Use of multistage models to infer stage affected by carcinogenic exposure: Example of lung cancer and cigarette smoking

https://doi.org/10.1016/S0021-9681(87)80020-6Get rights and content

Abstract

Statistical methods based on the Armitage-Doll mathematical model of the carcinogenic process are presented for analyzing epidemiologic case-control studies of cancer. These methods are proposed to provide inferences regarding the stage(s) in the cancer process at which the exposure of interest acts. An example of these methods is given which shows evidence that carcinogens in cigarette smoke appear to affect the transition rates for two separate stages in the development of lung cancer, and the relative magnitudes of these effects are estimated. The data for this analysis came from a European multi-center case-control study of lung cancer.

The results of the analysis show that: (1) the relative risk of lung cancer among continuing smokers compared to nonsmokers of the same age decreases as the age started smoking increases, while the rate of smoking stays fixed, a result which indicates a carcinogenic effect on an early stage in the process; and (2) the relative risk among ex-smokers compared to continuing smokers having the same duration and rate of smoking decreases with time since smoking stopped, a result which indicates a carcinogenic effect on a late stage in the process. Both results are shown to be best described by the hypothesis that cigarette smoking affects two stages. The estimated relative magnitudes of cigarettes' carcinogenic effects on the two stages indicate that the largest proportion of the total lifetime lung cancer risk among continuing smokers is due to its late stage effect, and that the proportion of risk due to causes other than smoking varies from 23% among men smoking 1–10 cigarettes per day to 6% among those smoking greater than 30 cigarettes per day. These findings imply that preventive measures directed toward inducing smokers to stop would have a potentially substantial payoff in reducing future lung cancer mortality.

References (15)

  • HG Muller

    Radiation damage to the genetic material

    Sci Prog

    (1951)
  • CO Nordling

    A new theory of the cancer inducing mechanism

    Br J Cancer

    (1953)
  • F Stenback et al.

    Initiation and promotion at different ages and doses in 2200 mice. I. Methods, and the apparent persistence of initiated cells

    Br J Cancer

    (1981)
  • F Stenback et al.

    Initiation and promotion at different ages and doses in 2200 mice. II. Decrease in promotion by TPA with aging

    Br J Cancer

    (1981)
  • F Stenback et al.

    Initiation and promotion at different ages and doses. III. Linear extrapolation from high doses may underestimate low-dose tumour risks

    Br J Cancer

    (1981)
  • AS Whittemore

    The age distribution of human cancer for carcinogenic exposures of varying intensity

    Am J Epidemiol

    (1977)
  • NE Day et al.

    Multistage models and primary prevention of cancer

    J Natl Cancer Inst

    (1980)
There are more references available in the full text version of this article.

Cited by (58)

  • How rapidly does the excess risk of lung cancer decline following quitting smoking? A quantitative review using the negative exponential model

    2013, Regulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology
    Citation Excerpt :

    Thus, if the RR is, for example, 15 for current smokers, so that the excess risk is 14, our interest is in estimating the time after quitting at which the excess risk is 7 (or the RR is 8), and in estimating the excess risk (and RR) at other time points since quitting. In Additional file 1: “Multistage” (downloadable from http://www.pnlee.co.uk/downloads/ieslc3/LC_Quitting_Paper_AdditionalFiles.htm), we demonstrate that the predictions of the decline in excess risk following quitting are quite similar to those of the multistage model, often used for detailed analysis of individual subject data on smoking and lung cancer (Brown and Chu, 1987; Doll and Peto, 1978; Freedman and Navidi, 1990; Lee, 1995; Whittemore, 1988), and that estimates of H depend little on the assumed magnitude of the excess risk in current smokers. Although, for a given current smoker RR, estimates of H tend to be somewhat greater for populations with a longer duration of smoking, the negative exponential model appears a useful simple method to summarize published epidemiological data.

  • Application of a two-stage Syrian hamster embryo cell transformation assay to cigarette smoke particulate matter

    2005, Mutation Research - Fundamental and Molecular Mechanisms of Mutagenesis
  • A flexible modeling approach to estimating the component effects of smoking behavior on lung cancer

    2004, Journal of Clinical Epidemiology
    Citation Excerpt :

    The independent effect of early age at started smoking on lung cancer risk remains controversial. Previous studies [5,16,25,28,29,33–35] reported an effect of age started, although some found no effect [36–39]. Most of these studies failed to account for confounding by duration, which is naturally correlated with age started or by years since quitting.

  • Cigarette smoking and the risk of invasive epithelial ovarian cancer in a prospective cohort study

    2003, European Journal of Cancer
    Citation Excerpt :

    In contrast, we did not observe a clear trend for mucinous tumours, but the number of cases of these tumours in our data-set was low. If a carcinogen acts early in cancer development, its association with cancer risk will be characterised by a relatively long period of time between the causal action of cigarette smoking and diagnosis, or that smoking acts at different stages in the development of the respective tumour types [24,25]. In contrast, the association with risk of a carcinogen that acts late in cancer development would tend towards the null with increasing years since cessation of exposure to that carcinogen [24,25].

  • Introduction to mathematical oncology

    2016, Introduction to Mathematical Oncology
View all citing articles on Scopus
View full text