populations, pp. 286–292, Defence and Civil Institute of Environmental Medicine, Downsview, Ont., 1978
Allen CL, Celentano EJ, Nottrodt JW, Hart LEM, Cox KM, et al. Development of occupational physical selection standards for the Canadian Forces — summary reports, DCIEM Reports, Downsview, Ont., 1984
American College of Sports Medicine. The recommended quantity and quality of exercise for developing and maintaining cardiorespiratory and muscular fitness in healthy adults. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 22: 265–274, 1990
Amor AF. A survey of physical fitness in the British Army. In Allen C (Ed.) Proceedings of the First RSG4 Physical Fitness Symposium with Special Reference to Military Populations. pp. 38–46, Defence and Civil Institute of Environmental Medicine, Downsview, Ont., 1978
Amor AF, Taylor S. A step test of fitness for British Army women. In Allen C (Ed.) Proceedings of the First RSG4 Physical Fitness Symposium with Special Reference to Military Populations, pp. 190–200, Defence and Civil Institute of Environmental Medicine, Downsview, Ont., 1978
Amor AF, Worsley DE, Haisman MF, O’Hara WJ. Energy expenditure in movement over snow. UK Army Personnel Research Establishment, Report 9/77, 1977
Åstrand I. Degree of strain during building work as related to individual aerobic work capacity. Ergonomics 10: 293–303, 1967
Åstrand PO. Exercise physiology of the mature athlete. In Sutton & Brock (Eds) Sports medicine for the mature athlete, pp. 3–13, Benchmark Press, Indianapolis, 1986
Ayres SM, Evans R, Licht D, Griesbach J, Reinhold F, et al. Health effects of exposure to high concentrations of automotive emissions. Archives of Environmental Health 27: 168–178, 1973
Babin M. Sondage sur la forme physique des policiers canadiens. Gazette de la Gendarmérie Royale du Canada 45(4): 19–22, 1983a
Babin M. Etre en forme- une nécessité des policiers canadiens. Gazette de la Gendarmérie Royale du Canada 45(4): 1–16, 1983b
Bahrke MS. Voluntary and mandatory fitness programs for firefighters. Physician and Sportsmedicine 10(8): 126–130, 1982
Baker BR, Danielson NF. Police personnel administration. pp. 59–100, Police Foundation, Washington, 1974
Bard C, Fleury M, Jobin J, Lagassé P, Roy B. Elaboration des normes physiques d’admission aux corps d’agents de la paix. Unpublished manuscript, Faculty of Physical Education, Laval University, Quebec City, 1985
Bardsley JE. The Canadian Forces Life Quality Improvement Programme. In Allen C (Ed.) Proceedings of RSG4 Physical Fitness symposium, with Special Reference to Military Forces, pp. 263–270, Defence and Civil Institute of Environmental Medicine, Downsview, Ont., 1978
Barnard RJ, Anthony DF. Effect of health maintenance programs in Los Angeles City firefighters. Journal of Occupational Medicine 22: 667–669, 1980
Barnard RJ, Gardner GW, Diaco NV. ‘Ischemic’ heart disease in firefighters with normal coronary arteries. Journal of Occupational Medicine 18: 818–820, 1976
Barnard RJ, Gardner GW, Diaco NV, MacAlpin RN, Kattus AA. Cardiovascular response to sudden strenuous exercise — heart rate, blood pressure and ECG. Journal of Applied Physiology 34: 833–837, 1973
Bertina FM. A physical fitness test employed by the Royal Netherlands Army. In Allen C (Ed.) Proceedings of the First RSG4 Physical Fitness Symposium with Special Reference to Military Populations, pp. 70–75, Defence and Civil Institute of Environmental Medicine, Downsview, Ont., 1978
Blair SN, Pieserchia PV, Wilbur CS, Crowder JH. A public health intervention model for work-site health promotion: impact on exercise and physical fitness in a health promotion plan after 24 months. Journal of the American Medical Association 255: 921–926, 1986
Bonjer FH. Relationship between working time, physical working capacity and allowable caloric expenditure. In Rohmert W (Ed.) Muskelarbeit und Muskeltraining, Gentner Verlag, Darmstadt, 1968
Booth WS, Hornick CN. Physical ability testing for police officers in the 80s. Police Chief 51(1): 39–41, 1984
Borkan GA, Norris AH. Biological age in adulthood: comparison of active and inactive US males. Human Biology 52: 787–802, 1980
Brown JR, Crowden GP. Energy expenditure ranges and muscular work grades. British Journal of Industrial Medicine 20: 277–283, 1963
Brownlie L, Brown S, Diewert G, Good P, Holman G, et al. The evaluation of firefighter recruits. Abstract. Canadian Journal of Sport Sciences 7: 231, 1982
Burelle C, Ricci J, Peronnet F. Condition physique des policiers de la communauté de Montréal. Médicine du Sport 61: 13–17, 1987
Cady LA, Phillip CT, Karwalsky RJ. Program for increasing health and physical fitness of firefighters. Journal of Occupational Medicine 27: 110–114, 1985
Canadian Public Health Association. Employee fitness project 1978, Canadian Public Health Association, Ottawa, 1979
Carmean G. Police management considerations of physical capacity screening. Police Chief 51(1): 42–43, 1984
Cathcart EO, Richardson DT, Campbell W. Maximum load to be carried by the soldier. Journal of the Royal Army Medical Corps 40: 12–24, and 41: 161–178, 1923
Collingwood TR. A comparison of policemen versus offender fitness. Monograph series on Fitness, National Consortium for Education I(6), 1974 cited by Bard et al. (1985)
Collingwood TR, Kohl HW, Hollingsworth M. Construct validation of physical performance selection tests for public safety officers. Abstract. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 21: S6, 1989
Cooper KH. A means of assessing maximal oxygen intake. Journal of the American Medical Association 203: 201–204, 1968
Cumming GR. Correlation of physical performance with laboratory measurements of fitness. In Shephard RJ (Ed.) Frontiers of fitness, pp. 265–279, CC Thomas, Springfield, I11, 1971
Daniels WL, Vogel JA, Kowal DA. Fitness levels and response to training of women in US army. In Allen C (Ed.) Proceedings of the First RSG4 Physical Fitness Symposium with Special Reference to Military Populations, pp. 184–188, Defence and Civil Institute of Environmental Medicine, Downsview, Ont., 1978
Danielson R, Danielson K. Exercise program effects on productivity of forestry firefighters, pp. 1–20, Ontario Ministry of Tourism and Recreation, Toronto, 1982
Davis PO, Dotson CO. Job performance testing: an alternative to age discrimination. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 19: 179–185, 1987
Davis PO, Dotson CO. Predictors of wall-scaling success in law enforcement personnel. Abstract. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 21: S6, 1989
Davis PO, Dotson CO, Santa-Maria DL. Relationship between simulated firefighting tasks and physical performance measures. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 14: 65–71, 1982
Davis J, Wilmore JH. Validation of a bench-stepping test for cardiorespiratory fitness classification of emergency service personnel. Journal of Occupational Medicine 21: 671–673, 1979
Dibbs E, Thomas HE, Weiss ST, Sparrow D. Firefighting and coronary heart disease. Circulation 65: 943–946, 1982
Drake V, Jones G, Brown JR, Shephard RJ. Fitness performance tests and their relationship to maximum oxygen intake. Canadian Medical Association Journal 99: 844–848, 1968
Drinkwater BL. Women and exercise: physiological aspects. Exercise and Sport Science Reviews 12: 21–52, 1984
Dubik JM, Fullerton TD. Soldier overloading in Grenada. Military Review 67: 38–47, 1987
Dublin LT, Vane RJ. Occupational mortality experience of insured wage earners. Monthly Labour Review 64: 1003–1018, 1947
Eclache JP, Quard S, Beaury J, Flandrois R. L’aptitude physique des jeunes francais de 20 ans. In Allen C (Ed.) Proceedings of First RSG4 Physical Fitness Symposium with Special Reference to Military Populations, pp. 59–67, Defence and Civil Institute of Environmental Medicine, Downsview, Ont., 1978
Farenholtz DW, Rhodes EC, Bonheau J. Validation of a police officers physical abilities test. Abstract. Canadian Journal of Sport Sciences 14: 11OP, 1989
Federal Register. Uniform guidelines on employee selection procedures. Federal Register 43: 38290–38315, 1978
Fried T, Shephard RJ. Deterioration and restoration of physical fitness after training. Canadian Medical Association Journal 100: 831–837, 1969
Fried T, Shephard RJ. Assessment of lower extremity training programme. Canadian Association Medical Journal 103: 260–266, 1970
Gendron R. Révision des normes d’embauche des agents et cadets de la Sûreté du Québec et des Corps de police municipaux. Rapport d’etape, Annex II, 1984. Cited in Bardsley et al. 1985
Gilbreth FB, Gilbreth LM. Motion study for the handicapped, Routledge, London, 1920
Gilson JC, Hugh-Jones P. Lung function in coalworkers’ pneumoconiosis. MRC Special Report Series 290: pp. 1–266, Her Majesty’s Stationery Office, London, 1955
Gruber GP, Hörne DG, Johnson HA, MacNeil DD. Physical fitness standards for the Calgary police service. Police Service Project 83, Report 3, Calgary 1983. Cited by Bard et al. 1985
Guralnik L. Mortality by occupation and cause of death. US Public Health Service, Vital Statistics Report 53(3), 1963
Hilyer JC, Brown KC, Sirles AT, Peoples L. A flexibility intervention to reduce the incidence and severity of joint injuries among municipal firefighters. Journal of Occupational Medicine 32: 631–637, 1990
Hughes AL, Goldman RF. Energy cost of hard work. Journal of Applied Physiology 29: 570–572, 1970
Humphrey SJE, Wolff HS. The OXYLOG. Journal of Physiology 267: 12P, 1977
International Association of Chiefs of Police. Police Personnel Selection Survey, pp. 1–18, Washington DC, 1971
Jamnik V, Gledhill N. Characteristics of the physical demands of firefighting. Abstract. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 21: S6, 1989
Johnston JH, Hope DP. Physical fitness assessment and education plan. Police Chief 48(1): 16–17, 1981
Kasch FW, Wallace JP, Van Camp SP. Effects of 18 years of endurance exercise on the physical work capacity of older men. Journal of Cardiac Rehabilitation 5: 308–312, 1985
Kasch FW, Boyer J, Van Camp SP, Verity LS, Wallace JP. The effect of physical activity and inactivity on aerobic power in older men (a longitudinal study). Physician and Sportsmedicine 18(4): 73–83, 1990
Klingzing JPF. The physical fitness status of police officers. Journal of Sports Medicine and Physical Fitness 20: 291–296, 1980
Knapik J, Daniels W, Murphy M, Fitzgerald P, Drews F, et al. Physiological factors in infantry operations. European Journal of Applied Physiology 60: 233–238, 1990
Kofranyi E, Michaelis HF. Ein tragbarer Apparat zur Bestimmung des Gasstoffwechsels. Arbeitsphysiologie 11: 148–150, 1949
Kuorinka I, Korhonen O. Firefighters reaction to an alarm: an ECG and heart rate study. Journal of Occupational Medicine 23: 762–766, 1981
Leatt P, Hattin H, West C, Shephard RJ. Seven year follow-up of employee fitness program. Canadian Journal of Public Health 79: 20–25, 1988
Leon A. Introduction to the symposium: age as a criterion for work performance — chronologic versus physiologic age. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 19: 157–158, 1987a
Leon A. Age and other predictors of coronary heart disease. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 19: 159–167, 1987b
Lilley JH, Grennberg SF. Physical training program addresses long term attitude toward fitness. Police Chief 51(1): 47–49, 1984
Mastromatteo E. Mortality in city firemen: a review. Archives of Industrial Health 20: 1–7, 1959a
Mastromatteo E. Mortality in city firemen, II. A study of mortality in firemen of a city fire department. Archives of Industrial Health 20: 227–233, 1959b
McCaig RH, Gooderson CY. Ergonomic and physiological aspects of military operations in a wet climate. Ergonomics 29: 849–857, 1986
McHenry PL, Fisch C, Jordan JW, Corya BR. Cardiac arrhythmias observed during maximal treadmill testing in clinically normal men. American Journal of Cardiology 29: 331–336, 1972
Métivier G, Gauthier R, Gaboriault R. Test d’evaluation pour la sélection des policiers. Journal du Collège Canadien de Police 6: 1–12, 1982
Moores B. A comparison of work-load using physiological and time-study assessments. Ergonomics 13: 769–776, 1970
Morris WHM. Heart disease in farm workers. Canadian Medical Association Journal 96: 821–824, 1967
Mostardi RA, Porterfield JA, King S, Urycki S. Pre-employment screening and health management for safety forces — methods and techniques. Journal of Orthopaedic and Sports Physical Therapy 11: 398–401, 1990
Myerburg RJ, Davis JH. The medical ecology of public safety. I. Sudden death due to coronary heart disease. American Heart Journal 68: 586–595, 1964
Myles WS, Allen C. Current levels of fitness in the Canadian Forces. In Allen C (Ed.) Proceedings of the First RSG4 Physical Fitness Symposium with Special Reference to Military Populations, pp. 21–27, Defence and Civil Institute of Environmental Medicine, Downview, Ont., 1978
Myles WS, Toft RJ. A cycle ergometer test of maximal aerobic power. European Journal of Applied Physiology 49: 121–129, 1982
Nottrodt JW, Celentano EW. Use of validity measures in the selection of physical screening tests. In Attwood DA & McCann C (Eds) Proceedings of the 1984 International Conference on Occupational Ergonomics, pp. 433–437, Human Factors Association of Canada, Toronto, 1984
Oborne DJ. Ergonomics at work, 2nd ed., John Wiley, Chichester, 1987
Ontario Human Rights Code, Statutes of Ontario 1981, Chap. 53, Queen’s Printer, Toronto, 1981
Osborn GD. Validating physical agility tests. Police Chief 43: 43–45, 1976
Patton JF, Vogel JA, Kowal DM. Requirements for fitness according to job assignment in the US Army. In Allen C. Proceedings of the First RSG4 Physical Fitness Symposium with Special Reference to Military Populations, pp. 88–92, Defence and Civil Institute of Environmental Medicine, Downsview, Ont., 1978
Peters RK, Cady LD, Bischoff DP, Bernstein L, Pike MC. Physical fitness and subsequent myocardial infarction in healthy workers. Journal of the American Medical Association 249: 3052–3056, 1983
Phoon W-O, Ong CN, Foo SW, Plueksawan W. A cross-sectional study on the health of firefighters in Singapore. Japanese Journal of Industrial Health 25: 463–470, 1983
Pohndorf RH, Cathey RE. Fitness changes during a 14-week basic law enforcement training program. Federal Bureau of Investigation Law Enforcement Bulletin (Jan): 20–23, 1975
Pollock ML, Gettman LR, Ullman Meyer B. Analysis of physical fitness and coronary heart disease risk of Dallas area police officers. Journal of Occupational Medicine 20: 393–398, 1978
Radford EP, Levine MS. Occupational exposure to carbon monoxide in Baltimore firefighters. Journal of Occupational Medicine 18: 628–633, 1976
Reid EL, Morgan RW. Exercise prescription: a clinical trial. American Journal of Public Health 69: 591–595, 1979
Rogers CC. Firing up for fitness. Physician and Sportsmedicine 12(4): 134–142, 1984
Santa-Maria DL. Energy cost of wearing firefighting clothing and equipment. In Broekhoff J (Ed.) Physical education, sports and the sciences pp. 219–222, College of Physical Education and Recreation, Eugene, Oregon, 1976
Serra RC. Police officer physical efficiency battery. Police Chief 51(1): 45–51, 1984
Sharkey BJ. Functional versus chronological age. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 19: 174–178, 1987
Shephard RJ. Men at work: application of ergonomics to performance and design, CC Thomas, Springfield, ill., 1974
Shephard RJ. Endurance fitness, 2nd ed. University of Toronto Press, Toronto, 1977
Shephard RJ, Lavellée H. Physical fitness assessment: principles, practice and application, CC Thomas, Springfield, ill., 1978
Shephard RJ. Ischemic heart disease and exercise, Croom Helm, London, 1981
Shephard RJ. The daily work load of the postal carrier. Journal of Human Ergology 11: 157–164, 1982a
Shephard RJ. Physiology and biochemistry of exercise, Praeger, New York, 1982b
Shephard RJ. Equal opportunity for a geriatric labour force: some observations on marine surveying. Journal of Occupational Medicine 25: 211–214, 1983
Shephard RJ. Fitness and health in industry, Karger, Basel, 1986
Shephard RJ. Human rights and and the older worker: changes in work capacity with age. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 19: 168–173, 1987a
Shephard RJ. Physical activity and aging, 2nd ed., Croom Helm, London, 1987b
Shephard RJ. Cardiac patient and driving: the Ontario experience. Perspectives in Cardiology 6: 43–49, 1990a
Shephard RJ. Assessment of occupational fitness in the context of human rights legislation. Canadian Journal of Sport Sciences 15: 89–95, 1990b
Shephard RJ, Hughes EP, Hughes GL. Age restriction on bus driver selection. Journal of Human Ergology 17: 117–126, 1988
Siscovick DS, Laporte RE, Newman JL. The disease-specific benefits and risks of physical activity and exercise. Public Health Reports 100: 180–188, 1985
Snook S. The effects of age and physique on continuous work capacity. Human Factors 13: 467–479, 1971
Spitler DL, Jones G, Hawkins J, Dudka L. Body composition and physiological characteristics of law enforcement officers. British Journal of Sports Medicine 21: 154–157, 1987
Stamford BA, Weltman A, Moffatt RJ, Fulco C. Status of police officers with regard to selected cardio-respiratory and body composition fitness variables. Medicine and Science in Sports 10: 294–297, 1978
US National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health. Work practices guide for manual lifting, DHHS (NIOSH) Publication 81–122, Washington DC, 1981
Vogel JA, Patton JF. Evaluation of fitness in the US army. In Allen C (Ed.) Proceedings of the First RSG4 Physical Fitness Symposium with Special Reference to Military Populations pp. 30–35, Defence and Civil Institute of Environmental Medicine, Downsview, Ont., 1978
Vogel JA, Patton JF, Mello RP, Daniels WL. An analysis of aerobic capacity in a large United States population. Journal of Applied Physiology 60: 494–500, 1986
Vuori I, Suurnakki L, Suurnakki T. Risk of sudden cardiovascular death (SCVD) in exercise. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 14: 114–115, 1982
Weiss S, Hagan RD, Kaman RL, Taylor SC, Woodworth RM. Age-related changes of coronary heart disease risk factors in municipal firefighters. Abstract. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 16: 195, 1984
Wilkie RC. Job related physical tests for patrol officers. Police Chief 41(5): 42–47, 1974
Wilmore JH, Davis JA. Validation of a physical abilities field test for the selection of state traffic officers. Journal of Occupational Medicine 21: 33–40, 1979
Wilson D, Bracci R. The police agility test. Law and Order 30: 36–42, 1982
Wolitz L. An analysis of the labor market for policemen. Doctoral dissertation, pp. 18–19, University of California, Berkeley, Ca, 1974
Wright GR, Jewczyk S, Onrot J, Tomlinson P, Shephard RJ. Carbon monoxide in the urban atmosphere: hazards to the pedestrian and the street worker. Archives of Environmental Health 30: 123–129, 1975
Wright GR, Sidney KH, Shephard RJ. Variance of direct and indirect measurements of aerobic power. Journal of Sports Medicine and Physical Fitness 18: 33–42, 1978
Wyndham CH. An examination of the methods of classification of African labourers for manual work. South African Medical Journal 40: 275–278, 1966
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Shephard, R.J. Occupational Demand and Human Rights. Sports Med 12, 94–109 (1991). https://doi.org/10.2165/00007256-199112020-00003
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2165/00007256-199112020-00003