Abstract
Effects of catchment urbanization described as the urban stream syndrome generally result in an altered fish community with headwater stream fish communities particularly vulnerable to changes associated with urbanization. In this study, we considered how the fish community in a Central Texas headwater karst stream changed with catchment urbanization. Paleohistory and a narrative on urbanization within the upper San Marcos River were compiled and qualitatively related to historical fish changes from 1880 to 2011 to test predictions of the urban stream syndrome. Our predictions of decreases in native fish community and species abundances were largely unsupported despite 170 years of urbanization, specifically anthropogenic alterations to instream and catchment habitats, water quantity and water quality, stream morphology, and introduced species. Overall, the upper San Marcos River supports a persistent (>60 %) fish community through time with observed native species declines and extirpations not attributed solely to urbanization within the catchment. As such, we conclude that upper San Marcos River is largely an exception to the urban stream syndrome, which we attribute to two mechanisms; 1) paleohistory of the upper San Marcos River suggests a dynamic stream system with decreasing stream flow and increasing water temperatures since the last glacial maximum, and 2) water quantity of the San Marcos River is much greater than water quantity of other headwater streams used to assess urban stream syndrome. Nevertheless, the lower portion of the upper San Marcos River is indicative of an altered system, in both habitat and fish community, and represents a target area for rehabilitation.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Al-Rabab’Ah MA, Williams CG (2004) An ancient bottleneck in the lost pines of central Texas. Mol Ecol 13:1075–1084
Baker VR (1975) Flood hazards along the Balcones Escarpment in Central Texas: Alternative approaches to their recognition, mapping and management. Bureau of Economic Geology, University of Texas, Geological Circular 75–5
Bean PT, Bonner TH, Littrell BM (2007) Spatial and temporal patterns in the fish assemblage of the Blanco River, Texas. Tex J Sci 59:179–200
Bean PT, Jackson JT, McHenry DJ, Bonner TH, Forstner MRJ (2011) Rediscovery of headwater catfish, Ictalurus lupus (Ictaluridae) in a western gulf slope drainage. Southwest Nat 56:285–289
Bean PT, Lutz-Carrillo DJ, Bonner TH (2013) Range-wide survey of the introgressive status of Guadalupe bass Micropterus treculii: implications for conservation and management. T Am Fish Soc 142:681–689
Bednarek AT (2001) Undamming rivers: a review of the ecological impacts of dam removal. Environ Manag 27(6):803–814
Behen KPK (2013) Influence of connectivity and habitat on fishes of the upper San Marcos River. Master Thesis, Texas State University, San Marcos TX
Blum MD, Toomey RS III, Valastro S Jr (1994) Fluvial response to late quaternary climatic and environmental change, Edwards Plateau, Texas. Palaeogeogr Palaeoclimatol Palaeoecol 18:1–21
Bonner TH, Thomas C, Williams CS, Karges JP (2005) Temporal assessment of a West Texas stream fish assemblage. Southwest Nat 50(1):74–78
Booth DB, Jackson CR (1997) Urbanization of aquatic systems: degradation thresholds, stormwater detection, and the limits of mitigation. J Am Water Resour Assoc 33:1077–1090
Bousman CB, Nickels DL (2003) Archaeological Testing of the Burleson Homestead at 41HY37 Hays County, Texas. Center for Archaeological Studies. Archaeological Studies Report No. 4, San Marcos
Bowles DE, Arsuffi TL (1993) Karst aquatic ecosystems of the Edwards Plateau region of central Texas, USA: a consideration of their importance, threats to their existence, and efforts for their conservation. Aquat Conserv 3:317–329
Brandt SA (2000) Classification of geomorphological effects downstream of dams. Catena 40:375–401
Brown LR, Gray RH, Hughes RM, Meador MR (2005) Introduction to effects of urbanization on stream ecosystems. Am Fish Soc Symp 47:1–8
Brown LR, Cuffney TF, Coles JF, Fitzpatrick F, McMahon G, Steuer J, Bell AH, May JT (2009) Urban streams across the USA: lessons learned from studies in 9 metropolitan areas. J N Am Benthol Soc 28(4):1051–1069
Brune GM (1981) Springs of Texas. In: Jones CA (ed) The decline of Texas springs, 2nd edn. Texas A&M University Press, College Station, pp 35–39
Catalano MJ, Bozek MA, Pellett TD (2007) Effects of dam removal on fish assemblage structure and spatial distributions in the Baraboo River, Wisconsin. N Am J Fish Manag 27(2):519–530
Clarke A, Mac NR, Bond N, Lake PS (2008) Macroinvertebrate diversity in headwater streams: a review. Freshwat Biol 53:1707–1721
Crooks JA, Soulé ME (1999) Lag itmes in population explosions of invasive species: causes and implications. In: Sandlun OT, Schei PJ (eds) Viken (eds) Invasive species and biodiversity management. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Netherlands, pp 103–125
Curtis SG (2012) Effects of a declining hydrograph on instream habitats and fish communities in a karstic stream. Master Thesis, Texas State University, San Marcos TX
Deike RG (1990) Dolomite dissolution rates and possible Holocene dedolomitization of water-bearing units in the Edwards aquifer, south-central Texas. J Hydrol 112(3–4):335–373
Doyle MW, Stanley EH, Orr CH, Selle AR, Sethi SA, Harbor JM (2005) Stream ecosystem response to small dam removal: lessons from the heartland. Geomorphology 71:227–244
Earl RA, Wood CR (2002) Upstream changes and downstream effects of the San Marcos River of central Texas. Tex J Sci 54(1):69–88
Echelle AA, Miller RR (1974) Rediscovery and redescription of the Leon Springs Pupfish, Cyprinodon bovinus, from Pecos County, Texas. Southwest Nat 19:179–190
Edwards RJ (2001) New additions and persistence of the introduced fishes of the upper San Antonio River, Bexar County, Texas. Tex J Sci 53(1):3–12
Edwards Aquifer Authority (2011) Groundwater Management Plan: 2010–2015 www.edwardsaquifer.org/files/Final_GMP.pdf. Accessed online September 24, 2012
Edwards RJ, Contreras-Balderas S (1991) Historical changes in the ichthyofauna of the lower Rio Grande (Rio Bravo del Norte), Texas and Mexico. The Southwest Nat 36(2):201–212
Eisenhour DJ (2004) Systematics, variation, and speciation of the Macrhybopsis aestivalis complex west of the Mississippi River. Bull Ala Mus Nat Hist 23:9–47
Elmore AJ, Kaushal SS (2008) Disappearing headwaters: patterns of stream burial due to urbanization. Ecol Soc Am 6(6):308–312
Finkenbine JK, Atwater JW, Mavinic DS (2000) Stream health after urbanization. J Am Water Resour Assoc 36(5):1149–1159
Gage MS, Spivak A, Paradise CJ (2004) Effects of land use and disturbance on benthic insects in headwater streams draining small watersheds north of Charlotte, NC. Southeast Nat 3(2):345–358
Garrett GP, Edwards RJ, Price AH (1992) Distribution and status of the Devils River minnow, Dionda diaboli. Southwest Nat 37(3):259–267
Garrett GP, Edwards RJ, Hubbs C (2004) Discovery of a new population of Devils River minnow (Dionda dialoli), with implications for conservation of the species. Southwest Nat 49(4):435–441
Grimshaw TW, Woodruff CM Jr (1986) Structural style in an En Echelon Fault System, Balcones Fault Zone, Central Texas: geomorphologic and hydrologic implications. In: Abbott PL, Woodruff CM Jr (eds) The balacones escarpment: geology, hydrology, ecology and social development in Central Texas. Geological Society of America, San Antonio, pp 71–76
Groeger AW, Brown PF, Tietjen TE, Kelsey TC (1997) Water quality of the San Marcos River. Tex J Sci 49(4):279–294
Hardy TB, Kollaus KA, Heard TC, Tennant JM, Tower K (2012) Incorporating physical habitat and water temperature modeling at high spatial and temporal scales to evaluate required minimum flow regimes during sustained drought. In: Mader H, Kraml J (eds) 9th ISE, Vienna, Austria
Hart DD, Johnson TE, Bushaw-Newton KL, Horwitz RJ, Bednarek AT, Charles DF, Kreeger DA, Velinsky DJ (2002) Dam removal: challenges and opportunities for ecological research and river restoration. Bioscience 52(8):669–681
Hubbs C (1954) A new Texas subspecies, apristis, of the darter Hadropterus scierus, with a discussion of variation within the species. Am Midl Nat 52:211–220
Hubbs C (1995) Springs and spring runs as unique aquatic systems. Copeia 1995(4):989–991
Hubbs C, Jensen BL (1984) Extinction of Gambusia amistadensis, an endangered fish. Copeia 1984:529–530
Hubbs C, Peden AE (1969) Gambusia georgei sp. nov. from San Marcos, Texas. Copeia 1969(2):357–364
Hubbs C, Kuehne RA, Ball JC (1953) The fishes of the upper Guadalupe River, Texas. Tex J Sci 5(2):216–244
Hubbs C, Edwards RJ, Garrett GP (2008) An annotated checklist of the freshwater fishes of Texas, with keys to identification of species. Texas academy of science. Tex J Sci 43:1–87
Hudson, PF (2012) Removal of Capes Dam, San Marcos River: Modeling Hydrologic, Geomorphic, and Ecological Response. Report to United States Fish and Wildlife Service
Hughes RM, Dunham S, Maas-Hebner K, Yeakley JA, Schreck C, Harte M, Molina N, Shock CC, Kaczynski VW, Schaeffer J (2014) A review of urban water body challenges and approaches: (1) rehabilitation and remediation. Fisheries 39(1):18–29
Hurst HN, Bass G, Hubbs C (1975) The biology of the Guadalupe, Suwannee, and redeye basses. In: Stroud RH, Clepper H (eds) Black bass biology and management. Sport Fishing Institute, Washington D.C., pp 47–53
Kaushal SS, Belt KT (2012) The urban watershed continuum: evolving spatial and temporal dimensions. Urban Ecosyst 15:409–435
Kelsch SW, Hendricks FS (1990) Distribution of the headwater catfish Ictalurus lupus (Pisces: Ictaluridae). Southwest Nat 35:292–297
Kollaus KA, Bonner TH (2012) Habitat associations of a semi-arid fish community in a karst spring-fed stream. J Arid Environ 76:72–79
Konrad CP, Booth DB (2005) Hydrologic changes in urban streams and their ecological significance. Am Fish Soc Symp 47:157–177
Kurtz JC, Yates DF, Macauley JM, Quarles RL, Genthner FJ, Chancy CA, Devereux R (2003) Effects of light reduction on growth of the submerged macrophyte Vallisneris Americana and the community of root-associated heterotrophic bacteria. J Exp Mar Biol Ecol 291:199–218
Labay B, Cohen AE, Sissel B, Hendrickson DA, Martin FD, Sarkar S (2011) Assessing historical fish community composition using surveys, historical collection data, and species distribution models. PLoS One 6:e25125. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0025145
Littrell BM, Lutz-Carrillo D, Bonner TH, Fries LT (2007) Status of an introgressed Guadalupe bass population in a central Texas stream. N Am J Fish Manag 27:785–791
Loáiciga HA (2009) Long-term climatic change and sustainable ground water resources management. Environ Res Lett 4:1–11
Lopez-Fernandez H, Winemiller KO (2005) Status of Dionda diaboli and report of established populations of exotic fish species in lower San Felipe Creek, Val Verde County, Texas. Southwest Nat 50:246–251
Maxwell RJ (2012) Patterns of endemism and species richness of fishes of the western gulf slope. Master’s Thesis, Texas State University-San Marcos
McClure-Baker SA, Echelle AA, Van den Bussche RA, Echelle AF, Hendrickson DA, Garrett GG (2010) Genetic status of headwater catfish in Texas and New Mexico: a perspectivefrom mtDNA and morphology. T Am Fish Soc 139:1780–1791
Meador MR, Coles JF, Humbert Z (2005) Fish assemblage responses to urban intensity gradients in contrasting metropolitan areas: Birmingham, Alabama and Boston, Massachusetts. Am Fish Soc Symp 47:409–423
Meffe GK, Minckley WL (1987) Persistence and stability of fish and invertebrate assemblages in a repeatedly disturbed sonoran desert stream. Am Midl Nat 117(1):177–191
Meyer JL, Wallace JB (2001) Lost linkages and lotic ecology: rediscovering small streams. In: Huntly NJ, Levin S (eds) Ecology: achievement and challenges. Blackwell Science, Massachusetts, pp 295–317
Meyer JL, Strayer DL, Wallace JB, Eggert SL, Helfman GS, Leonard NE (2007) The contribution of headwater streams to biodiversity in river networks. J Am Water Resour Assoc 43(1):86–103
Morgan RP, Cushman SF (2005) Urbanization effects on stream fish assemblages in Maryland, USA. J N Am Benthol Soc 24(3):643–655
Morizot DC, Calhoun SW, Clepper LL, Schmidt ME, Williamson JH, Carmichael GJ (1991) Multispecies hybridization among native and introduced centrarchid basses in central Texas. T Am Fish Soc 120:283–289
Nelson KC, Palmer MA (2007) Stream temperature surges under urbanization and climate change: data, models, and responses. J Am Water Resour Assoc 43(2):440–451
Nickels DL, Bousman CB, (2010) Archaeological Testing at San Marcos Springs (41HY160) for the Texas Rivers Center, Texas, Hays County, Texas. Center for Archaeological Studies. Archaeological Studies Report No. 13, San Marcos
Nico LG, Martin RT (2001) The South American Suckermouth Catfish, Pterygoplichthys anisitsi (Pisces: Loricaridae), in Texas, with comments on foreign fish introductions in the American Southwest. Southwest Nat 46:98–104
Niezgoda SL, Johnson PA (2005) Improving the urban stream restoration effort: Identifying critical form and processes relationships. Environ Manag 35(5):579–592
O’Connor JE, Costa JE (2004) Spatial distribution of the largest rainfall-runoff floods from basins between 2.6 and 26,000 km2 in the United States and Puerto Rico. Water Resour Res 40, W01107
O’Driscoll M, Clinton S, Jefferson A, Manda A, McMillan S (2010) Urbanization effects on watershed hydrology and in-stream processes in the southern United States. Water 2:605–648
Paul MJ, Meyer JL (2001) Streams in the urban landscape. Annu Rev Ecol Syst 32:333–365
Perkin JS, Bonner TH (2011) Long-term changes in flow regime and fish assemblage composition in the Guadalupe and San Marcos rivers of Texas. River Res Appl 27:566–579
Perkin JS, Shattuck ZR, Gerken JE, Bonner TH (2013) Fragmentation and drought legacy correlated with distribution of Burrhead Chub in subtropical streams of North America. T Am Fish Soc 142:1287–1298
Recon Environmental Inc. et al. (2012) Edwards Aquifer Recovery Implementation Program: Habitat Conservation Plan. Edwards Aquifer Authority. http://www.eahcp.org/files/uploads/Final%20HCP%20November%202012.pdf
Rhodes K, Hubbs C (1992) Recovery of Pecos River fishes from a red tide fish kill. Southwest Nat 37:178–187
Roark SA, Andrews JF, Guttman SL (2001) Population genetic structure of the western mosquitofish Gambusia affinis, in a highly channelized portion of the San Antonio River in San Antonio, TX. Ecotoxicology 10:223–227
Rohde FC (1980) Noturus gyrinus (Mitchill), Tadpole madtom. In: Lee DS, Gilbert CR, Hocutt CH, McAllister DE, Stauffer JR Jr (eds) Atlas of North American freshwater fishes. North Carolina State Museum of Natural History, Raleigh, p 459
Roy AH, Dybas AL, Fritz KM, Lubbers HR (2009) Urbanization affects the extent and hydrologic permanence of headwater streams in a midwesten US metropolitan area. J N Am Benthol Soc 28(4):911–928
Runyan DT (2007) Fish assemblage changes in Gulf Slope drainages; an historical perspective and Occurrence and distribution of age-0 fishes in the Rio Grande. Master Thesis, Texas State University, San Marcos TX
Russ J, Loyd DH, Boutton TW (2000) A paleoclimate reconstruction for southwestern Texas using oxlatate residue from lichen as a paleoclimate proxy. Quatern Int 67:29–36
Rybicki NB, McFarland DG, Ruhl HA, Reel JT, Barko JW (2001) Investigations of the availability and survival of submersed aquatic vegetation propagules in the tidal Potomac River. Estuaries 24(3):407–424
Sanborn CW (1944) The Story of Riverside. Thesis, Texas State University
Santucci VJ, Gephard SR, Pescitelli SM (2005) Effects of multiple low-head dams on fish, macroinvertebrates, habitat, and water quality in the Fox River, Illinois. N Am J Fish Manag 25:975–992
Saunders KS, Mayes KB, Jurgensen TA, Trungale JF, Kleinsasser LJ, Aziz K, Fields JR, Moss RE (2001) An evaluation of spring flows to support the upper San Marcos River spring ecosystem, Hays County, Texas. Texas Parks and Wildlife Department. River Studies Report No. 16, Austin
Schenck JR, Whiteside BG (1976) Distribution, habitat preference and population size estimate of Etheostoma fonticola. Copeia 1976(4):697–703
Schiff R, Benoit G (2007) Effects of impervious cover at multiple spatial scales on coastal watershed streams. J Am Water Resour Assoc 43(3):712–730
Sharp JM Jr (2010) The impacts of urbanization on groundwater systems and recharge. Aqua Mundi 1:51–56
Simon TP (1999) Assessment of Balon’s reproductive guilds with application to Midwestern North American freshwater fishes. In: Simon TP (ed) Assessing the sustainability and biological integrity of water resources using fish communities. CRC Press, New York, pp 97–121
Smith RF, Lamp WO (2008) Comparison of insect communities between adjacent headwater and main-stem streams in urban and rural watersheds. J N Am Benthol Soc 27(1):161–175
Spellerberg IF, Fedor PJ (2003) A tribute to Claude Shannon (1916–2000) and a plea for a more rigorous use of species richness, species diversity, and the ‘Shannon-Wiener’ Index. Glob Ecol Biogeogr 12:177–179
Steedman RJ, Whillans TH, Behm AP, Bray KE, Cullis KI, Holland MM, Stoddart SJ, White RJ (1996) Use of historical information for conservation and restoration of Great Lakes aquatic habitat. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 53:415–423
Sung CY, Li MH (2010) The effect of urbanization on stream hydrology in hillslope watersheds in central Texas. Hydrol Process 24:3706–3717
Sylvia DA, Galloway WE (2006) Morphology and stratigraphy of the late Quaternary lower Brazos valley: implications for paleo-climate, discharge, and sediment delivery. Sediment Geol 190:159–175
Thomas C, Bonner TH, Whiteside BG (2007) Freshwater fishes of Texas, 1st edn. Texas A&M university press, College Station
Tolley-Jordan LR, Power P (2007) Effects of water temperature on growth of the federally endangered Texas wild rice (Zizania texana). Southwest Nat 52:201–208
Toomey RS III, Blum MD, Valastro S Jr (1992) Late Quaternary climates and environments of the Edwards Plateau, Texas. Glob Planet Chang 7:299–320
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (1996) San Marcos and Comal Springs and associated aquatic ecosystems (revised) recovery Plan. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Albuquerque
Violin CR, Cada P, Sudduth EB, Hassett BA, Penrose DL, Bernhardt ES (2011) Effects of urbanization and urban stream restoration on the physical and biological structure of stream ecosystems. Ecol Appl 21(6):1932–1949
Walsh CJ, Roy AH, Feminella JW, Cottingham PD, Groffman PM, Morgan RP II (2005) The urban stream syndrome: current knowledge and the search for a cure. J N Am Benthol Soc 24(3):706–723
Walters DM, Freeman MC, Leigh DS, Freeman BJ, Pringle CM (2005) Urbanization effects on fishes and habitat quality in a southern Piedmont River basin. Am Fish S S 1–17
Walters DM, Roy AH, Leigh DS (2009) Environmental indicators of macroinvertebrate and fish assemblage integrity in urbanizing watersheds. Ecol Indic 9:1222–1233
Warren ML Jr, Burr BM (1994) Status of freshwater fishes of the United States: overview of and imperiled fauna. Fisheries 19(1):6–18
Watson JM (2006) Patterns and habitat associations of a desert spring fish assemblage and responses to a large-scale flood. Master Thesis, Texas State University, San Marcos TX
Weaver AL, Garman GC (1994) Urbanization of a watershed and historical changes in a stream fish assemblage. Am Fish Soc 123:162–172
White WB (1998) Groundwater flow in karst aquifers. In: Delleur JW (ed) The handbook of groundwater engineering, 2nd edn. CRC Press, Florida, pp 21.1–21.9
White K, Davidson GR, Paquin P (2009) Hydrologic evolution of the Edwards Aquifer recharge zone (Balcones fault zone) as recorded in the DNA of eyeless Cicurina cave spiders, south-central Texas. Geology 37:339–342
Whiteside BG, Berkhouse C (1992) Some new collection locations for six fish species. Tex J Sci 44:494
Winemiller KO, Anderson AA (1997) Response of endangered desert fish populations to a constructed refuge. Restor Ecol 5(3):204–213
Winter TC (2007) The role of ground water in generating streamflow in headwater areas and in maintaining base flow. J Am Water Resour Assoc 43(1):15–25
Woodruff CM Jr, Abbott PL (1979) Drainage basin evolution and aquifer development in a karstic limestone terrain south-central Texas, USA. Earth Surf Process 4:319–334
Zektser S, Loáiciga HA, Wolf JT (2005) Environmental impacts of groundwater overdraft: selected case studies in the southwestern United States. Environ Geol 47:396–404
Acknowledgments
Funding for this study was provided by American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (ARRA). We thank S. Curtis, C. Thomas, and several other Texas State University graduate and undergraduate students for their assistance in the field. Sampling permits were granted by Texas State University-San Marcos (IACUC 06-0620_802), Texas Parks & Wildlife Department (Permit SPR-0601-159; issued to Bonner, T), and United States Fish and Wildlife Service (TE236730-1, issued to Bonner, T).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Appendix 1
Appendix 1
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kollaus, K.A., Behen, K.P.K., Heard, T.C. et al. Influence of urbanization on a karst terrain stream and fish community. Urban Ecosyst 18, 293–320 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11252-014-0384-x
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11252-014-0384-x