Emergency Psychiatry in the General HospitalThe emergency room is the interface between community and health care institution. Whether through outreach or in-hospital service, the psychiatrist in the general hospital must have specialized skill and knowledge to attend the increased numbers of mentally ill, substance abusers, homeless individuals, and those with greater acuity and comorbidity than previously known. This Special Section will address those overlapping aspects of psychiatric, medicine, neurology, psychopharmacology, and psychology of essential interest to the psychiatrist who provides emergency consultation and treatment to the general hospital population.Stability of the diagnosis of first-episode psychosis made in an emergency setting☆
Introduction
The accuracy of psychiatric diagnosis has been increasingly considered during the last two decades. Indeed, the improvement of diagnostic classification and the development of structured interviews and rating instruments have greatly contributed to the enhancement of psychiatric diagnosis reliability and validity [1].
Several factors could interfere with the reliability of psychiatric diagnosis, including the diagnostic system selected, the evaluator's experience, patient's clinical characteristics and the situation or condition where the diagnostic interview is conducted [2].
The psychiatric diagnosis elaborated in an emergency service presents a series of shortcomings inherent in that setting. In general, time is limited, frequently without additional information from relatives, and in most of the cases, there is a need for immediate intervention [3], [4]. The examiner's observation can also be jeopardized because of the intrinsic aspects of the situation itself, such as demand pressures and need of agility in the forwardness of the cases. Furthermore, the severity of symptoms, which justify looking for an emergency service, could interfere in the quality of information given.
The role of emergency psychiatric services within a network of mental health services has been modified and amplified by changes in mental health policies, which encourage the use of alternative treatment setting in preference to exclusive psychiatric hospitalization [5]. Often emergency services receive patients in their first episode of mental disorder providing an entry point into the health system. The significance of a precise diagnosis is highlighted in a first episode of a mental disorder since all decisions about prognosis and therapeutic approach will be based on the initial diagnostic impression. Moreover, in clinical settings, there is a tendency to keep the first diagnosis made at time of the patient's initial admission into the mental health system, even with subsequent assessments by different clinicians [6].
Although the systematic use of operational diagnostic criteria could be an alternative to enhance the reliability of the psychiatric diagnosis made during an emergency assessment [7], good agreement between evaluators is not enough to assure the stability and the predictive validity of diagnosis in first-episode psychoses. For instance, three fourths of the patients that had received an initial diagnosis of schizophreniform disorder, according to DSM-IV [8], had their diagnosis modified after 6 months [9] and around one third of patients with the initial diagnosis of schizophreniform disorder received a follow-up diagnosis of affective disorder [10].
The aim of this study was to verify the accuracy of psychiatric diagnosis made in an emergency setting. For this purpose, we adopted two strategies. Firstly, we studied the stability of the diagnosis throughout the validity of the emergency diagnoses compared with longitudinal diagnosis made using the Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV (SCID) [11]. Secondly, we compared the profile of symptoms presented at the emergency assessment with the longitudinal diagnosis.
Section snippets
Patient population
The sample was composed of all patients admitted in the emergency psychiatric unit of the Clinical Hospital of Ribeirão Preto Medical School, São Paulo University, Brazil, during a period of 15 months in a first episode of a psychotic disorder. First-episode psychosis was defined by the presence of at least one of four symptom groups (delusion, hallucination, disorganized thoughts and disorganized or catatonic behavior) for up to 6 months. Patients with mental disorders due to general medical
Results
The average admission length of time in the emergency room was 2.16±1.82 days and the average follow-up length of time was 19.35±6.12 months.
Discussion
The initial diagnosis made in an emergency psychiatric context has shown poor agreement with the psychiatric diagnosis made through a gold standard pattern, that is, based on a longitudinal follow-up, taking into account all sources of information and applying structured interviews [19], confirming previous results concerning the difficulties of establishing reliable diagnosis in an emergency setting [3], [4]. However, the overall agreement of the discharge emergency diagnosis as compared to
Acknowledgments
The authors are very grateful to Professor Frederico G. Graeff for his comments and suggestions in the revision of the manuscript.
References (27)
- et al.
Five-year course of schizophreniform disorder
Psychiatry Res
(1995) The action of sedatives on brainstem oculomotor systems in man
Neuropharmacology
(1971)- et al.
Best-estimate versus structured interview-based diagnosis in first-admission psychosis
Compr Psychiatry
(1994) Adult outcomes of child- and adolescent-onset schizophrenia: diagnostic stability and predictive validity
Am J Psychiatry
(2000)- et al.
The Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-III-R (SCID) II. Multisite test–retest reliability
Arch Gen Psychiatry
(1992) - et al.
Comprehensive psychiatric emergency services
Psychiatr Q
(1990) - et al.
Factors in the quality of patient evaluations in general hospital psychiatric emergency services
Psychiatr Serv
(1995) The past and future of psychiatric emergency services in the US
Hosp Comm Psychiatry
(1994)- et al.
DSM-III in outreach emergency psychiatry
Int J Soc Psychiatry
(1990) - et al.
Interrater agreement among psychiatrist in psychiatric emergency assessments
Am J Psychiatry
(1998)
Diagnostical and statistical manual of mental disorder
DSM-III-R schizophreniform disorder with good prognostic features: a six-year follow-up
Can J Psychiatry
Structured clinical interview for DSM-IV axis I disorders—clinical version (SCID-CV)
Cited by (33)
Diagnostic validity of ICD-10 acute and transient psychotic disorders and DSM-5 brief psychotic disorder
2017, European PsychiatryCitation Excerpt :There were 10 studies on course and outcome of BPD with follow-up periods from 15 months to 10 years (Table 4). Over the short-term, four studies found that about two-thirds of cases with BPD do not develop another diagnosis and/or remitted rapidly [57,91–93], while others reported far higher transition rates mainly to schizophrenia and related disorders [56,94,95]. The latter findings compare favourably with longer-term follow-up studies showing that many cases with BPD evolved into more severe and persistent affective and/or psychotic disorders [59,60].
Predictive validity of a culturally informed diagnosis of schizophrenia: A 30month follow-up study with first episode psychosis
2011, Schizophrenia ResearchCitation Excerpt :Our finding of a relatively low diagnostic stability of schizophrenia using the standard CASH in Moroccans is consistent with the study by Veen et al. (2004) reporting diagnostic shifts from or to schizophrenia after 30 months in 32% of the Moroccan and 60% of the Turkish immigrants in The Netherlands, as compared to shifts in only 17% among native Dutch patients. Our findings regarding the low diagnostic stability in Moroccans using the standard CASH are also in contrast with the reported relative high stability of a diagnosis of schizophrenia in different studies in non-ethnic populations (Rufino et al., 2005; Schimmelmann et al., 2005; Baca-Garcia et al., 2007). However, using the adapted version of the CASH we found a diagnostic stability of 85% for native Dutch and of 81% for Moroccan immigrants, percentages that are consistent with older studies reported diagnostic stability of 83% among ethnic minorities (Amin et al., 1999; Goater et al., 1999; Harrison et al., 1999).
Does having more admission diagnoses increase the accuracy rate for elderly patients in the emergency department?
2010, International Journal of GerontologyCOOP/WONCA charts as a screen for mental disorders in primary care
2011, Annals of Family MedicineCitation Excerpt :When patients agreed to participate, community health workers and nurse assistants administered the SRQ-20, the WHO-5, and the COOP/WONCA Charts in a random order during the routine care of these patients. Within a week, a psychiatrist who was trained in the use of the SCID42–44 and had participated in previous studies in which it was used administered the interview in person, remaining blinded to the patients' results on the previous questionnaires. Patients who were determined to have a mental disorder received adequate care in the primary care facilities.
Enhancing identification of nonaffective psychosis in register-based studies
2024, SchizophreniaThe predictive validity and outcome of ICD-10 and DSM-5 short-lived psychotic disorders: a review and meta-analysis
2022, European Archives of Psychiatry and Clinical Neuroscience
- ☆
This work was done at the Department of Neurology, Psychiatry and Medical Psychology, Clinical Hospital of the School of Ribeirão Preto, São Paulo University, Brazil.