Abstract
Pupil groupings within classrooms are a constant social pedagogic factor which effect participation and learning. The grouping of pupils provides a dynamic relationship between learning tasks and the classroom context within which learning takes place. This paper explores types of pupil groupings found in secondary school classrooms related to themes of group size and composition, learning task, group interaction and teacher presence. The paper questions how classroom groupings may be related to the circumstances that promote or inhibit school learning. Previous studies concerning classroom grouping in secondary schools have been dominated by ability or attainment level of the child. The approach and review presented in this study advances a new and more extensive understanding of social pedagogic activity within classrooms. Empirically, a novel classroom “mapping” method with follow-up questions for teachers was used to identify within-class grouping characteristics of children aged 12 and 15 years (in school Years 7 and 10), across curriculum subjects (English, mathematics, science and humanities) in secondary schools. Maps were drawn for 250 classrooms and explained by teachers from 47 schools in England. Results identified that a variety of groupings were found in most classes. Use of particular groupings related to phase of lesson and, to some extent, curriculum. The results showed: little pedagogic association with learning task or interaction; teacher presence associated with control of knowledge; and group composition dominated by stereotypical adolescent friendships. Discussion considers the social pedagogic potential of grouping (with regard to relational capital), control of knowledge and social structure of the classroom attributed to the teacher, and patterns of grouping that may be associated with polarisation in the classroom.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
G. Allport (1954) The nature of prejudice Addison-Wesley Reading, Mass
S. Ball (1981) Beachside comprehensive: A case study of secondary schooling Cambridge University Press Cambridge
N. Bennett (1994) Co-operative Learning P. Kutnick C. Rogers (Eds) Groups in schools. Cassell London 50–65
N. Bennett C. Desforge A. Cockburn B. Wilkinson (1984) The quality of pupil learning experiences LEA London
E. Baines P. Blatchford P. Kutnick (2003) ArticleTitleChanges in grouping practices over primary and secondary school International Journal of Educational Research. 39 9–84 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0883-0355(03)00071-5
Blatchford, P., Kutnick, P., & Baines, E.(1999). The nature and use of classroom groups in primary schools. Final report to ESRC, held at British Library
P. Blatchford E. Baines P. Kutnick C. Martin (2001) ArticleTitleClassroom contexts: Connections between class size and within class grouping British Journal of Educational Psychology. 71 283–302 Occurrence Handle10.1348/000709901158523
P. Blatchford P. Kutnick E. Baines M. Galton (2003) ArticleTitleTowards a social pedagogy of classroom group work International Journal of Educational Research. 39 153–172
J. Boaler (1997) ArticleTitleSetting, social class and survival of the quickest British Journal of Educational Research. 23 IssueID5 575–596
J. Boaler D. Wilam M. Brown (2000) ArticleTitleStudents’ experience of ability grouping disaffection, polarisation and the construction of failure British Journal of Educational Research. 26 IssueID5 631–648
S. Bossert B. Barnett N. Filby (1985) Grouping and instructional organisation P. Peterson L. Wilkinson M. Hallinan (Eds) The social context of instruction. Academic Press Orlando, Fla 39–52
P. Bourdieu J.C. Passeron (1977) Reproduction in education, society and culture Sage London
S. Bowles H. Gintis (1976) Schooling in capitalist America: Educational reforms and the contradictions Routledge & Kegan Paul London
W. Damon E. Phelps (1989) ArticleTitleCritical distinctions among three approaches to peer education International Journal of Educational Research. 13 9–19 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0883-0355(89)90013-X
H. Daniels (2001) Vygotsky and pedagogy Routledge/Falmer London
U. Dahllof (1971) Ability Grouping, content validity and curriculum process analysis Teachers College Press New York
Y. Dar N. Resh (1986) Classroom composition and pupil achievement Gordon & Breach New York
M. Denscombe (1998) The good research guide Open University Press Buckingham
M. Deutsch (1949) ArticleTitleA theory of cooperation and competition Human Relations 2 129–152
InstitutionalAuthorNameDfEE (1997) ‘ Excellence in schools’ – white paper DfEE London
R. Dreeben (1985) First-Grade reading groups: Their formation and change P. Peterson L. Wilkinson M. Hallinan (Eds) The social context of instruction. Academic Press Orlando, Fla 69–84
J.F. Eggleston M.J. Galton (1976) Processes and products of science teaching Macmillan London
N.A. Flanders (1970) Analyzing teaching behavior Addison-Wesley London
J. Floud A.H. Halsey (1957) ArticleTitleSocial class, intelligence tests and selection for secondary schools British journal of Sociology. 8 33–39 Occurrence Handle10.2307/587403
M. Fuller (1984) Black girls in a London comprehensive M. Hammersley P. Woods (Eds) Life in school Open University Press Milton Keynes 77–88
M.J. Galton (1990) Grouping and group-work C. Rogers P. Kutnick (Eds) The social psychology of the primary school. Routledge London
M.J. Galton L. Hargreaves C. Comber D. Wall A. Pell (1999) Inside the primary classroom: 20 years on Routledge London
Galton M., Gray J., Rudduck J. (2003). Transfer and transitions in the middle years of schooling (7–14): Continuities and discontinuities in learning. DfES, London
R. Gillies (2003) ArticleTitleStructuring cooperative group work in classrooms International Journal of Educational Research. 39 35–49 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0883-0355(03)00072-7
I.F. Goodson J.M. Managan (1995) ArticleTitleSubject cultures and the introduction of classroom computers British Educational Research Journal. 25 IssueID5 613–628
S. Hallam I. Toutounji (1996) What do we know about the grouping of pupils by ability? Institute of Education London
M. Hammersley (1990) ArticleTitleAn evaluation of two studies of gender imbalance in primary classrooms British Educational Research Journal. 16 125–143
Hanifan L.J (1916). The Rural School Community Centre, Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, Vol.67 pp. 130–138; cited in R. Putnam (2000) Bowling alone. New York: Simon & Schuster
D. Hargreaves (1967) Social relations in a secondary school Routledge & Kegan Paul London
N. Hastings K. Chantry (2002) Reorganising primary classroom learning Open University Press Buckingham
Howe C.J. (1997). Gender and classroom Interaction: A research review. SCRE, v
C. Howe A. Tolmie (2003) ArticleTitleGroup work in primary school science: Discussion, consensus and guidance from experts International Journal of Educational Research. 39 51–72 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0883-0355(03)00073-9
J. Ireson S. Hallam (1999) ArticleTitleRaising standards: Is ability grouping the answer? Oxford Review of Education. 25 343–358 Occurrence Handle10.1080/030549899104026
J. Ireson S. Hallam (2001) Ability grouping in education Paul Chapman London
A. Jackson P. Kutnick A. Kington (2001) ArticleTitlePrinciples and practical grouping for the use of drill and practice programs Journal of Computer Assisted Learning. 17 130–141 Occurrence Handle10.1046/j.0266-4909.2001.00166.x
D. Johnson R. Johnson (1987) Learning together and alone Prentice-Hall Englewood Cliffs
M. Jones T. Greig (1994) ArticleTitleSilent sixth grade students: Characteristics, achievement and teacher expectations The Elementary School Journal. 95 169–182 Occurrence Handle10.1086/461797
J.A. Kulik C.-L.C. Kulik (1992) ArticleTitleMeta-analytic findings on grouping programs Gifted Child Quarterly. 36 73–77
P. Kutnick (1994) Use and effectiveness of groups in classrooms P. Kutnick C. Rogers (Eds) Groups in schools. Cassell London 13–36
P. Kutnick P. Blatchford E. Baines (2002) ArticleTitlePupil groupings in primary school classrooms; sites for learning and social pedagogy? British Educational Research Journal. 28 IssueID2 187–206 Occurrence Handle10.1080/01411920120122149
P. Kutnick P. Blatchford E. Baines H. Maclntyre H. Clark (2005) ArticleTitleTeachers’ understandings of the relationship between within-class (pupil) grouping and learning in secondary schools Educational Research. 47 IssueID1 1–24 Occurrence Handle10.1080/0013188042000337532
P. Kutnick A. Kington (2005) ArticleTitleChildren’s friendships and learning in school; cognitive enhancement through social interaction? British Journal of Educational Psychology. 75 1–19 Occurrence Handle10.1348/000709904X24591
C. Lacey (1974) Hightown Grammar: The school as a social system Manchester University Press Manchester
P. Light K. Littleton (1994) Cognitive approaches to group work P. Kutnick C. Rogers (Eds) Groups in schools. Cassell London 87–103
B. Lloyd G. Duveen (1992) Gender identities and education Wheatsheaf Harvester London
P. Mahony (1985) Schools for boys Hutchinson London
P. Mahony I. Hextall (2001) ArticleTitleTesting, testing: Teacher assessment in England Teaching Education. 12 IssueID1 35–47 Occurrence Handle10.1080/10476210124328
W. Maxwell (1990) The Nature of Friendship in the Primary School C. Rogers P. Kutnick (Eds) The social psychology of the primary school. Routledge London 169–198
N. Mercer (2000) Words and Minds: How we use language to think together Routledge London
E. Millard (1997) Differently literate Falmer Press London
V. Morgan S. Dunn (1988) ArticleTitleChameleons in the classroom: Visible and invisible children in nursery and infant classes Educational Review. 40 3–12
P. Murphy (2000) Gender identities and the process of negotiation in social interaction R. Joiner K. Littleton D. Faulkner D. Meill (Eds) Rethinking collaborative learning. Free Association Books London 139–159
D. Myhill (2002) ArticleTitleBad boys and good girls British Educational Research Journal. 28 IssueID3 339–352 Occurrence Handle10.1080/01411920220137430
A. Pollard (1985) The social world of the primary school Holt, Rinehart and Winston London
A. Pollard P. Triggs P. Broadfoot E. McNess M. Osborn (2000) What pupils say: Changing policy and practice in primary education Continuum London
R. Putnam (2000) Bowling alone; The collapse and revival of American community Simon & Schuster New York
R. Rosenthal L. Jacobson (1968) Pygmalion in the classroom Holt, Rinehart & Winston New York
J. Rudduck R. Chaplain G. Wallace (Eds) (1996) School improvement; what can pupils tell us? Fulton London
R. Slavin (1990a) ArticleTitleAchievement effects of ability grouping in secondary schools – a best evidence synthesis Review of Educational Research. 60 IssueID3 471–499
R. Slavin (1990b) Co-operative learning C. Rogers P. Kutnick (Eds) The social psychology of the primary school. Routledge London 226–246
H. Tajfel (1981) Human groups and social categories Cambridge University Press Cambridge
Tolmie, A., Howe, C., Duchak, V., & Rattray, C. (1998). Group Work and the Integration of Conceptual and Procedural Knowledge in Primary Science. Paper at BPS Developmental Section Conference, Lancaster University
K. Topping (1983) Education systems for disruptive adolescents Croom Helm London
L. Vygotsky (1978) Mind in society: The development of higher mental processes Harvard University Press Cambridge
N. Webb (1989) ArticleTitlePeer interaction and learning small groups International Journal of Educational Research. 13 21–39
N.M. Webb G.P. Baxter L. Thompson (1997) ArticleTitleTeachers’ Grouping Practices in Fifth Grade Science Classrooms The Elementary School Journal. 98 IssueID2 91–113 Occurrence Handle10.1086/461886
N. Webb A. Mastergeorge (2003) ArticleTitlePromoting effective helping behaviour in peer-directed groups International Journal of Educational Research. 39 73–97 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S0883-0355(03)00074-0
R. Wegrif N. Mercer L. Dawes (1999) ArticleTitleFrom socio interaction to individual reasoning Learning and Instruction. 9 IssueID6 493–516
D. Wood (1998) How Children Think andi learn: The social contexts of cognitive development EditionNumber2 Blackwell Oxford
M. Young (Eds) (1971) Knowledge and control: New directions for the sociology of education Collier-Macmillan London
M. Younger M. Warrington J. Williams (1999) ArticleTitleThe gender gap and classroom interactions; reality and rhetoric British Journal of Sociology of Education. 20 325–344
R.J. Zajac W.W. Hartup (1997) ArticleTitleFriends as co-workers: research review and classroom implications Elementary School Journal. 98 IssueID1 3–13 Occurrence Handle10.1086/461881
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
*Research reported was part of the GRIS (The Nature and Use of Within Class Groupings in Secondary Schools) project funded by the ESRC, grant number R000238172.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kutnick, P., Blatchford, P. & Baines, E. Grouping of Pupils in Secondary School Classrooms: Possible Links between Pedagogy and Learning. Soc Psychol Educ 8, 349–374 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11218-005-1212-1
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11218-005-1212-1