Abstract
Conventional locomotives employing diesel-based propulsion systems have raised concerns about the environment and hence sustainable development due to their emissions. To obtain an environmentally benign railway system, fuel cell-based locomotives are considered promising candidates owing to their high efficiencies as well as environmental performance. In the present study, a review of the development of fuel cell-based locomotives is conducted and their current progress is described. Further, investigations conducted on various aspects of these types of locomotives are discussed. The literature studies were found to be focused on four main areas namely (1) prototype design/analysis, (2) energy management, (3) feasibility and economic assessment and (4) environmental performance. Fuel cell-based hybrid locomotives entail the potential to reduce the environmental emissions considerably with similar investment costs as diesel fuel-based locomotives. Nearly 3318 tonnes/year of \(\hbox {CO}_{2}\) emissions may be reduced by replacing diesel engine locomotives with fuel cell trains. Approximately 98% of \(\hbox {NO}_{\mathrm{x}}\) emissions are estimated to be reduced with the utilization of hybrid fuel cell locomotives. Moreover, several control systems utilizing fuzzy logic control strategy have been proved to be efficient energy management aids for such locomotives. Overall locomotive efficiencies of 50.9% are achievable with the deployment of such control strategies that effectively manage the power demands between the fuel cells, batteries and supercapacitors.
Similar content being viewed by others
Abbreviations
- AFC:
-
Alkaline fuel cell
- \(\hbox {CO}_{2}\) :
-
Carbon dioxide
- CuCl:
-
Copper chlorine
- DC:
-
Direct current
- GHG:
-
Greenhouse gas emissions
- HX:
-
Heat exchanger
- SOFC:
-
Solid oxide fuel cell
- MCFC:
-
Molten carbonate fuel cell
- PAFC:
-
Phosphoric acid fuel cell
- PEM:
-
Proton exchange membrane
- PM:
-
Particulate matter
- PSO:
-
Particle swarm optimization
- \(\hbox {NO}_{\mathrm{x}}\) :
-
Nitrogen oxides
- ROG:
-
Reactive organic compounds
- \(\hbox {SO}_{\mathrm{x}}\) :
-
Sulphur oxides
- TOG:
-
Total organic compounds
- wt:
-
Weight
References
International Energy Agency (IEA) World Energy Balances (2015). https://www.iea.org/publications/freepublications/publication/KeyWorld2017.pdf. Accessed 1 June 2018
Transport, Energy and CO2. IEA. https://www.iea.org/publications/freepublications/publication/transport2009.pdf. Accessed 1 June 2018
Worldbank, Fossil fuel energy consumption (% of total) \({\vert }\) Data (2014). http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/EG.USE.COMM.FO.ZS. Accessed 24 Mar 2017
Transportation electrification. Hydro Quebec. http://www.hydroquebec.com/transportation-electrification/. Accessed 1 June 2018
Scott, D.S.; Rogner, H.; Scott, M.B.: Fuel cell locomotives in Canada. Int. J. Hydrog. Energy 18(3), 253–263 (1993)
Moghbelli, H.; Gao, Y.; Langari, R.; Ehsani, M.: Investigation of hybrid fuel cell technology applications on the future passenger railroad transportation. In: Proceedings of the 2003 IEEE/ASME Joint Rail Conference, pp. 39–53 (2003)
Zavada, J.; Zavada, J.B.; Plesa, T.: Hybrid propulsion of railway vehicles. In: Proceedings of 16th International Scientific-Technical Trans & AutoMoto Conference, pp. 11–14 (2009)
Miller, A.R.; Hess, K.S.; Barnes, D.L.; Erickson, T.L.: System design of a large fuel cell hybrid locomotive. J. Power Sources 173, 935–942 (2007)
US Department of Energy, Comparison of fuel cell technologies. https://www.energy.gov/eere/fuelcells/comparison-fuel-cell-technologies. Accessed 1 June 2018
Carrette, L.S.U.; Friedrich, K.A.: Fuel cells–fundamentals and applications. Fuel Cells 1, 5–39 (2001)
Prater, K.B.: Solid polymer fuel cells for transport and stationary applications. J. Power Sources 61, 105–109 (1996)
Kordesch, K.V.S.G.: Fuel Cells and Their Applications. Wiley, Hoboken (1996)
Sopian, K.W.D.W.: Challenges and future developments in proton exchange membrane fuel cells. Renew. Energy 31, 719–27 (2006)
Wang, Y.; Chen, K.S.; Mishler, J.; Cho, S.C.; Adroher, X.C.: A review of polymer electrolyte membrane fuel cells: technology, applications, and needs on fundamental research. Appl. Energy 88, 981–1007 (2011)
Kordesch, K.; Hacker, V.; Gsellmann, J.; Cifrain, M.; Faleschini, G.; Enzinger, P.; Fankhauser, R.; Ortner, M.; Muhr, M.; Aronson, R.R.: Alkaline fuel cells applications. J. Power Sources 86, 162–165 (2000)
Bidault, F.; Brett, D.J.L.; Middleton, P.H.; Brandon, N.P.: Review of gas diffusion cathodes for alkaline fuel cells. J. Power Sources 187, 39–48 (2009)
Nijmeijer, K.; Merle, G.; Wessling, M.: Anion exchange membranes for alkaline fuel cells: a review. J. Membr. Sci. 377, 1–35 (2011)
Gottesfeld, S.: Anion exchange membrane fuel cells: current status and remaining challenges. J. Power Sources 375, 170–184 (2018)
Wang, Y.; Qiao, J.; Baker, R.; Zhang, J.: Alkaline polymer electrolyte membranes for fuel cell applications. Chem. Soc. Rev. 42, 5768–5787 (2013)
Varcoe, J.R.: Prospects for alkaline anion-exchange membranes in low temperature fuel cells. Fuel Cells 5(2), 187–200 (2005)
AFC Energy (2018). https://www.afcenergy.com/. Accessed 1 June 2018
Badwal, S.; Ciacchi, F.: Oxygen-ion conducting electrolyte materials for solid oxide fuel cells. Ionics 6, 1–21 (2000)
Boldrin, P.; Ruiz-Trejo, E.; Mermelstein, J.; Bermúdez, J.M.; Reina, T.R.; Brandon, N.P.: Strategies for carbon and sulfur tolerant solid oxide fuel cell materials, incorporating lessons from heterogeneous catalysis. Chem. Rev. 116, 13633 (2016)
Brodnikovskii, E.M.: Solid oxide fuel cell anode materials. Powder Metall. Met. Ceram. 54, 166–174 (2015)
da Silva, F.S.; de Souza, T.M.: Novel materials for solid oxide fuel cell technologies: a literature review. Int. J. Hydrog. Energy 42, 26020–26036 (2017)
Gao, Z.; Mogni, L.V.; Miller, E.C.; Railsback, J.G.; Barnett, S.A.: A perspective on low-temperature solid oxide fuel cells. Energy Environ. Sci. 9, 162–1644 (2016)
Mahato, N.; Banerjee, A.; Gupta, A.; Omar, S.; Balani, K.: Progress in material selection for solid oxide fuel cell technology: a review. Progr. Mater. Sci. 72, 141–337 (2015)
Minh, N.: Ceramic fuel-cells. J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 76, 563–588 (1993)
Saravanan, R.: Solid Oxide Fuel Cell (SOFC) Materials. Materials Research Forum LLC., Millersville (2018)
Singhal, S.; Kendall, K.: High-Temperature Solid Oxide Fuel Cells: Fundamentals, Design and Applications. Elsevier, Amsterdam (2003)
Weber, A.; Ivers-Tiffee, E.: Materials and concepts for solid oxide fuel cells (SOFCs) in stationary and mobile applications. J. Power Sources 127, 273–283 (2004)
Zhang, Y.; Knibbe, R.; Sunarso, J.; Zhong, Y.; Zhou, W.; Shao, Z.; Zhu, Z.: Solid-oxide fuel cells: recent progress on advanced materials for solid-oxide fuel cells operating below \(500\, ^{\circ }\text{C}\) (Adv. Mater. 48/2017). Adv. Mater. 29(48) (2017). https://doi.org/10.1002/adma.201770345
Veyo, S.: The westinghouse solid oxide fuel cell program—a status report. In: LECEC 96-Proceedings of the 31st Intersociety Energy Conversion Engineering Conference, pp. 1138–1143 (1996)
Ideris, A.; Croiset, E.; Pritzker, M.; Amin, A.: Direct-methane solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) with Ni-SDC anode-supported cell. Int. J. Hydrog. Energy 42(36), 23118–23129 (2017)
Ding, H.; Tao, Z.; Liu, S.; Yang, Y.: A redox-stable direct-methane solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) with Sr2FeNb0.2Mo0.8O6-\(\updelta \) double perovskite as anode material. J. Power Sources 327, 573–579 (2016)
Li, P.; Li, J.; Li, Y.; Yu, B.; Yao, X.; Zhao, Y.: Improved activity and stability of Ni–Ce0.8Sm0.2O1.9 anode for solid oxide fuel cells fed with methanol through addition of molybdenum. J. Power Sources 320, 251–256 (2016)
Elleuch, A.; Halouani, K.; Li, Y.: Bio-methanol fueled intermediate temperature solid oxide fuel cell: A future solution as component in auxiliary power unit for eco-transportation. Mater. Des. 97, 331–340 (2016)
Li, P.; Li, J.; Li, Y.; Yu, X.; Yao, B.; Zhao, Y.: A single layer solid oxide fuel cell composed of La2NiO4 and doped ceria-carbonate with H2 and methanol as fuels. Int. J. Hydrog. Energy 41(21), 9059–9065 (2016)
Qu, J.; Wang, W.; Chen, Y.; Deng, X.; Shao, Z.: Stable direct-methane solid oxide fuel cells with calcium-oxide-modified nickel-based anodes operating at reduced temperatures. Appl. Energy 164, 563–571 (2015)
Li, Y.; Wong, L.M.; Xie, H.; Wang, S.; Su, P.: Nanoporous palladium anode for direct ethanol solid oxide fuel cells with nanoscale proton-conducting ceramic electrolyte. J. Power Sources 340, 98–103 (2016)
Tippawan, A.; Arpornwichanop, P.; Dincer, I.: Energy and exergy analyses of an ethanol-fueled solid oxide fuel cell for a trigeneration system. Energy 87, 228–239 (2015)
Steil, M.C.; Nobrega, S.D.; Georges, S.; Gelin, P.; Uhlenbruck, S.; Fonseca, F.C.: Durable direct ethanol anode-supported solid oxide fuel cell. Appl. Energy 199, 180–186 (2017)
Yang, J.; Molouk, A.F.S.; Okanishi, T.; Muroyama, H.; Matsui, T.; Eguchi, K.: A stability study of Ni/Yttria-stabilized zirconia anode for direct ammonia solid oxide fuel cells. ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces 7(51), 28701 (2015)
Siddiqui, O.; Dincer, I.: Analysis and performance assessment of a new solar-based multigeneration system integrated with ammonia fuel cell and solid oxide fuel cell-gas turbine combined cycle. J. Power Sources 370, 138–154 (2017)
Cinti, G.; Discepoli, G.; Sisani, E.; Desideri, U.: SOFC operating with ammonia: stack test and system analysis. Int. J. Hydrog. Energy 41(31), 13583–13590 (2016)
Alnegren, P.; Grolig, J.G.; Ekberg, J.; Göransson, G.; Svensson, J.E.: Metallic bipolar plates for high temperature polymer electrolyte membrane fuel cells. Fuel Cells 16(1), 39–45 (2016)
Kakati, B.K.; Sathiyamoorthy, D.; Verma, A.: Electrochemical and mechanical behavior of carbon composite bipolar plate for fuel cell. Int. J. Hydrog. Energy 35(9), 4185–4194 (2010)
Weissbecker, K.; Wippermann, V.; Lehnert, W.: Electrochemical corrosion study of metallic materials in phosphoric acid as bipolar plates for HT-PEFCs. J. Electrochem. Soc. 161(14), F1437–F1447 (2014)
Bevilacqua, N.; George, M.G.; Galbiati, S.; Bazylak, A.; Zeis, R.: Phosphoric acid invasion in high temperature PEM fuel cell gas diffusion layers. Electrochem. Acta 257, 89–98 (2017)
Lee, D.; Lee, D.G.: Carbon composite bipolar plate for high-temperature proton exchange membrane fuel cells (HT-PEMFCs). J. Power Sources 327, 119–126 (2016)
United Technologies Corp. www.utc.com. Accessed 1 June 2018
Brenscheidt, T.; Janowitz, K.; Salge, H.; Wendt, H.; Brammer, F.: Performance of ONSI PC25 PAFC cogeneration plant. Int. J. Hydrog. Energy 23(1), 53–56 (1998)
Hojo, N.; Okuda, M.; Nakamura, M.: Phosphoric acid fuel cells in Japan. J. Power Sources 61(1–2), 73–77 (1996)
Miyake, Y.; Akiyama, Y.; Hamada, A.; Itoh, Y.; Oda, K.; Sumi, S.: Status of fuel cells R and D activities at Sanyo. J. Power Sources 61, 155–160 (1996)
Hu, Y.; Jiang, Y.; Jensen, J.O.; Cleemann, L.N.; Li, Q.: Catalyst evaluation for oxygen reduction reaction in concentrated phosphoric acid at elevated temperatures. J. Power Sources 375, 77–81 (2018)
Chen, X.; Wang, Y.; Zhao, Y.; Zhou, Y.: A study of double functions and load matching of a phosphoric acid fuel cell/heat-driven refrigerator hybrid system. Energy 101, 359–365 (2016)
Ito, H.: Economic and environmental assessment of phosphoric acid fuel cell-based combined heat and power system for an apartment complex. Int. J. Hydrog. Energy 42(23), 15449–15463 (2017)
Wang, H.; Chang, C.; Huang, Y.; Su, Y.; Tseng, F.: A high-yield and ultra-low-temperature methanol reformer integratable with phosphoric acid fuel cell (PAFC). Energy 133, 1142–1152 (2017)
Wu, M.; Zhang, H.; Zhao, J.; Wang, F.; Yuan, J.: Performance analyzes of an integrated phosphoric acid fuel cell and thermoelectric device system for power and cooling cogeneration. Int. J. Refrig. 89, 61–69 (2018)
Fuel cell & Hydrogen Energy Association. http://www.fchea.org. Accessed 1 June 2018
Shipboard testing now under way for FellowSHIP project. Fuel Cells Bulletin, no. 11 (2009)
Baron, R.; Wejrzanowski, T.; Szabłowski, Ł.; Szczęśniak, A.; Milewski, J.; Fung, K.: Dual ionic conductive membrane for molten carbonate fuel cell. Int. J. Hydrog. Energy 43(16), 8100–8104 (2018)
Jienkulsawad, P.; Saebea, D.; Patcharavorachot, Y.; Kheawhom, S.; Arpornwichanop, A.: Analysis of a solid oxide fuel cell and a molten carbonate fuel cell integrated system with different configurations. Int. J. Hydrog. Energy 43(2), 932–942 (2018)
Czelej, K.; Cwieka, K.; Colmenares, J.C.; Kurzydlowski, K.J.: Catalytic activity of NiO cathode in molten carbonate fuel cells. Appl. Catal. B Environ. 222, 73–75 (2018)
De Lorenzo, G.; Milewski, J.; Fragiacomo, P.: Theoretical and experimental investigation of syngas-fueled molten carbonate fuel cell for assessment of its performance. Int. J. Hydrog. Energy 42(48), 28816–28828 (2017)
Milewski, J.; Futyma, K.; Szczęśniak, A.: Molten carbonate fuel cell operation under high concentrations of SO2 on the cathode side. Int. J. Hydrog. Energy 41(41), 18769–18777 (2016)
Fuel cell mine locomotive passes initial tests. Fuel Cells Bull. 2002(10), 5–6 (2002)
Consortium to develop fuel cell locomotive. Fuel Cells Bull. 2003(10), 2 (2003)
Design milestone for fuel cell locomotive. Fuel Cells Bull. 2004(4), 6 (2004)
Contract to develop fuel cell power for rail vehicle. Fuel Cells Bull. (11), 7 (2005)
Japanese train company to test world’s first fuel cell passenger train. Fuel Cells Bull. (6), 4 (2006)
BNSF, Vehicle Projects demonstrate fuel cell switch locomotive I. Fuel Cells Bull. (8), 4 (2009)
US–SA partnership to produce five fuel cell mine locomotives. Fuel Cells Bull. (2), 4 (2012)
Anglo American fuel cell mine locomotive in South Africa. Fuel Cells Bull. (6), 12 (2012)
Ballard signs Chinese deal to develop fuel cell modules for trams. Fuel Cells Bull. (7), 4–5 (2015)
Latvian Railways plan locomotives powered with Ballard fuel cells. Fuel Cells Bull. (9), 6 (2016)
Alstom unveils Coradia iLint hydrogen fuel cell powered train for European regional market. Fuel Cells Bulle. 9, 1 (2016)
Indian Railways in project to develop fuel cell powered train. Fuel Cells Bull. (3), 4–5 (2018)
Hoffrichter, A.; Fisher, P.; Tutcher, J.; Hillmansen, S.; Roberts, C.: Performance evaluation of the hydrogen-powered prototype locomotive ‘Hydrogen Pioneer’. J. Power Sources 250, 120–127 (2014)
Peng, F.; Chen, W.; Liu, Z.; Li, Q.; Dai, C.: System integration of China ’ s first proton exchange membrane fuel cell locomotive. Int. J. Hydrog. Energy 39, 13886–13893 (2014)
Fernandez, L.M.; Garcia, P.; Garcia, C.A.; Torreglosa, J.P.; Jurado, F.: Comparison of control schemes for a fuel cell hybrid tramway integrating two dc/dc converters. Int. J. Hydrog. Energy 35(11), 5731–5744 (2010)
Fernandez, L.M.; Garcia, P.; Andrés, C.; Jurado, F.: Hybrid electric system based on fuel cell and battery and integrating a single dc/dc converter for a tramway. Energy Convers. Manag. 52(5), 2183–2192 (2011)
Guo, L.; Yedavalli, K.; Zinger, D.: Design and modeling of power system for a fuel cell hybrid switcher locomotive. Energy Convers. Manag. 52(2), 1406–1413 (2011)
Torreglosa, J.P.; Jurado, F.; Garcı, P.; Ferna’ndez, L.M.: Application of cascade and fuzzy logic based control in a model of a fuel-cell hybrid tramway. Eng. Appl. Artif. Intell. 24, 1–11 (2011)
Torreglosa, J.P.; Jurado, F.; Garcı’a, P.; Ferna’ndez, L.M.: Hybrid fuel cell and battery tramway control based on an equivalent consumption minimization strategy. Control Eng. Pract. 19, 1182–1194 (2011)
Li, Q.; Chen, W.; Liu, Z.; Li, M.; Ma, L.: Development of energy management system based on a power sharing strategy for a fuel cell-battery-supercapacitor hybrid tramway. J. Power Sources 279, 267–280 (2015)
Li, Q.; Yang, H.; Han, Y.; Li, M.; Chen, W.: A state machine strategy based on droop control for an energy management system of PEMFC-battery- supercapacitor hybrid tramway. Int. J. Hydrog. Energy 41, 16148–16159 (2016)
Zhang, G.; Chen, W.; Li, Q.: Modeling, optimization and control of a FC/battery hybrid locomotive based on ADVISOR. Int. J. Hydrog. Energy 42, 18568–18583 (2017)
Hong, Z.; Li, Q.; Han, Y.; Shang, W.; Zhu, Y.; Chen, W.: An energy management strategy based on dynamic power factor for fuel cell/battery hybrid locomotive. Int. J. Hydrog. Energy 43, 3261–3272 (2018)
Fragiacomo, P.; Francesco, P.: Energy performance of a fuel cell hybrid system for rail vehicle propulsion. In: September 2017, Lecce, Italy 72nd Conference of the Italian Thermal Machines Engineering Association, vol. 126, pp. 1051–1058 (2017)
Zhang, W.: Comparison of daily operation strategies for a fuel cell/battery tram. Int. J. Hydrog. Energy 42, 18532–18539 (2017)
Li, Q.; Chen, W.; Liu, Z.; Guo, A.; Huang, J.: Nonlinear multivariable modeling of locomotive proton exchange membrane fuel cell system. Int. J. Hydrog. Energy 39, 13777–13786 (2014)
Miller, A.R.; Peters, J.; Smith, B.E.; Velev, O.A.: Analysis of fuel cell hybrid locomotives. J. Power Sources 157, 855–861 (2006)
Schroeder, D.J.; Majumdar, P.: Feasibility analysis for solid oxide fuel cells as a power source for railroad road locomotives. Int. J. Hydrog. Energy 35(20), 11308–11314 (2010)
Martinez, A.S.; Brouwer, J.; Samuelsen, G.S.: Feasibility study for SOFC-GT hybrid locomotive power: Part I. Development of a dynamic 3.5 MW SOFC-GT FORTRAN model. J. Power Sources, 213(x), 203–217 (2012)
Martinez, A.S.; Brouwer, J.; Samuelsen, G.S.: Feasibility study for SOFC-GT hybrid locomotive power part II System packaging and operating route simulation. J. Power Sources 213(X), 358–374 (2012)
Zhang, W.: Comparison study on life-cycle costs of different trams powered by fuel cell systems and others. Int. J. Hydrog. Energy 41, 16577–16591 (2016)
Haseli, Y.; Naterer, G.F.; Dincer, I.Ã.: Comparative assessment of greenhouse gas mitigation of hydrogen passenger trains. Int. J. Hydrog. Energy 33, 1788–1796 (2008)
Meegahawatte, D.; Hillmansen, S.; Roberts, C.; Falco, M.; Mcgordon, A.; Jennings, P.: Analysis of a fuel cell hybrid commuter railway vehicle. J. Power Sources 195(23), 7829–7837 (2010)
Marin, G.D.; Naterer, G.F.; Gabriel, K.: Rail transportation by hydrogen versus electrification—Case study for Ontario Canada, I : propulsion and storage. Int. J. Hydrog. Energy 35, 6084–6096 (2010)
Martinez, A.S.; Brouwer, J.; Samuelsen, G.S.: Comparative analysis of SOFC-GT freight locomotive fueled by natural gas and diesel with onboard reformation. Appl. Energy 148, 421–438 (2015)
Ortech Environmental, Air Quality Assessment Report for GO Transit Georgetown, Mississauga (2009)
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Siddiqui, O., Dincer, I. A Review on Fuel Cell-Based Locomotive Powering Options for Sustainable Transportation. Arab J Sci Eng 44, 677–693 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s13369-018-3607-2
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s13369-018-3607-2