Abstract
This paper provides a critique and re-evaluation of the way that ethics is understood and promoted within mainstream Human Resource Management (HRM) discourse. We argue that the ethics located within this discourse focuses on bolstering the relevance of HRM as a key contributor to organizational strategy, enhancing an organization’s sense of moral legitimacy and augmenting organizational control over employee behaviour and subjectivity. We question this discourse in that it subordinates the ethics of the employment relationship to managerial prerogative. In response, we suggest a different model of the relationship between ethics and HRM—one that finds the possibility of ethics in the contestation and destabilization of HRM. Such ethics arises through resistance to moral normalization and the constraint of freedom and difference. The contribution of our paper is in theorising the possibilities of a relationship between ethics and HRM that does not place HRM at its centre, as chief intermediary of the ethics of the employment relationship, but rather sees HRM as being a powerful player in a set of what Mouffe calls ‘agonistic’ socio-ethical relations.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Ackroyd, S., & Thompson, P. (1999). Organizational misbehaviour. London: Sage.
Adler, N. J., & Bartholomew, S. (1992). Academic and professional communities of discourse: Generating knowledge on transnational human resource management. Journal of International Business Studies, 23(3), 551–569.
Alvesson, M. (2009). Critical perspectives on critical HRM. In J. Storey, P. White, & D. Ulrich (Eds.), The Routledge companion to human resource management (pp. 52–68). London: Routledge.
Anderson, P. (1967). The limits and possibilities of trade union action. In R. Blackburn & A. Cockburn (Eds.), The incompatibles: Trade union militancy and consensus (pp. 263–280). Penguin: Harmondsworth.
Bamber, G. J., Gittell, J. H., Kochan, T. A., & von Nordenflycht, A. (2009). Up in the air: How airlines can improve performance by engaging their employees. Ithaca: ILR Press.
Barratt, E. (1999). Justice in the workplace?: Normative ethics and the critique of human resource management. Personnel Review, 28(4), 307–318.
Bauman, Z. (1993). Postmodern ethics. London: Blackwell.
Becker, B., & Gerhart, B. (1996). The impact of human resource management on organizational performance: Progress and prospects. Academy of Management Journal, 39(4), 779–801.
Beer, M., Spector, B., Lawrence, P. R., Quinn Mills, D., & Walton, R. E. (1984). Managing human assets. New York: Free Press.
Boling, T. E. (1978). The management ethics “crisis”: An organizational perspective. Academy of Management Review, 3(2), 360–365.
Boxall, P., & Purcell, J. (2011). Strategy and human resource management (3rd ed.). London: Palgrave.
Bratton, J., & Gold, J. (2007). Human resource management: Theory and practice (4th ed.). Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Caldwell, C., Truong, D. X., Linh, P. T., & Tuan, A. (2010). Strategic human resource management as ethical stewardship. Journal of Business Ethics, 98(1), 171–182.
Claydon, T. (2000). Employee participation and involvement. In D. Winstanley & J. Goodall (Eds.), Ethical issues in contemporary human resource management (pp. 208–244). London: MacMillan.
Claydon, T., & Doyle, M. (1996). Trusting me, trusting you? The ethics of employee empowerment. Personnel Review, 25(6), 13–25.
Collinson, D. (1999). ‘Surviving the rigs’: Safety and surveillance on North Sea Oil installations. Organization Studies, 20(4), 579–600.
Critchley, S. (2007). Infinitely demanding: ethics of commitment, politics of resistance. London: Verso.
Critchley, S., & James, S. (2009). Infinitely demanding anarchism: An interview with Simon Critchley. Perspectives: International Postgraduate Journal of Philosophy, 2(1), 3–21.
Crossley, N. (2003). Even newer social movements? Anti-corporate protests, capitalist crises and the remoralization of society. Organization, 10(2), 287–305.
Delbridge, R., & Keenoy, T. (2010). Beyond managerialism? International Journal of Human Resource Management, 21(6), 799–817.
Derrida, J. (1978/2001). Writing and difference. London: Routledge.
Diprose, R. (2003). Corporeal generosity: On giving with Nietzsche, Merleau-Ponty, and Levinas. New York: SUNY.
Feldman, G. (2007). Putting Uncle Milton to Bed: Re-examining Milton Friedman’s essay on the social responsibility of business. Labour Studies Journal, 32(2), 125–141.
Fleming, P. (2009). Cultural politics of work: New forms of informal control. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Fleming, P., & Sewell, G. (2002). Looking for the good soldier, Ŝvejk: Alternative modalities of resistance in the contemporary workplace. Sociology, 36(4), 857–873.
Fleming, P., & Spicer, A. (2004). ‘You can checkout anytime, but you can never leave’: Spatial boundaries in a high commitment organization. Human Relations, 57(1), 75–94.
Fombrun, C., Tichy, N. M., & DeVanna, M. A. (Eds.). (1984). Strategic human resource management. New York: Wiley.
Ford, J., & Harding, N. (2003). Invoking Satan or the ethics of the employment contract. Journal of Management Studies, 40(5), 1131–1150.
Geare, A., Edgar, F., & McAndrew, I. (2006). Employment relationships: Ideology and HRM practice. The International Journal of HRM, 17(7), 1190–1208.
Gilley, J. W., Anderson, S. K., & Gilley, A. (2008). Human resource management as a champion for corporate ethics: Moving towards ethical integration and acculturation in the HR function and profession. In S. A. Quattro & R. R. Sims (Eds.), Executive ethics: Ethical dilemmas and challenges for the C-suite (pp. 215–228). Charlotte, NC: Information Age Publishing.
Godard, J. (2001). High performance and the transformation of work? The implications of alternative work practices for the experience and outcomes of work. Industrial and Labor Relations Review, 54(4), 776–805.
Greenwood, M. R. (2002). Ethics and HRM: A review and conceptual analysis. Journal of Business Ethics, 36(3), 261–278.
Greenwood, M., & de Cieri, H. (2007). Stakeholder theory and the ethics Of HRM. In A. F. Pinnington, R. Macklin, & T. Campbell (Eds.), Human Resource Management: Ethics and employment (pp. 119–136). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Guest, D. E. (1987). Human resource management and industrial relations. Journal of Management Studies, 24(5), 503–521.
Guest, D. E. (1994). Organizational psychology and human resource management: Towards a European approach. European Work and Organizational Psychologist, 4(3), 251–270.
Guest, D. E. (1995). Human resource management: The workers’ verdict. Human Resource Management Journal, 9(3), 5–25.
Guest, D. E. (2011). Human resource management and performance: Still searching for some answers. Human Resource Management Journal, 21(1), 3–13.
Guest, D. E., & Bryson, A. (2009). From industrial relations to human resource management: The changing role of the personnel function. In K. Whitfield, A. Bryson, J. Forth, & W. Brown (Eds.), The evolution of the modern workplace (pp. 120–150). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hardy, C., & Clegg, S. R. (2006). Some are call it power. In S. R. Clegg, C. Hardy, T. B. Lawrence, & W. R. Nord (Eds.), The Sage handbook of organization studies (2nd ed., pp. 754–775). London: Sage.
Hart, T. J. (1993). Human resource management: Time to exercise the militant tendency. Employee Relations, 15(3), 29–36.
Hendry, J. (2004). Between ethics and enterprise: Business and management in a bimoral society. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Hond, F. D., & Bakker, F. G. A. (2007). Ideologically motivated activism: How activist groups influence corporate social change activities. The Academy of Management Review, 32(3), 901–924.
Hyman, R. (1971). Marxism and the sociology of trade unionism. London: Pluto Press.
Janssens, M., & Steyaert, C. (2009). HRM and performance: A plea for reflexivity in HRM studies. Journal of Management Studies, 46(1), 143–155.
Johnstone, S., Wilkinson, A., & Ackers, P. (2004). Partnership paradoxes: A case study of an energy company. Employee Relations, 26(4), 353–376.
Keenoy, T. (1997). HRMism and the language of re-presentation. Journal of Management Studies, 34(5), 825–841.
Keenoy, T. (1999). HRM as hologram: A polemic. Journal of Management Studies, 36(1), 1–23.
Knights, D., & McCabe, D. (1999). ‘Are there no limits to authority?’: TQM and organizational power. Organization Studies, 20(2), 197–224.
Lawler, E. E. (1986). High-involvement management. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Legge, K. (1995). Human resource management: Rhetorics and realities. London: Macmillan.
Legge, K. (1998). The morality of HRM. In C. Mabey, D. Skinner, & To. Clark (Eds.), Experiencing human resource management. London: Sage.
Legge, K., & Exley, M. (1975). Authority, ambiguity and adaptation: The personnel specialist’s dilemma. Industrial Relations Journal, 6(3), 51–65.
Levinas, E. (1991). Totality and infinity. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Lowry, D. (2006). HR managers as ethical decision-makers: Mapping the terrain. Asia Pacific Journal of Human Resource Management, 44(2), 171–183.
Macklin, R. (2006). The moral autonomy of human resource managers. Asia Pacific Journal of Human Resources, 44(2), 211–221.
Maravelias, C. (2009). Make your presence known! Post-bureaucracy. HRM and the fear of being unseen. Personnel Review, 38(4), 349–365.
Marks, A., Findlay, P., Hine, J., McKinlay, A., & Thompson, P. (1998). The politics of partnership? Innovation in employment relations in the Scottish Spirits Industry. British Journal of Industrial Relations, 36(2), 209–226.
McCabe, D. (2007). Individualization at work? Subjectivity, team working and anti-unionism. Organization, 14(2), 243–266.
McMurray, R., Pullen, A., & Rhodes, C. (2011). Ethical subjectivity and politics in organizations: A case of health care tendering. Organization, 18(4), 541–561.
Meyer, J. P., & Allen, N. J. (1991). A three component conceptualization of organizational commitment. Human Resource Management, 1, 61–89.
Miller, P. (1996). Strategy and the ethical management of human resources. Human Resource Management Journal, 6(1), 5–26.
Mouffe, C. (1996). Dimensions of radical democracy: Pluralism, citizenship, community. London: Verso.
Mouffe, C. (2000a). Deliberative democracy or agonistic pluralism. Vienna: Institute for Advanced Studies.
Mouffe, C. (2000b). Deliberative democracy or agonistic pluralism. Vienna: Institute for Advanced Studies.
Mouffe, C. (2000c). The democratic paradox. London: Verso.
Mouffe, C. (2005). On the political. London: Routledge.
Mueller, F., & Carter, C. (2005). The ‘HRM project’ and managerialism: Or why some discourses are more equal than others. Journal of Organizational Change Management, 18(4), 369–382.
Paauwe, J. (2004). HRM and performance: Achieving long-term viability. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Parker, M. (2003). Against management. Cambridge: Polity.
Parker, M. (2006). The counter culture of organisation: Towards a cultural studies of representations of work. Consumption, Markets and Culture, 9(1), 1–15.
Purcell, J., & Ahlstrand, B. (1989). Corporate strategy and the management of employee relations in the multi-divisional company. British Journal of Industrial Relations, 27, 396–417.
Ramsay, H., Scholarios, D., & Harley, B. (2000). Employees and high performance work systems: Testing inside the black box. British Journal of Industrial Relations, 38(4), 501–531.
Rhodes, C., & Westwood, R. (2008). Critical representations of work and organization in popular culture. London: Routledge.
Roscigno, V. J., Hodson, R., & Lopez, S. H. (2009). Workplace incivilities: The role of interest conflicts, social closure and organizational chaos. Work, Employment & Society, 23(4), 747–773.
Scott, E. (2005). The ethics of human resource management. In J. W. Budd & J. G. Scoville (Eds.), The ethics of human resources and industrial relations (pp. 173–202). Champaign, IL: Labour and Employment Relations Association, University of Illinois.
Simmons, J. (2003). Balancing performance, accountability and equity in stakeholder relationships: Towards more socially responsible HR practice. Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management, 10(3), 129–140.
Simmons, J. (2004). Managing in the post-managerialist era: Towards socially responsible corporate governance. Management Decision, 42(3/4), 601–611.
Simmons, J. (2008). Ethics and morality in human resource management. Social Responsibility Journal, 4(1/2), 8–23.
Sloan, K., & Gavin, J. H. (2010). Human resource management: Meeting the ethical obligations of the function. Business and Society Review, 115(1), 57–74.
Sparrow, P., & Hiltrop, J.-M. (1994). European human resource management in transition. Hemel Hempstead: Prentice Hall.
Spicer, a., & Bohm, S. (2007). Moving management: Theorizing struggles against the hegemony of management. Organization Studies, 28(11), 1667–1698.
Storey, J. (1989). New perspectives on human resource management. London: Routledge.
Storey, J. (1992). Developments in the management of human resources. Oxford: Blackwell.
Styhre, A. (2001). Kaizen, ethics, and care of the operations: Management after empowerment. Journal of Management Studies, 38(6), 795–810.
ten Bos, R. (2003). Business ethics, accounting and the fear of melancholy. Organization, 10(2), 267–285.
Thompson, P. (2011). The trouble with HRM. Human Resource Management Journal, 21(4), 355–367.
Thompson, P., & Ackroyd, S. (1995). All quiet on the workplace front? A critique of recent trends in British Industrial Sociology. Sociology, 29(4), 615–633.
Townley, B. (1994). Reframing human resource management: Power, ethics and the subject at work. London: Sage.
Vaara, E., & Tienari, J. (2002). Justification, legitimization and naturalization of mergers and acquisitions: A critical discourse analysis of media texts. Organization, 9(2), 275–304.
Walton, R. (1985). From control to commitment in the workplace. Harvard Business Review, 63(2), 77–84.
Watson, T. J. (1995). In search of HRM: Beyond the rhetoric and reality distinction or the case of the dog that didn’t bark. Personnel Review, 24(4), 6–16.
Winstanley, D., & Woodall, J. (2000a). The ethical dimension of human resource management. Human Resource Management Journal, 10(2), 5–20.
Winstanley, D., & Woodall, J. (2000b). Ethical issues in contemporary human resource management. Basingstoke: Palgrave.
Winstanley, D., Woodall, J., & Heery, E. (1996). Business ethics and human resource management: Themes And issues. Personnel Review, 25(6), 5–12.
Wood, S. J., & Wall, T. D. (2007). Work enrichment and employee voice in human resource management-performance studies. International Journal of Human Resource Management, 18(7), 1335–1372.
Wright Mills, C. (1948). The new men of power: America’s labor leaders. New York: Harcourt, Brace.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Rhodes, C., Harvey, G. Agonism and the Possibilities of Ethics for HRM. J Bus Ethics 111, 49–59 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-012-1441-0
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-012-1441-0