Elsevier

Crop Protection

Volume 64, October 2014, Pages 78-87
Crop Protection

Effects of fertiliser applications on survival and recruitment of the apple snail, Pomacea canaliculata (Lamarck)

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cropro.2014.05.020Get rights and content

Highlights

  • Through laboratory bioassays, we demonstrate that fertilisers have toxic effects on apple snails.

  • Mortality of adults was higher than juveniles and the toxicity of fertilizer increased with concentration.

  • Draining experimental arenas decreased snail mortality, indicating that soil reduces the toxic effects of fertilisers.

  • Possibilities for managing apple snails by altering fertiliser and flooding regimes are discussed.

  • We note that the potential negative effects of fertilisers on beneficial aquatic organisms require further attention.

Abstract

Since its introduction to Asia in the 1980s, the golden apple snail, Pomacea canaliculata (Lamarck), has represented a major constraint to the profitability of rice (Oryza sativa L.) farming by damaging rice seedlings during crop establishment. This study describes a series of experiments designed to determine the effects of nitrogenous fertilisers on snail fitness. We examined the possibility of a two-phase model of snail response to nitrogen, whereby fertilisers initially increase snail mortality through toxicity, but once assimilated into the rice ecosystem, eventually favour snail reproduction and survival. In experimental arenas, fertiliser had lethal effects: Complete fertiliser (14:14:14), urea, ammonium sulphate and organic fertilisers were associated with snail mortality, generally affecting adult snails more than juvenile snails, and with greater effects when applied to saturated soil that was subsequently flooded (as opposed to direct application to flooded soil). Snail mortality was found to decline considerably when snails were added to arenas one day after fertiliser application – this occurred in arenas with soil and water, but not in arenas with water only, suggesting that soil can reduce the toxic effects of fertilisers. In a field experiment, snail numbers declined in both fertilised and non-fertilised plots at the time of crop establishment. Numbers increased in all plots after rice tillering, with significantly more recruitment in plots with high nitrogen. Although the responses were generally weak in the field experiment, they did support the two-phase model. The consequences of fertiliser applications for snail management and ecosystem health are discussed.

Introduction

Pressures to increase food production to meet a growing world population and global food demands have led to an increasing use of chemical and organic inputs in agriculture; particularly nitrogen-based chemical fertilisers (FAO, 2008). The global demand for fertilisers is forecast to grow annually by 1.9%, from around 180 million tonnes in 2012 to around 194 million tonnes by 2016 (FAO, 2012). The use of nitrogen in agriculture has been linked to sustaining agricultural productivity (Stewart et al., 2005) and due to limitations in land availability, increasing fertiliser use on existing cropland is considered the most likely path farmers will take to increase production (FAO, 2008). However, high fertiliser use has a number of negative effects on ecosystems, such as altering plant community composition (Vitousek, 1994, Tilman and Lehman, 2001); increasing greenhouse gas (nitrous oxide) emissions; and contaminating groundwater, rivers, lakes and coastal waters, causing eutrophication (Zhu and Chen, 2002, Galloway et al., 2003).

Rice (Oryza sativa L.) is the only major cereal crop that is grown in standing water, thus the use of nitrogen fertilisers during rice production is likely to have major consequences for the aquatic flora and fauna that inhabit rice ecosystems. Many aquatic organisms are susceptible to water-borne chemicals, including fertilisers, and to changes in floodwater chemistry as a result of chemical inputs (Simpson et al., 1994a). However, few studies have examined the effects of nitrogen fertilisers on aquatic organisms in rice ecosystems. Aquatic biomass, in particular green algae, followed by populations of ostracods and chironomid as well as mosquito larvae have been shown to increase following inorganic nitrogen fertiliser applications in rice fields (Simpson et al., 1994a, Simpson et al., 1994b, Sunish and Reuben, 2002, Mutero et al., 2004). Simpson et al. (1994a) indicated that benthic molluscan communities change over the course of rice crop development and that this may be associated with changing water chemistry resulting from fertiliser use. Furthermore, De La Cruz et al. (2001) demonstrated that inorganic nitrogen fertilisers cause mortality of golden apple snails (Pomacea canaliculata [Lamarck]) within a few days of application during land preparation for rice crops.

Applications of nitrogen fertilisers from land preparation to within 14 days of crop establishment, followed by one to two further applications during the rice cropping season, are common practices in rice fields in South-East Asia (Buresh et al., 2007, Palis et al., 2007). The addition of nitrogen to the rice crop initially increases photosynthesis levels and pH and reduces concentrations of dissolved oxygen in the floodwater (Mikkelsen et al., 1978; Simpson et al., 1994a). However, assimilation of nitrogen also increases plant vigor, which benefits the crop, and increases primary productivity in the aquatic environment. This includes new growth of macrophytes and algae. Increasing plant and algal productivity can also benefit aquatic herbivores by increasing food quality and availability (Horgan et al., 2014). For aquatic herbivores, nitrogen fertilisers can therefore have both negative effects through toxicity and by altering the physio-chemical properties of the water, and positive effects by increasing the production (biomass) and quality of aquatic vegetation. Because of the dynamic nature of nitrogen in aquatic agro-ecosystems like rice, including sudden peaks during application and gradual declines post-application, interactions between nitrogen fertilisers and aquatic herbivores will be complex.

The present study examines the effects of fertilisers on the survival of P. canaliculata (Lamarck) in rice systems. P. canaliculata was introduced to much of Asia, including the Philippines, during the 1980s and is considered a major pest of rice during early crop stages, but a beneficial herbivore of weeds during later crop stages (Joshi et al., 2006, Hidaka et al., 2007, Horgan et al., 2014). Previous field experiments by De La Cruz et al. (2001) indicated a reduction in rice damage from snails (missing hills) as a result of basal applications of inorganic nitrogen fertilisers, but the effects of compound fertilisers on snail mortality were largely inconclusive. Furthermore, as plants are affected by fertiliser treatments, i.e., increased growth rates, increased tolerance, and an increased capacity to compensate for damage, field experiments that monitor missing hills or other forms of damage to the crop do not clearly differentiate between the direct effects of snails on the plants and indirect effects mediated through snail mortality. Therefore, we conducted a series of controlled experiments to examine the direct effects of fertilisers on snail mortality. Furthermore, we addressed a two-phase model of snail responses to fertilisers, whereby mortality is increased soon after nitrogen application, but where survival and fitness is eventually enhanced once the excess nitrogen has been assimilated into plant tissues, creating a more favorable environment for herbivore growth and development.

Section snippets

Study species

The P. canaliculata in our experiments were collected from lowland irrigated rice fields at the International Rice Research Institute Experimental Station (henceforth IRRI), Los Baños, Philippines (14°11′N, 121°15′E). Although several Pomacea species have been introduced into Asia (and the Philippines), recent molecular analysis has indicated P. canaliculata as the most common and perhaps only apple snail species present in the Philippines (Hayes et al., 2008). Using published primers (Cooke

Experiment 1 – fertiliser (type) induced mortality

Snail mortality at the end of the experiment was affected by fertiliser type/treatment and snail size (Table 1; Fig. 1), with the highest mortality occurring among adults. Post-hoc analysis revealed a significant difference (P < 0.05) in snail mortality between the control and all four fertiliser types, but no significant difference between the four fertilisers tested (Table 1; Fig. 1). There was higher adult mortality in pots that received either complete fertiliser or urea, but similar levels

Discussion

Our study has shown that nitrogen fertilisers have lethal effects on apple snails. This confirms findings by De La Cruz et al. (2001) that nitrogen pulses in irrigated rice ecosystems initially cause a decrease in P. canaliculata survival. In our laboratory studies we found 10–60% mortality of adult snails when confined in the presence of fertiliser and in the field we found larger declines in snail numbers (18%) in fertilised plots compared to control plots. Complete fertiliser and urea

Acknowledgements

We thank Alberto Naredo, Vincent Vertudes, Reyuel Quintana, Felisa Navor and Marol Recide for their assistance in sampling and measuring snails from the field and for monitoring the field experiment at IRRI farm. We thank two anonymous reviewers for helpful comments that improved the manuscript. This study was funded by the Global Rice Science Partnership (GRiSP). ANP was funded through a training and mobility grant from the Spanish Government and administered through Becas Faro (Faro Global).

References (37)

  • FAO

    Current World Fertiliser Trends and Outlook to 2016

    (2012)
  • J.N. Galloway et al.

    The nitrogen cascade

    BioScience

    (2003)
  • K.A. Hayes et al.

    Out of South America: multiple origins of non-native apple snails in Asia

    Divers. Distrib.

    (2008)
  • K. Hidaka et al.

    Impact evaluation of apple snail, Pomacea canaliculata (Lamarck) invasion on vascular plant flora in rice fields: some notes in a case of rice fields using conventional herbicides in Matsuyama City

    J. Rural Plan. Assoc.

    (2007)
  • R.C. Joshi et al.

    Role of golden apple snail in organic rice cultivation and weed management

  • D.S. Mikkelsen et al.

    Ammonia volatilization losses from flooded rice soils

    Soil. Sci. Soc. Am. J.

    (1978)
  • A. Mohammed

    Why are early life stages of aquatic organisms more sensitive to toxicants than adults?

  • E.J. Muturi et al.

    Laboratory studies on the effect of inorganic fertilisers on survival and development of immature Culex quinquefasciatus (Diptera: Culicidae)

    J. Vector Borne Dis.

    (2007)
  • Cited by (21)

    • Assessing the molluscicidal and biochemical activities of New-Fort®, an inorganic fertilizer against Theba pisana snails

      2023, Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology Part - C: Toxicology and Pharmacology
    • Effects of cropping systems and soil amendments on nematode community and its relationship with soil physicochemical properties in a paddy rice field in the Vietnamese Mekong Delta

      2020, Applied Soil Ecology
      Citation Excerpt :

      To maintain productivity, this cultivation system relies greatly on chemical fertilisers and pesticides (Tran et al., 2018). Overuse of inorganic fertilisers and pesticides causes serious environmental problems, such as water pollution (Stone and Hornberger, 2016), emission of greenhouse gases (Hoa et al., 2018), and increase in pests and diseases (Stuart et al., 2014). In addition, soil quality may decline (Cassman and Harwood, 1995).

    • On-farm assessment of different rice crop management practices in the Mekong Delta, Vietnam, using sustainability performance indicators

      2018, Field Crops Research
      Citation Excerpt :

      Overuse of inputs coupled with the rising production costs, which have outpaced nominal increases in producer paddy prices (Demont and Rutsaert, 2017), are making it increasingly difficult for smallholder rice farming in the MKD to remain economically and environmentally sustainable (Tu, 2015; Tong, 2017). As well as the associated economic and environmental costs, high seed, pesticide and nitrogen fertilizer rates can lead to favorable conditions for pests and diseases, excessive tiller production and lodging (Stuart et al., 2014; Wang et al., 2014; Horgan, 2017). To address such issues, the Vietnam Ministry of Agricultural and Rural Development in collaboration with the Irrigated Rice Research Consortium, launched the ‘Three Reductions, Three Gains’ (3R3G) integrated technology package in 2003, aiming to reduce seed rates, nitrogen fertilizer and insecticides, while maintaining yield, improving farmers’ health and protecting the environment (Rejesus et al., 2014).

    • Reduced efficiency of tropical flies (Diptera) in the decomposition of snail cadavers following molluscicide poisoning

      2018, Applied Soil Ecology
      Citation Excerpt :

      Apple snails are usually poisoned at the land preparation stage during flooding. However, cadavers will occur on dry and saturated soils during temporary draining of fields at each crop stage (Stuart et al., 2014). Fields varied in the rice varieties that were grown, nutrient inputs and their histories of pesticide applications.

    • Effectiveness of biopesticides in enhancing paddy growth for yield improvement

      2018, Sustainable Chemistry and Pharmacy
      Citation Excerpt :

      Fig. 4 described that the pest population at T1 started to decrease from 71 days of paddy cultivation due to repeated application of BV612EC contrary with T2 and C1, in which the pest population increased during observation on 71 and 101 days of paddy cultivation. The BPH and golden apple snail affected the tillers, while the insect such as grasshopper and bugs; and bacteria affected the leaves which led to increasing of dead leaves and tillers (Alexander et al., 2014; Ji Zhi-juan et al., 2016). Thus, the combination of the biopesticides application were more effective in reducing the pest infestation compared to only one type of biopesticide.

    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text