Abstract
We show that candlestick charting, the oldest known form of technical analysis, is not profitable in the Japanese equity market over the 1975–2004 period. Candlestick technical analysis, which was developed in Japan in the 1600s, is deeply intertwined with Japanese culture and is very popular in Japan. However, there is no evidence candlestick technical trading strategies add value in either the entire 30 year period, in three 10 year sub-periods or in bull or bear markets.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Fock et al. (2005) find that candlestick technical analysis is not profitable on intraday German futures data; however, their study is less relevant to this paper for several reasons. Firstly, technical analysis books highlight that the significance of the close price to candlestick charting is due to it being the final price prior to the market being closed for a period. This suggests that candlestick technical analysis may not be as reliable on an intraday basis. Second, Fock et al. (2005) do not apply a bootstrapping methodology so their results are not directly comparable to ours.
See Pring (2002).
During the 1/1/1975–31/12/1989 period the Nikkei gained 930%, while it declined by 71% during the 1/1/1990–31/12/2004 period.
We thank an anonymous reviewer for highlighting this.
As far as we are aware, no one else has attempted to conduct this bootstrap procedure on more than 30 stocks.
Results for the other null models are available on request.
We initially intended to consider the profitability of candlestick technical analysis with varying levels of transaction costs but decided against this once it became evident that it is not profitable before transaction costs.
References
Bartov E, Kim E (2004) Risk, mispricing, and value investing. Rev Quant Finance Acc 23:353–376
Brusia J, Lui P (2004) The day-of-the-week and week-of-the-month effects: an analysis of investors’ trading activities. Rev Quant Finance Acc 23:19–30
Brock W, Lakonishok J, LeBaron B (1992) Simple technical trading rules and the stochastic properties of stock returns. J Finance 47(5):1731–1764
Carter, RB, Van Auken HE (1990) Security analysis and portfolio management: a survey and analysis. J Portfol Manage, Summer:81–85.
Corrado CJ, Lee SH (1992) Filter rule tests of the economic significance of serial dependence in daily stock returns. J Finan Res 154:369–387
Day T, Wang P (2002) Dividends, nonsynchronous prices, and the returns from trading the Dow Jones Industrial Average. J Empirical Finance 9:431–454
Efron B (1979) Bootstrap methods: another look at the jackknife. Ann Stat 71:1–26
Fama EF (1998) Market efficiency, long-term returns, and behavioural finance. J Finan Econ 49(3):283–306
Fock JH, Klein C, Zwergel B (2005) Performance of candlestick analysis on intraday futures data. J Futures Markets, Fall:28–40
Ito A (1999) Profits on technical trading rules and time-varying expected returns: evidence from pacific-basin equity markets. Pacific-Basin Finance J 7(3–4):283–330
Jorion P, Goetzman WN (1999) Global stock markets in the twentieth century. J Finance 54:953–986
Kavajecz KA, Odders-White RE (2004) Technical analysis and liquidity provision. Rev Financial Stud 17(4):1043–1071
Lo AW, Mamaysky H, Wang J (2000) Foundations of technical analysis: computational algorithms, statistical inference, and empirical implementation. J Finance 55:1705–1770
Malkiel B (1981) A random walk down wall street, 2nd edn. Norton, New York
Marshall BR, Young MR, Rose LC (2006) Candlestick technical trading strategies: can they create value for investors? J Banking Finance 30:2303–2323
Miller, EM (1990) Atomic bombs, the depression and equilibrium. J Portfol Manage, Summer:37–41
Morris G (1995) Candlestick charting explained: timeless techniques for trading stocks and futures, 2nd edn. McGraw-Hill Trade, New York
Nison S (1991) Japanese candlestick charting techniques: a contemporary guide to the ancient investment technique of the Far East. New York Institute of Finance
Nison S (2004) Candlestick trading principles. Technical analysis of stocks and commodities November, 22–27
Olson D (2004) Have trading rule profits in the currency markets declined over time? J Banking Finance 28:85–105
Osler C (2003) Currency orders and exchange-rate dynamics: An explanation for the predictive success of technical analysis. J Finance 58(5):1791–1820
Pring M (2002) Candlesticks explained. McGraw-Hill, New York
Treynor JL, Ferguson R (1984) In defence of technical analysis. J Finance 40(3):757–773
Acknowledgments
We thank the editor, Cheng-few Lee, and two anonymous referees for comments that have improved the paper.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Marshall, B.R., Young, M.R. & Cahan, R. Are candlestick technical trading strategies profitable in the Japanese equity market?. Rev Quant Finan Acc 31, 191–207 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11156-007-0068-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11156-007-0068-1