Trabecular bone modulus and strength can depend on specimen geometry

doi:10.1016/0021-9290(93)90059-N

Journal of Biomechanics

Volume 26, Issue 8, August 1993, Pages 991-995, 997, 999-1000

https://doi.org/10.1016/0021-9290(93)90059-N Get rights and content

Abstract

We performed a series of uniaxial compression tests on wet bovine trabecular bone to compare both modulus and strength when measured using 2:1 aspect ratio (10 mm long, 5 mm diameter) cylinders (n = 30) and 5 mm cubes (n = 29). We also compared the correlation coefficients in the resulting modulus-density and strength-density regressions and the standard errors of the estimate. When comparing the mean values of modulus and strength for each group, the confounding variations in apparent density were accounted for with an analysis of covariance. The Fisher's Z transformation was used to compare the correlation coefficients statistically. Results from the analysis of covariance indicated that the modulus and strength of the cubes were higher by 36% (p < 0.01) and 18% (p < 0.05), respectively, with respect to the 2:1 cylinder values. The correlation coefficients in the modulus-density and strength-density regressions were not sensitive to the regression model (linear versus power law). However, correlation coefficients for both modulus-density and strength-density regressions were higher (p < 0.05) for the 2:1 cylinders (r = 0.90, modulus; r = 0.94, strength) than for the cubes (r = 0.57, modulus; r = 0.82, strength). In addition, the standard errors of the estimate in both modulus and strength were substantially lower for the 2:1 cylinders. These data indicate that both modulus and strength can depend on the specimen geometry when using conventional compression testing techniques. We conclude, therefore, that inter-study comparisons of modulus and strength may be invalid if these confounding effects of different specimen geometries are not addressed. Our data also indicate that density can better explain the observed variance in modulus and strength when 2:1 cylinders are used as opposed to cubes. Using this phenomenon as a rationale for choosing a standard specimen gometry, we recommend that the 2:1 cylinder be used as a standard specimen in studies designed to determine the effects of various treatments on the uniaxial compressive modulus and strength of trabecular bone.

References (14)

R.B. Ashman et al.
Anatomic variation of orthotropic elastic moduli of the proximal human tibia
J. Biomechanics
(1989)
T.P. Harrigan et al.
Limitations of the continuum assumption in cancellous bone
J. Biomechanics
(1988)
F. Linde et al.
Stiffness behaviour of trabecular bone specimens
J. Biomechanics
(1987)
F. Linde et al.
The effect of constraint on the mechanical behavior of trabecular bone specimens
J. Biomechanics
(1989)
F. Linde et al.
The effect of specimen geometry on the mechanical behavior of trabecular bone specimens
J. Biomechanics
(1992)
A. Odgaard et al.
Compressive axial strain distributions in cancellous bone specimens
J. Biomechanics
(1989)
A. Odgaard et al.
The underestimation of Young's modulus in compressive testing of cancellous bone specimens
J. Biomechanics
(1991)

There are more references available in the full text version of this article.

Cited by (133)

Compressive mechanical properties of dry antler cortical bone cylinders from different cervidae species
2024, Journal of the Mechanical Behavior of Biomedical Materials
Antlers are bony structures composed predominantly of primary osteons with unique mechanical properties due to their specific use by deer as weapon and shield. Antler bone fracture resistance has attracted prior scrutiny through experimental tests and theoretical models. To characterize antler mechanical properties, compression of cubes, or bending or tensioning of rectangular bars have been performed in the literature with variations in the protocols precluding comparisons of the data. Compression testing is a widely used experimental technique for determining the mechanical properties of specimens excised from cortical or cancellous regions of bone. However, the recommended geometry for compression tests is the cylinder, being more representative of the real performances of the material. The purpose of research was to report data for compressive strength and stiffness of antler cortical bone following current guidelines. Cylinders (n = 296) of dry antler cortical bone from either the main beam or the tines of Cervus elaphus, Rangifer tarandus, Cervus nippon and Dama dama were tested. This study highlights the fact that compression of antler cortical bone cylinders following current guidelines is feasible but not applicable in all species. Standardization of the testing protocols could help to compare data from the literature. This study also confirms that sample localization has no effect on the mechanical properties, that sample density has a significant impact and allows enriching the knowledge of the mechanical properties of dry antler cortical bone.
Biomechanical properties and clinical significance of cancellous bone in proximal femur: A review
2023, Injury
Trabecular bone plays an important role in the load-bearing capacity of the femur. Understanding the structural characteristics, biomechanics, and mechanical conduction of the trabecular bone is of great value in studying the mechanism of fractures and formulating surgical plans. The past decade has witnessed unprecedented progress in imaging, biomechanics and finite element analysis techniques, translating into a better understanding of trabecular bone. This article reviews the research progress achieved over the years regarding femoral trabecular bone, especially on factors influencing the strength of the proximal femoral cancellous bone and cancellous bone microfractures and provides a comprehensive overview of the latest findings on proximal femoral trabecular bone and their clinical significance.
The effects of force application on the compressive properties of femoral spongious bone
2023, Clinical Biomechanics
End artefacts play a major role in uniaxial compression tests with cancellous bone specimens. They lead to misinterpretation of mechanical parameters of bones due to uncontrolled introduction of bending moments into the free ends of trabeculae. This work aims to simplify current methods preventing end-artefacts and furthermore to investigate the influence of end artefacts on plateau stress.
176 cylindrical cancellous bone specimens were taken from human femoral condyles and tested in uniaxial compression. The specimens were divided into 2 groups (direct, end-cap) and compressive modulus, maximum stress, plateau stress, energy absorbtion as well as apparent density were evaluated. Density values are from separate specimens which are immediately adjacent to the mechanical specimen.
All mechanical parameters were significantly higher in the end-cap specimens than in the direct ones by about 30 – 40 %, thus reaching similar differences as the previous studies. Greatest differences between groups were determined for compressive modulus (45 %) and plateau stress (35 %). Energy absorbtion can be explained with great accuracy by plateau stress (P < 0.001; R² = 0.95). Among all parameters plateau stress can be best explained by apparent density using an exponential function (P < 0.001; R² = 0.38).
The end-cap method used here to prevent end artefacts showed variations consistent with the literature when compared to the direct method. Additionally it was shown that the way in which the force is applied to the specimen has a major influence on the failure progression behavior, which was characterized using the plateau stress.
Decellularised human bone allograft from different anatomical sites as a basis for functionally stratified repair material for bone defects
2022, Journal of the Mechanical Behavior of Biomedical Materials
Tissue engineered bone solutions aim to overcome the limitations of autologous and allogeneic grafts. Decellularised tissues are produced by washing cellular components from human or animal tissue to produce an immunologically safe and biocompatible scaffold, capable of integration following implantation. A decellularisation procedure utilising low concentration sodium dodecyl sulphate (0.1% w/v) was applied to trabecular bone from human femoral heads (FH) and tibial plateaus (TP). Biological (histology, DNA quantification), biomechanical (compression testing) and structural (μCT) comparisons were made between decellularised and unprocessed cellular tissue. Total DNA levels of decellularised FH and TP bone were below 50 ng·mg^-1 dry tissue weight and nuclear material was removed. No differences were found between cellular and decellularised bone, from each anatomical region, for all the biomechanical and structural parameters investigated. Differences were found between cellular FH and TP and between decellularised FH and TP. Decellularised FH had a higher ultimate compressive stress, Young's modulus and 0.2% proof stress than decellularised TP (p = 0.001, 0.002, 0.001, Mann Whitney U test, MWU). The mineral density of cellular and decellularised TP bone was significantly greater than cellular and decellularised FH bone respectively (cellular: p = 0.001, decellularised: p < 0.001, MWU). The bone volume fraction and trabecular thickness of cellular and decellularised FH bone were significantly greater than cellular and decellularised TP bone respectively (cellular: p = 0.001, 0.005; decellularised: p < 0.001, <0.001, MWU). Characterisation of decellularised trabecular bone from different anatomical regions offers the possibility of product stratification, allowing selection of biomechanical properties to match particular anatomical regions undergoing bone graft procedures.
Development of a crushable foam model for human trabecular bone
2021, Medical Engineering and Physics
Citation Excerpt :
It is present at the end of all long bones, such as the femur, tibia, and humerus, in the vertebral bodies of the spine, and in flat and irregular bones such as the pelvic bones [1]. Bone mineral density (BMD), age, sex, geometry, and anatomical site all have an influence on the material properties of this type of bone [2]. Mechanical properties of trabecular bone play an essential role in the biomechanical response of the whole skeleton.
Finite element (FE) simulations can be used to evaluate the mechanical behavior of human bone and allow for quantitative prediction of press-fit implant fixation. An adequate material model that captures post-yield behavior is essential for a realistic simulation. The crushable foam (CF) model is a constitutive model that has recently been proposed in this regard. Compression tests under uniaxial and confined loading conditions were performed on 59 human trabecular bone specimens. Three essential material parameters were obtained as a function of bone mineral density (BMD) to develop the isotropic CF model. The related constitutive rule was implemented in FE models and the results were compared to the experimental data. The CF model provided an accurate simulation of uniaxial compression tests and the post-yield behavior of the stress-strain was well-matched with the experimental results. The model was able to reproduce the confined response of the bone up to 15% of strain. This model allows for simulation of the mechanical behavior of the cellular structure of human bone and adequately predicts the post-yield response of trabecular bone, particularly under uniaxial loading conditions. The model can be further improved to simulate bone collapse due to local overload around orthopaedic implants.
Fast decellularization process using supercritical carbon dioxide for trabecular bone
2021, Journal of Supercritical Fluids
Decellularization is a process that consists on the removal of immunogenic cellular material from a tissue, so that it can be safely implanted as a functional and bioactive scaffold. Most decellularization protocols rely on the use of harsh chemicals and very long washing processes, leading to severe changes in the ultrastructure and loss of mechanical integrity. To tackle these challenges, supercritical carbon dioxide (scCO₂) is herein proposed as an alternative methodology for assisting decellularization of porcine trabecular bone tissue and is combined, for the first time, with Tri(n-butyl) phosphate (TnBP). Histological and DNA analysis revealed that both TnBP and scCO₂ were able to extract the DNA content from the scaffolds, being this effect more pronounced in treatments that used TnBP as a co-solvent. The combined protocol led to a decrease in DNA content by at least 90%, demonstrating the potential of this methodology and opening new possibilities for future optimizations.

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text

Trabecular bone modulus and strength can depend on specimen geometry

Abstract

J. Biomechanics

J. Biomechanics

J. Biomechanics

J. Biomechanics

J. Biomechanics

J. Biomechanics

J. Biomechanics