Predictive value of proximal femoral bone densitometry in determining local orthogonal material properties

https://doi.org/10.1016/0021-9290(95)00133-6Get rights and content

Abstract

Models which are based on non-invasive bone measurements may in the future be able to successfully identify individual subjects at an increased risk for hip fracture; thus, we designed a study to determine the usefulness of dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) and quantitative computed tomography (QCT) in predicting the local material properties of human proximal femoral cancellous bone. There has been some disagreement in the scientific literature regarding appropriate predictive models for local material properties of cancellous bone. We sought to confirm that density-mechanical property relationships were consistent from subject to subject, and that three-dimensional QCT measurements were stronger predictors of mechanical properties than two-dimensional DXA results. Linear and power fit relationships between these densitometric measures and material properties were also examined to determine which were more appropriate. Bone cubes from specific regions of highly oriented trabeculae were analyzed separately to determine if cube orientation had an effect on mechanical properties independent of bone density. Ten pairs of ex vivo femurs (five male, five female; age 30–93, mean age 62) were prepared such that specific anatomic planes were visible radiographically. Both QCT and DXA measurements were made on all 20 femurs. Cancellous bone cubes were obtained proceeding along two distinct directions from the proximal end of each femur pair. Unexpectedly, the density-modulus relationships among these ten donors were found to be significantly different at p < 0.01 (83% of the tests were different at p < 0.0001). Density-strength regressions were also significantly different at p < 0.01, but this effect was not as consistent nor as statistically significant. In general, the QCT method did not produce predictions of local cancellous bone material properties superior to the DXA method. The linear and power fit models appeared to produce consistent results, with neither being obviously more advantageous. These density measurements explained at best 30–40% of the variance in modulus and 50–60% of the variance in ultimate stress. The orientation of cancellous cubes in the principal compressive trabeculae region was a significant contributor to mechanical properties (p = 0.0001) independent of bone density. This finding was not as dramatic in the femoral neck cancellous bone region.

References (22)

  • T.D. Brown et al.

    Mechanical property distributions in the cancellous bone of the human proximal femur

    Acta Orthop. Scand.

    (1980)
  • Cited by (31)

    • Hyperlipidemia affects multiscale structure and strength of murine femur

      2014, Journal of Biomechanics
      Citation Excerpt :

      We simulated 3-point bending and physiological loading (Fig. 1) producing strains in the same elastic range. For the 3-point bending, we calculated bone strength (defined as load at yield point) from load–displacement diagrams, as load at 90% of maximum load (Cody et al. 1996). We used the yield point to ensure that models’ load and displacement fell within the elastic range.

    • Comparison of mechanical and ultrasound elastic modulus of ovine tibial cortical bone

      2014, Medical Engineering and Physics
      Citation Excerpt :

      Much research has been done on relating various forms of density to the elastic modulus for human trabecular and cortical bone. From Carter and Hayes’ early work in 1977 [9] continuing through to recent papers by the likes of Cody et al. [10–12], Keyak et al. [13,14], Rho et al. [15–17] and Keller et al. [18] many elasticity–density relationships have been derived. All of which use either the ash density or the apparent density (ρapp) of the bone to determine the elastic modulus.

    • Experimental and histological investigations of the bone using two different Oscillating Osteotomy techniques compared with conventional rotary osteotomy

      2012, Annals of Anatomy
      Citation Excerpt :

      Some have reported no influence of drill rotation speed on temperature (Eriksson et al., 1984). It is recommended to drill in the speed range of 750–1250 rpm to take advantage of the decrease in the flow stress of the material at these speeds (Cody et al., 1996). In this study, the amount of heat generated within the bone underneath the osteotomy was investigated by considering the temperature differences of 2 temperature sensors.

    • Assessment of the bilateral asymmetry of human femurs based on physical, densitometric, and structural rigidity characteristics

      2010, Journal of Biomechanics
      Citation Excerpt :

      The contralateral limb is frequently used as an intra-subject control in research studies that assess changes in bone size, shape, density, and structural properties as a result of tumor, infection, fracture, asymmetric loading applications, or device implantation in one of the bones forming the pair. The gold standard of practice for measuring areal bone mineral density (BMD), osteoporosis screening, and fracture risk analysis is dual energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA), which scans a single hip for average BMD and bone mineral content (BMC) values (Adachi, 1996; Cody et al., 1996; Khunkitti et al., 2000; Bainbridge et al., 2004). Particularly relevant to the femur is the use of the contralateral femur as a template for robot controlled milling of the proximal femur in computer assisted total hip arthroplasty and computer assisted navigation, and preoperative planning systems (Bargar et al., 1998; DiGioia et al., 1998; Noble et al., 2003; Gonzalez Della Valle et al., 2005).

    • Predicting regional variations in trabecular bone mechanical properties within the human proximal tibia using MR imaging

      2008, Bone
      Citation Excerpt :

      Correlations between the amount of bone and Young's modulus, yield stress and ultimate stress have been determined using several other clinical and experimental imaging modalities. Low resolution imaging such as DEXA and QCT have resulted in coefficients of determination ranging from r2 = 0.22 to 0.74 [32–34] and r2 = 0.25 to 0.95 [33,35,36] respectively. The large variations in predictive power may be due to limitations of these imaging modalities, such as 2-dimensional measurements and variations in resolution.

    • Proximal femoral density and geometry measurements by quantitative computed tomography: Association with hip fracture

      2007, Bone
      Citation Excerpt :

      vQCT has become an increasingly important clinical research tool in analyzing the effect of age [22], drug therapy [3,4], mechanical unloading [16], and other phenomena on the density and geometry of bone. The density, geometry, and strength measures derived from vQCT images have been correlated to bone strength [6,8,14,17], thereby providing a theoretical link to fracture risk. However, there is little direct information regarding their association with hip fracture, the key clinical endpoint in osteoporosis.

    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text