Theoretical constructions of and by the real

doi:10.1016/0361-3682(86)90037-1

Accounting, Organizations and Society

Volume 11, Issue 6, 1986, Pages 583-598

https://doi.org/10.1016/0361-3682(86)90037-1 Get rights and content

Abstract

In accounting, there are few accounts of theorising as a lived, social process. Governed by the restrictive tenets of hypothetico-deductivism, the manufacture of theory has been objectified into an activity which is divorced from the life-world of the researcher and the researched. This paper gives a reconstruction of theorising on a four year research project and argues that (a) Theory is grounded in prior assumptions about the constitution of the Real; (b) Theory constructs and is constructed by the Real; and (c) Theory choice is an inevitable part of the act of research.

References (84)

A.T. Berry et al.
Management Control in an Area of the National Coal Board: Rationales of Accounting Practices in a Public Enterprise
Accounting, Organizations and Society
(1985)
S. Burchell et al.
Accounting in its Social Context: Towards a History of Valued added in the United Kingdom
Accounting, Organizations and Society
(1985)
S. Burchell et al.
The Roles of Accounting in Organizations and Society
Accounting, Organizations and Society
(1980)
E.A. Lowe et al.
Simple Theories for Complex Processes: Accounting Policy and the Market for Myopia
Journal of Accounting and Public Policy
(Spring 1983)
D. Otley
The Contingency Theory of Management Accounting: Achievement and Prognosis
Accounting, Organizations and Society
(1980)
B. Rhodes
Occupational Orientations in Nursing in Britain
International Journal of Nursing Studies
(1980)
C. Tomkins et al.
The Everyday Accountant and Researching his Reality
Accounting, Organizations and Society
(1983)
C. Tomkins et al.
The Social Process of Research: Some Reflections on Developing A Multi-Disciplinary Accounting Project
Accounting, Organizations and Society
(1980)
A.R. Abdel-khalik et al.
Empirical Research in Accounting. A Methodological Viewpoint
(1979)
T. Adorno et al.
Dialect of Enlightenment
(1972)

Audit Commission for Local Authorities in England and Wales

Improving Economy, Efficiency and Effectiveness in Local Government in England and Wales

An Audit Commission Handbook

(1983)

I. Berlin

Does Political Theory Still Exist?

R.J. Bernstein

The Restructuring of Social and Political Theory

(1976)

R.J. Bernstein

Beyond Objectivism and Relativism

(1983)

H. Blumer

Symbolic Interactionism, Perspective and Method

(1969)

R.B. Braithwaite

Scientific Explanation

(1953)

P. Brownell

Participation in Budgeting, Locus of Control and Organizational Effectiveness

The Accounting Review

(October, 1981)

G. Burrell et al.

Sociological Paradigms and Organizational Analysis, Elements of the Sociology of Corporate Life

(1979)

K. Cameron

Domains of Organizational Effectiveness in Colleges and Universities

Academy of Management Journal

(1981)

R.J. Chambers

Accounting, Evaluation and Economic Behaviour

(1966)

C.W. Chow

The Demand for External Auditing: Size, Debt and Ownership Influences

The Accounting Review

(April 1982)

C. Christenson

The Methodology of Positive Accounting

The Accounting Review

(January 1983)

W.F. Chua

A Study of the Concept of Organizational Effectiveness with Empirical Reference to a Nurse Training System

(1982)

L. Colville

Reconstructing “behavioural accounting”

Accounting, Organizations and Society

(1981)

R.G. Corwin et al.

Some Concomitants of Bureaucratic and Professional Conceptions of the Nurse Role

Nursing Research

(1962)

A. Crawford

Cost Accounting, Work Control and the Development of Cost Accounting in Britain, 1914–1925

Paper prepared for the European Accounting Association

(April, 1984)

J.D. Douglas

Investigative Social Research

(1976)

M. Foucault

The Birth of the Clinic: an Archaeology of Medical Perception

(1973)

M. Foucault

Discipline and Punish: the Birth of the Prison

(1977)

M. Foucault

The History of Sexuality

E. Freidson

Profession of Medicine

(1970)

H.-G. Gadamer

H. Garfinkel

Studies in Ethnomethodology

(1967)

R. Geuss

The Idea of A Critical Theory, Habermas & the Frankfurt School

(1981)

B.G. Glaser et al.

The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research

(1967)

J.J. Glynn

Value for Money Auditing in the Public Sector

(1985)

E. Goffman

The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life

(1959)

N.J. Gonedes et al.

Capital Market Equilibrium, Information Production and Selecting Accounting Techniques: Theoretical Framework and Review of Empirical Work in Studies in Financial Accounting Objectives

The Journal of Accounting Research

(1974)

P.S. Goodman et al.

New Perspectives on Organizational Effectiveness

(1977)

J. Habermas

Theory and Practice, Theorie und Praxis (1971)

(1974)

J. Habermas

Knowledge and Human Interests

(1978)

Cited by (70)

Accounting for crime in the neoliberal world
2019, British Accounting Review
This paper examines the recent European public sector accounting reform which introduces controversial calculative practices for the recognition of criminal activities in national accounts. Namely, accounting for unlawful drug production and drug trafficking, and accounting for prostitution. Challenging the presumption of accounting neutrality, this study analyses this “accounting for crime” policy from a semantic and an epistemological view point as a cognitive system of creation of meaning and formation of knowledge. The analysis reveals the polyhedrality of neoliberalism, and the way it exerts its influence on society through its circuitous discursive process of social construction and transfiguration of reality which flows crosswise its multiple dimensions. At the macro level this policy operates as a ‘hegemonic project’: It bonds together the economic and political interests of different ‘historical blocs’, making the implementation of these practices a matter of ‘common sense’. At the micro level this policy functions as an ‘apparatus of governmentality’: It encapsulates the cognition of crime within a panoptic logic of economic rationality, transforming its outcome into a contributory value of a country's prosperity. In this context, this study outlines the centrality of accounting practice as a pivotal tool of the neoliberal ideology: It permits extending the realm of calculative methodologies to the commodification of human weaknesses, addictions, and sexuality, in a rational process of accounting to balance the supply and demand of sex and drugs, between prostitutes and clients, pushers and addicts.
Microaccountability and biopolitics: Microfinance in a Sri Lankan village
2019, Accounting, Organizations and Society
Citation Excerpt :
The additional interviews were conducted in 2016 and 2017. The above data collection efforts conformed to our research methodology, which drew upon a post-positivistic, reflexive epistemology (Alvesson & Sköldberg, 2009; Chua, 1986; Tomkins & Groves, 1983). We wanted to allow the subjective constructions of actors' views to be seen, and to allow inductive inferences of meanings to be made from the participants' own subjective and qualitative interpretations of their experience, in the light of our theoretical framework.
Based on a micro-level study of microfinance, this paper explores how basic accounting technologies and interpersonal accountability are used to make lending to poor village women profitable and low risk. We argue that “microaccountability,” our term for the structuring and formalization of convivial relationships into a capillary system of accountability, must be recognized as a central tool of social governance under neoliberalism. Our field research in Sri Lanka allows us to analyse how microaccountability is employed by for-profit banks to create from poor villagers a legion of bankable individual entrepreneurs, trained to invigilate each other's savings and credit behaviours. Using the theoretical lens of biopolitics, we show how microaccountability enables the extension of the finance industry into untapped sectors of the global population.
Accounting for crime in the US: Race, class and the spectacle of fear
2018, Critical Perspectives on Accounting
Citation Excerpt :
We also appeal to the emerging literature on shadow accounting and counter-accounts as a potential for future research and expanding visibility and social justice. Deliberating accounting in the sphere of crime and prisons, we follow a broad view of accounting practices such as audits, techniques, accounting logic and accountabilities, all imbued in creating meaning (Broadbent & Laughlin, 2013; Chapman et al., 2009; Chua, 1986; Dillard, 2017; Hopwood, 1987; Young, 2003). Accounting and numbers are infused with our predilections rendering them consequential, particularly on vulnerable populations as demonstrated by O’Neil that “math-powered applications … tended to punish the poor” (O’Neil, 2016, p. 3; elaborated upon in our concluding of Section 4).
Expanding critical accounting research on incarceration, this paper explores the consequences of neoliberal techniques and discourses intersecting with race and class in prison practices. As crime is socially constructed we concentrate on two intertwined terrains of struggle: first, the privatization of prisons and second, the “creation of the other”. Controversies over privatization are pervasive and we illustrate that a raison d’être of privatization – minimizing costs – is discredited and distorted. The devastating consequences of privatization further the divide in communities between those privileged and those vulnerable based on race and class. Through this neoliberal process of privatization and racialization of crime there is a creation of the other – a powerful and hostile discourse. We are troubled that a crime-control dynamic mythologizing and fearing the other has become so institutionalized that domination and injustices are normalized. Accounting contributes to these processes with techniques claiming objectivity, but with undeniable moral impacts. Illustrating these dynamics, we review policies surrounding a four-decade “war on drugs” in the US, appraised as an assault on marginalized (poor) populations. Contrasting to white collar-financial crimes we make visible how incarceration displaces certain groups from significant entitlements of citizenship. While statistics indisputably reveal prejudicial treatment, this is only part of the story. Numbers reduce phenomena to simplistic representations erasing humane meaning and obscuring social dimensions of discrimination and power permeating incarceration practice. Acknowledging these complexities, one aim is developing counter accounts to promote new visibilities to advance social justice.
A socialist market economy with Chinese characteristics: The accounting annual report of China Mobile
2017, Accounting Forum
Since the economic opening reform in the 1970s, China has undergone significant ideological change that has shifted the country’s focus from a planned economy to a market economy. The co-existence of a market economy with a socialist political regime offers a unique opportunity to explore the role of accounting in contemporary China. Using critical discourse analysis, we have analysed the production, distribution, and consumption of a leading Chinese SOE’s annual report that has a dual readership (i.e. Chinese and Western). We demonstrate that accounting reflects and helps naturalise the competing ideologies of a global market economy with strong government control.
Goffman's theory of frames and situated meaning-making in performance reviews. The case of a category management approach in the French retail sector
2017, Accounting, Organizations and Society
Citation Excerpt :
Our methodology also requires the inter-organizational events witnessed first-hand to be related to the broader institutional, historical, economic and interpersonal context in which they are embedded. Theorizing is thus viewed as “a lived, social process of sense-making” (Chua, 1986, p. 585) and is deeply grounded in the logics of the field's specific modus operandi (Ahrens & Chapman, 2006). Such exploratory research involving long-lasting immersion is not easy to sustain over time (Ahrens & Chapman, 2006; Suddaby, 2006).
Following the scholarly view of accounting as a social practice, this research explores the role of accounting in managers' ongoing efforts to effectively understand and influence organizational change in the course of a series of review meetings. To study the role of accounting in meaning-making processes - i.e. collective processes of ascribing meanings to experienced social situations - we develop a processual and semiotic view of Goffman's theory of frames. Central to the paper's argument is the concept of framing, defined as an ongoing social process of context production in an unfolding situation. In this perspective, accounting numbers are viewed as signs mediating situated interactions. This theoretical framework is applied to complex situations of negotiation between a retailer and sixteen suppliers, under a category management approach. The crucial finding of our research, illustrated empirically, is the plurality of competing frames and the occurrence of frame-shifting episodes, the process by which one frame is suddenly replaced with another frame that has a deeply different way of narrating the situation: this process is triggered by a specific event, and the frame shift has potentially significant effects on practices. The case study highlights the mediating role of frames, and the plasticity and vulnerability of framing processes. It exemplifies the dual nature of accounting numbers in situated meaning-making: they can be viewed simultaneously as generic models - parts of social frames - and singular events - parts of the current situation. Due to this dual nature, they can act as mediators between a singular situation and socially-constructed, generic classes of meaning.
Accounting for climate change and the self-regulation of carbon disclosures
2011, Accounting Forum
Citation Excerpt :
Among the emerging professional responses, the accounting profession sees itself as integral to the development of disclosure practices that can assist broader public decision making (ACCA Global, 2008; CPA Australia, 2008; KPMG, 2008). There is an ample financial accounting literature that discusses the nature of accounting information as well as its usefulness and its limitations (Chua, 1986; Gaffikin, 2008; Hopwood, 2000). As accounting is a social practice, its purpose and emphasis has changed over time (Carmona & Ezzamel, 2007; Jones & Oldroyd, 2009).
Adopting a form of “critical dialogic engagement” (Bebbington et al., 2007), this paper explores how dominant environmental discourses can influence and shape carbon disclosure regulation. Carbon-related disclosures have increased significantly in the last five years, and many of these disclosures remain voluntary. This paper considers both the construction of self-regulated carbon disclosure practices and the role that this kind of carbon information may have in climate change-related decision making. Our preliminary findings indicate that the methodological diversity underpinning carbon disclosures may inhibit the usefulness of climate change-related data. To explore these issues, this paper focuses on the Carbon Disclosure Project (CDP) and the use of the Greenhouse Gas (GHG) Protocol as a reporting model within it.

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text

Theoretical constructions of and by the real

Abstract

Accounting, Organizations and Society

Accounting, Organizations and Society

Accounting, Organizations and Society

Journal of Accounting and Public Policy

Accounting, Organizations and Society

International Journal of Nursing Studies

Accounting, Organizations and Society

Accounting, Organizations and Society

Empirical Research in Accounting. A Methodological Viewpoint

Dialect of Enlightenment

Improving Economy, Efficiency and Effectiveness in Local Government in England and Wales

An Audit Commission Handbook

Does Political Theory Still Exist?

The Restructuring of Social and Political Theory

Beyond Objectivism and Relativism

Symbolic Interactionism, Perspective and Method

Scientific Explanation

Participation in Budgeting, Locus of Control and Organizational Effectiveness

The Accounting Review

Sociological Paradigms and Organizational Analysis, Elements of the Sociology of Corporate Life

Domains of Organizational Effectiveness in Colleges and Universities

Academy of Management Journal

Accounting, Evaluation and Economic Behaviour

The Demand for External Auditing: Size, Debt and Ownership Influences

The Accounting Review

The Methodology of Positive Accounting

The Accounting Review

A Study of the Concept of Organizational Effectiveness with Empirical Reference to a Nurse Training System

Reconstructing “behavioural accounting”

Accounting, Organizations and Society

Some Concomitants of Bureaucratic and Professional Conceptions of the Nurse Role

Nursing Research

Cost Accounting, Work Control and the Development of Cost Accounting in Britain, 1914–1925

Paper prepared for the European Accounting Association

Investigative Social Research

The Birth of the Clinic: an Archaeology of Medical Perception

Discipline and Punish: the Birth of the Prison

The History of Sexuality

Profession of Medicine

Studies in Ethnomethodology

The Idea of A Critical Theory, Habermas & the Frankfurt School

The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research

Value for Money Auditing in the Public Sector

The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life

Capital Market Equilibrium, Information Production and Selecting Accounting Techniques: Theoretical Framework and Review of Empirical Work in Studies in Financial Accounting Objectives

The Journal of Accounting Research

New Perspectives on Organizational Effectiveness

Theory and Practice, Theorie und Praxis (1971)

Knowledge and Human Interests