Abstract
The Baltic cod (Gadus morhua) plays a very significant role in the Baltic Sea ecosystem being the major fish top predator and the most important commercial species for the Baltic Sea fishing industry. Consequently the management and understanding of the exploitation pattern of the stock is of major importance. Technical regulations, improving the selectivity of cod, have been a major management strategy and the Baltic Sea is likely to be the area where most fishing gear selectivity studies, focussing on size selectivity, have been conducted over time. The methodology for conducting and analysing selectivity data has been significantly improved in recent years. The subject is reviewed since the choice of methodology can have a significant effect on the interpretation of the outcome of selectivity experiments. Factors affecting the selectivity of trawl and gill nets are considered. Alternative ways to improve the size and species selectivity of trawls using selective devices are reviewed. Selectivity parameters from available literature are listed and the correlations of selectivity parameters to the mesh size for different gears are estimated. The historical legislation on selectivity is reviewed and the expected selectivity for trawls is estimated. Management considerations concerning the mortality of escaping and discarded fish and wider management impacts have to be considered if improving selectivity. The review is ended by conclusions including reflections on needed research in the future.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Anon (1940) Dansk Fiskeriårbog
Anon (1950) Dansk Fiskeriårbog
Anon (1960) Dansk Fiskeriårbog
Anon (1970) Dansk Fiskeriårbog
Anon (1974) International Baltic Sea Fishery Commission. In: Proceedings of the 1st session, Warsaw, October 28–31, 1974
Anon (1976) International Baltic Sea Fishery Commission. In: Proceedings of the 2nd session, Warsaw, Sep 27-Oct 1, 1976
Anon (1977) International Baltic Sea Fishery Commission. In: Proceedings of the 3rd session, Warsaw, Sep 13–20, 1977
Anon (1988) EC council regulation No. 2178/88, 18 July 1988
Anon (1989) EC council regulation No. 887/89, 5 April 1989
Anon (1995a) EC council regulation No. 2250/95, 18 December 1995
Anon (1995b) EC council regulation No. 3362/94, 20 December 1994
Anon (1999) EC council regulation No. 48/99, 18 December 1998
Anon (2001a) EC council regulation No. 2555/2001, 18 December 2001
Anon (2001b) International Baltic Sea Fishery Commission. Extraordinary session—BACOMA, Brussels, 13–14 March 2001
Anon (2002) EC council regulation No. 2341/2002, 20 December 2002
Anon (2003) EC council regulation No. 1754/2003, 22 September 2003
Anon (2005) EC council regulation No. 2187/2005, 21 December 2005
Bagge O (1978) Danish mesh selection experiments with cod in the Baltic. ICES CM 1978/J:17
Bagge O, Thurow F, Steffensen E, Bay J (1994) The Baltic cod. Dana 10:1–28
Baranov FI (1948) Theory and assessment of fishing gear, Chap 7. Theory of fishing with gillnets. Pishchepromizdat, Moscow (Translated from Russian by the Ontario Department of Lands and Forests. Maplc. Ont.)
Bergham R, Rösner HU (1992) A method to quantify feeding of seabirds on discard from the shrimp fishery in the North Sea. Neth J Sea Res 28(4):347–350
Beverton RJH (1963) Escape of fish through different parts of a codend. Spec Publ ICNAF 5(2):9–11
Blady W, Zaucha J (2000) The selectivity of polyethylene codends with diamond meshes and selective windows in cod trawls. Meddelande från Havsfiskelaboratoriet 329:66–73
Bohl H (1976) Mesh selection of Baltic cod. German experiments in 1975. ICES CM 1976/B:34
Bohl H (1980) Selection of cod by bottom trawl cod-ends in the central Baltic (German experiments 1978). ICES CM 1980/B:8
Bohl H (1981) Selection of cod by bottom trawl cod-ends in the central Baltic (German experiments 1979 and 1980). ICES CM 1981/B:13
Bohl H, Seydlitz HV (1972) Note on the selection of Baltic cod by bottom trawl codends. ICES CM 1972/B:11
Bohl H, Valencia JE (1976) German mesh selection experiments on Baltic cod in 1974. ICES CM 1976/B:33
Briggs RP (1992) An assessment of nets with a square mesh panel as a whiting conservation tool in the Irish Sea Nephrops fishery. Fish Res 13:133–152
Briggs RP, Robertson JHB (1993) Square mesh panel studies in the Irish Sea Nephrops fishery. ICES CM 1993/B:20
Cieglewicz W, Strzyzewski W (1959) Selection of Baltic cod by cod-ends of different materials. Rapp Proc Verb 147:75–80
DeAlteris JT, Reifsteck DM (1993) Escapement and survival of fish from the codend of a demersal trawl. ICES Mar Sci Symp 196:128–131
Dickson W (1989) Cod gillnet simulation model. Fish Res 7:149–174
Evans SM, Hunter JE, Elizal, Wahju RI (1994) Composition and fate of the catch and bycatch in the Farne Deep (North Sea) Nephrops fishery. ICES J Mar Sci 51:155–168
Ferro RST, O’Neill FG (1994) An overview of the characteristics of twines and netting that may change cod-end selectivity. ICES BM 1994/B:35
Ferro RST, Xu L (1996) An investigation of three methods of mesh size measurement. Fish Res 25:171–190
Fonteyne R, M’Rabet R (1992) Selectivity experiments on sole with diamond and square mesh codends in the Belgian coastal beam trawl fishery. Fish Res 13:221–233
Fryer RJ (1991) A model of the between-haul variation in selectivity. ICES J Mar Sci 48:281–290
Galbraith RD, Fryer RJ, Maitland KMS (1994) Demersal pair trawl cod-end selectivity models. Fish Res 20:13–27
Garrod DJ (1976) Mesh selection of Nephrops. Fish Res Tech report no 26, Lowesoft
Garthe S, Hüppop O (1994) Distribution of ship-following seabirds and their utilization of discards in the North Sea in the summer. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 106:1–9
Garthe S, Scherp B (2003) Utilization of discards and offal from commercial fisheries by seabirds in the Baltic Sea. ICES J Mar Sci 60:980–989
Glass CW, Wardle CS (1995) Studies on the use of visual stimuli to control fish escape from codends: II. The effect of a black tunnel on the reaction behaviour of fish in otter trawl codends. Fish Res 23:165–174
Glass CW, Wardle CS, Gosden SJ, Racey DN (1995) Studies on the visual stimuli to control fish escape from codends: I. Fish Res 23:157–164
Halliday RG, Cooper CG, Fanning P, Hickey WM, Gagnon P (1999) Size selection of Atlantic cod, haddock and pollock (saithe) by otter trawls with square and diamond mesh codends of 130–155 mm mesh size. Fish Res 41:255–271
Hamley JM (1975) Review of gillnet selectivity. J Fish Res Board Can 32:1943–1969
Herrmann B (2005a) Effect of catch size and shape on the selectivity of diamond mesh cod-ends I. Model development. Fish Res 71:1–13
Herrmann B (2005b) Effect of catch size and shape on the selectivity of diamond mesh cod-ends II. Theoretical study of haddock selection. Fish Res 71:15–26
Hillis JP, McCormic R, Rihan D, Geary M (1991) Square mesh experiments in the Irish Sea. ICES CM 1991/B:58
Holst R, Moth-Poulsen T (1995) Numerical recipes and statistical methods for gillnet selectivity. ICES CM 1995/B:18
Holst R, Wileman D, Tschernij V, Madsen N (2000) Statistical modelling and analysis of gill net size selectivity data. Meddelande från Havsfiskelaboratoriet 329:149–188
Holst R, Wileman D, Madsen N (2002) The effect of twine thickness on the size selectivity and fishing power of Baltic cod gill nets. Fish Res 56:303–312
Holt SJ (1963) A method for determinating gear selectivity and its application. ICNAF Spec Publ 5:106–115
Hovgård H (1996) A two-step approach to estimating selectivity and fishing power of research gill nets used in Greenland waters. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 53:1007–1013
Hovgård H, Lassen H, Madsen N, Moth-Poulsen T, Wileman D (1999) Gillnet selectivity for North Sea Atlantic cod (Gadus morhua): model ambiguity and data quality are related. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 56:1307–1316
Hudson AV, Furness RW (1988) Utilization of discarded fish by scavenging seabirds behind whitefish trawlers in Shetland. J Zool Lond 215:151–166
ICES (1964) Coop Res Rep, vol 2, p 156
ICES (1965) Guide to the presentation of selectivity data. Proc V Réun. CIEM, part 1
ICES (1986) Report of the working group on assessment of demersal stocks in the Baltic. ICES CM 1986/Assess:21
ICES (2000) Report of the ICES advisory committee on fishery management, 2000. ICES Coop Res Rep, part 3
ICES (2003) Report of the ICES Advisory Committee on fishery management. ICES Cooperative Research Report, no. 261
ICES (2005) Report of the ICES Advisory Committee on fishery management, Advisory Committee on the marine environment and Advisory Committee on ecosystems, 2005. ICES Advice, vol 8
Isaksen B, Løkkeborg S (1993) Escape of cod (Gadus morhua) and haddock (Melanogrammus aeglefinus) from Danish seine codends during fishing and surface hauling operations. ICES Mar Sci Symp 196:86–91
Isaksen B, Valdemarsen JW (1986) Selectivity experiments with square mesh codends in bottom trawl. ICES CM 1986/B:28
Jacobsen J (1994) Survival experiments of fish escaping from 145 mm diamond cod-end meshes at Faroes in 1992 and 1993. Reported in ICES CM 1994/B: 2: pp18
Kirkegaard E, Nielsen NA, Bagge O (1989) Mesh selection of Nephrops on 60 and 70 mm Nephrops trawl. ICES CM 1989/B:15
Kirkwood GP, Walker TI (1986) Gill net mesh selectivities for gummy shark, Mustelus antarticus Günther, taken in south-eastern Australian waters. Aust J Mar Freshw Res 37:689–697
Kuikka S, Hildén M, Gislason H, Hansson S, Sparholt H, Varis O (1999) Modeling environmentally driven uncertainties in the Baltic cod (Gadus morhua) management by Bayesian influence diagrams. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 56:629–641
Larsson P-O, Claesson B, Nyberg L (1988) Catches of undersized cod in codends with square and diamond meshes. ICES CM 1988/B:57
Lehman K, Valdemarsen JW, Riget F (1993) Selectivity in shrimp trawl codends tested in a fishery in Greenland. ICES Mar Sci Symp 196:80–85
Lehtonen E, Tschernij V, Suuronen P (1998) An improved method for studying survival of fish that escape through meshes of trawl codends. Fish Res 38:303–306
Lowry N, Robertson JHB (1996) The effect of twine thickness on cod-end selectivity of trawls for haddock in the North Sea. Fish Res 26:353–363
Lowry N, Knudsen LH, Wileman DA (1994) Mesh size experiments in the Baltic cod fishery. ICES CM 1994/B:29
Lowry N, Knudsen LH, Wileman D (1995) Selectivity in Baltic cod trawls with square mesh codend windows. ICES CM 1995/B:5
Lowry N, Wileman D, Ferro D (1998) Factors affecting the variability of cod-end selectivity. Fishing gear technology and fish behaviour working group meeting. La Coruña, Spain 1998
MacLennan DV (1995) Gear selectivity and the variation of yield. ICES J Mar Sci 52(5):827–836
Madsen N (2000) Experimental adjustments of the escape window position in trawl codends—implications for Baltic Sea cod fishery. Meddelande från Havsfiskelaboratoriet 329:38–56
Madsen N, Holst R (2002) Assessment of the cover effect in trawl codend selectivity experiments. Fish Res 56:289–301
Madsen N, Moth-Poulsen T (1994) Measurements of the selectivity of Nephrops and demersal roundfish species in conventional and square mesh panel codends in the northern North Sea. ICES CM 1994/B:14
Madsen N, Stæhr K-J (2005) Selectivity experiments to estimate the effect of escape windows in the Skagerak roundfish fishery. Fish Res 71(2):241–245
Madsen N, Moth-Poulsen T, Lowry N (1998) Selectivity experiments with window codends fished in the Baltic Sea cod (Gadus morhua) fishery. Fish Res 36:1–14
Madsen N, Holst R, Wileman D, Moth-Poulsen T (1999a) Selectivity of Danish sole (Solea solea) gill nets fished in the North Sea. Fish Res 44:59–73
Madsen N, Moth-Poulsen T, Holst R, Wileman D (1999b) Selectivity experiments with escape windows in the North Sea Nephrops (Nephrops norvegicus) trawl fishery. Fish Res 42:167–181
Madsen N, Hansen KE, Moth-Poulsen T (2001) The kite cover: a new concept for covered codend selectivity studies. Fish Res 49:219–226
Madsen N, Holst R, Foldager L (2002) Escape windows to improve the size selectivity in the Baltic cod trawl fishery. Fish Res 57:223–235
Madsen N, Tschernij V, Hansen K, Larsson P-O (2006) Development and testing of a species-selective flatfish otter trawl to reduce cod bycatches. Fish Res 78:298–308
Main J, Sangster GI (1991) A different approach to covered cod-end selection experiments. Scott Fish Work paper no. 4/91
Main J, Sangster GI, Kynoch RJ, Ferro RST (1992) An experiment to measure the selectivity of cod-ends using two designs of covers. Scott. Fish Work paper no. 2/92
Marlen B van (1993) Research on improving the species selectivity of bottom trawls in the Netherlands. ICES Mar Sci Symp 196:165–169
Millar RB (1992) Estimating the size-selectivity of fishing gear by conditioning on the total catch. J Am Stat Assoc 87:962–968
Millar RB, Fryer RJ (1999) Estimating the size-selection curves of towed gears, traps, nets and hooks. Rev Fish Biol Fish 9:1–28
Millar RB, Holst R (1997) Estimation of gillnet and hook selectivity using log-linear models. ICES J Mar Sci 54(3):471–477
Moderhak W (1997) Determination of selectivity of cod codends made of netting turned through 90°. Bull Sea Fish Inst 1(140):3–14
Moderhak W (1999) Investigations of the selectivity of codends with meshes turned through 90°. Bull Sea Fish Inst 1(146):39–55
Moderhak W (2000a) Selectivity tests of polyamide and polyethylene codends made of netting with meshes turned through 90°. Bull Sea Fish Inst 1(149):1–9
Moderhak W (2000b) Selectivity properties of polyamide (PA) cod trawl codends made of meshes turned 90°. Meddelande från Havsfiskelaboratoriet 329:57–65
Moderhak W, Blady W, Czajka W (1995) Preliminary studies of vertical separation of cod in a trawl codend. IMR Report No. 327. Institute of Marine Research, Lysekil, Sweden
Mohr H (1983) Gute ergebrisse beim dorshfang mit grossmascigen stellnetzen in der westlichen Ostsee. Inf Fischw 30(1):40–43
Netzel J, Zaucha J (1989) Investigation results of cod trawls’ codend selectivity. ICES CM 1989/B:54
Olofsson J, Otterlind G (1978) Swedish mesh selection experiments on Baltic cod in 1977 and 1978. ICES CM 1978/B:2
O’Neill FG, Kynoch RJ (1996) The effect of cover mesh size and codend catch size on codend selectivity. Fish Res 28:291–303
O’Neill FG, Kynoch RJ, Fryer RJ (2006) Square mesh panels in Norths sea demersal trawls: separate estimates of panel and cod-end selectivity. Fish Res 78:333–341
Özbilgin H, Ferro RST, Robertson JHB, Holtrop G, Kynoch RJ (2006) Seasonal variation in trawl codend selection of northern North Sea haddock. ICES J Mar Sci 63(4):737–748
Pawson MG (2003) The catching capacity of lost static fishing gears. Fish Res 64:101–105
Polet H, Redant F (1994) Selectivity experiments in the Belgian Norway lobster, Nephrops norvegicus L., fishery. ICES CM 1994/B:39
Pope JG (1991) The ICES multispecies assessment working group: evaluation, insights, and future problems. ICES Mar Sci Symp 193:22–33
Pope JA, Margetts AR, Hamley JM, Akyuz EF (1975) Manuel of methods for fish stock assessment. Part III selectivity of fishing gear. FAO Fish Tech Pap. (41) revision 1
Reeves SA, Armstrong DW, Fryer R.J., Coull KA (1992) The effects of mesh size, cod-end extension length and cod-end diameter on the selectivity of Scottish trawls and seines. ICES J Mar Sci 49:279–288
Ridderstad G (1915) A new construction of trawl-net intended to spare under-sized fish. Svenske Hydr.-Biol. Kommisionens skrifter, vol. 6
Robertson JHB, Leaver ID (1989) An experiment with the ICES approved small mesh codend cover. Scott Fish Work paper no. 10/89
Robertson JHB, Stewart PAM (1988) A comparison of size selection of haddock and whiting by square and diamond mesh codends. J Cons Explor Mer 44:148–161
Robertson JHB, Emslie DC, Ballantyne KA, Chapman CJ (1986) Square and diamond mesh trawl codend selection trials on Nephrops norvegicus (L). ICES CM 1986/B:12
Robertson JHB, Lowry N, Kynoch B, Özbilgin H (1995) Improvements in designs of cod-end covers. ICES CM/B:35
Shevtsov SE (1981) Selectivity of the bottom trawl codends with 100 and 110 mm mesh size used for the Baltic cod fishery. ICES CM 1981/B:7
Soldal AV, Isaksen B (1993) Survival of cod (Gadus morhua) and Haddock (Melanogrammus aeglefinus) escaping from a Danish seine at the sea surface. Fishing gear Technology and Fish behaviour Working Group meeting, Gothenborg, Sweden
Sparholt H (1990) Improved estimates of the natural mortality rates of nine commercially important fish species included in the North Sea multispecies VPA model. J Cons Int Explor Mer 46:211–223
Sparholt H (1991) Multispecies assessment of Baltic fish stocks. ICES mar Sci Symp 193:64–79
Sparre P (1991) Introduction to multispecies virtual population analysis. ICES Mar Sci Symp 193:12–21
Strzyzewski W, Szymański W, Zdziebkowski G (1973) Investigations on the selectivity of Baltic cod and flounder carried out in 1972/1973. ICES CM 1973/F:25
Suuronen P, Millar R (1992) Size selectivity of diamond and square mesh codends in pelagic herring trawls: only small herring will notice the difference. Can J Fish Aquat Sci 49:2104–2117
Suuronen P, Millar RB, Järvik A (1991) Selectivity of diamond and hexagonal mesh codends in pelagic herring trawls: evidence of a catch size effect. Finn Fish Res 12:143–156
Suuronen P, Lehtonen E, Tschernij V, Larsson P-O (1996) Skin injury and mortality of Baltic cod escaping from trawl codends equipped with exit windows. Arch Fish Mar Res 44(3):165–178
Suuronen P, Lehtonen E, Tschernij V, Jounela P (2005) Escape mortality of trawl caught Baltic cod (Gadus morhua)—the effect of water temperature, fish size and codend catch. Fish Res 71:151–163
Thomsen B (1993) Selective flatfish trawling. ICES Mar Sci Symp 196:161–164
Thorsteinsson G (1992) Experiments with square mesh windows in the Nephrops trawling off South-Iceland. ICES CM 1991/B:3
Thurow F, Bohl H (1976) On survival rates of Baltic cod after capture. ICES CM 1976/P:4
Tokaç A, Özbilgin H, Tosunoğlu Z (2004) Effect of PA and PE material on codend selectivity in Turkish bottom trawl. Fish Res 67(3):317–327
Treshev AI, Shevtsov SE (1976) Selectivity of bottom trawl cod-end while fishing cod in the Baltic Sea. ICES CM 1976/B:12
Tschernij V, Holst R (1999) Evidence of factors at vessel-level affecting codend selectivity in Baltic cod demersal fishery. ICES CM 1999/R:02
Tschernij V, Larsson P-O (2003) Ghost fishing by lost cod gill nets in the Baltic Sea. Fish Res 64:151–162
Tschernij V, Suuronen P (2002) Improving trawl selectivity in the Baltic. Nordic Council of Ministers, TemaNord 2002, p 512
Tschernij V, Larsson P-O, Suuronen P, Holst R (1996) Swedish trials in the Baltic Sea to improve selectivity in demersal trawls. ICES CM 1996/B:25
Tschernij V, Suuronen P, Jounela P (2004) A modelling approach for assessing short-term catch losses as a consequence of a mesh size increase. Fish Res 69:399–406
Votier SC, Furness RW, Bearhop S, Crane JE, Caldow RW, Catry P, Ensor K, Hamer KC, Hudson AV, Kalmbach E, Klomp NI, Pfeiffer S, Phillips RA, Prieto I, Thompson DR (2004) Changes in fisheries discard rates and seabird communities. Nature 427:727–730
Walsh SJ, Cooper C, Hickey W (1989) Size selection of plaice by square and diamond mesh cod-ends. ICES CM 1989/B.22
Wienbeck H, Dahm E (2000) New ways for an improvement of the selectivity of trawl codends in the Baltic cod fishery. Meddelande från Havsfiskelaboratoriet 329:80–93
Wileman DA, Ferro RST, Fonteyne R, Millar RB (eds) (1996) Manual of methods of measuring the selectivity of towed fishing gears. ICES Coop Res Rep No. 215
Wileman DA, Tschernij V, Madsen N, Holst R (2000) Size selectivity and relative fishing power of Baltic cod gill nets. Meddelande från Havsfiskelaboratoriet 329:110–148
Zaucha J, Blady W, Czajka W, Moderhak W (1995) Studies of mesh size in cod gill nets with respect to protection requirements. Baltic cod, Symposium Gdynia, Poland March 21–22, 1995:78–86. IMR Report No. 327
Zaucha J, Blady W, Moderhak W (1997) Protective properties of cod trawl codends with selective windows. Bulletin of the Sea Fisheries Institute 1(140):15–24
Acknowledgments
This work was carried out with funds to the TEMAS project sponsored by the Directorate for Food, Fisheries and Agri Business. Thanks are due to colleagues for comments and discussions, particularly Mariana Horsten and Bo Lundgren and to Vesa Tscernij for use of a drawing (Fig. 1), anonymous referees and the editor for very useful comments.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Madsen, N. Selectivity of fishing gears used in the Baltic Sea cod fishery. Rev Fish Biol Fisheries 17, 517–544 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11160-007-9053-y
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11160-007-9053-y