Abstract
The paper reviews the fundamental components of stochastic and motorunit-based models of the surface electromyogram (SEMG). Stochastic models used in ergonomics and kinesiology consider the SEMG to be a stochastic process whose amplitude is related to the level of muscle activation and whose power spectral density reflects muscle conduction velocity. Motor-unit-based models for describing the spatio-temporal distribution of individual motor-unit action potentials throughout the limb are quite robust, making it possible to extract precise information about motor-unit architecture from SEMG signals recorded by multi-electrode arrays. Motor-unit-based models have not yet been proven as successful, however, for extracting information about recruitment and firing rates throughout the full range of contraction. The relationship between SEMG and force during natural dynamic movements is much too complex to model in terms of single motor units.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Andreassen, A., andRosenfalck, A. (1981): ‘Relationship of intracellular and extracellular action potentials of skeletal muscle fibers’,CRC Crit. Rev. Bioeng.,7, pp. 267–306
Arabadzhiev, T. I., Dimitrov, G. V., andDimitrova, N. A. (2003): ‘Simulation analysis of the ability to estimate motor unit propagation velocity non-invasively by different two-channel methods and types of electrodes’,J. Electromyogr. Kinesiol.,13, pp. 403–415
Basmajian, J. V., andDe Luca, C. J. (1985): ‘Muscles alive: their functions revealed by electromyography’, 5th edn (William and Wilkins, Baltimore, 1985) p. 185
Bigland-Ritchie, B. (1981): ‘EMG/force relations and fatigue of human voluntary contractions’,Exerc. Sports Sci. Rev.,9, pp. 75–117
Blinowska, A., Verroust, J., andCannet, G. (1979). ‘The determination of motor unit characteristics from the low frequency electromyographic power spectra’,Electromyogr. Clin. Neurophysiol.,19, pp. 281–290
Bonato, P. (2001): ‘Recent advancements in the analysis of dynamic EMG data’,IEEE Eng. Med. Biol. Mag.,20, pp. 29–32
Brezina, V., Orekhova, I. V., andKlaudiusz, R. W. (2000) ‘The nonlinear transform: the dynamic, nonlinear link between motor neuron firing patterns and muscle contraction in rhythmic behaviors’,J. Neurophysiol.,83, pp. 207–231
Christakos, C. N. (1982): ‘A study of the electromyogram using a population stochastic model of skeletal muscle’,Biol. Cybern.,45, pp. 5–12.
Clancy, E. A., Bouchard, S., andRancour, D. (2001): ‘Estimation and application of EMG amplitude during dynamic contraction’,IEEE Eng. Med. Biol. Mag.,20, pp. 47–54
Clarys, J. P., andCabri, J. (1993). ‘Electromyography and the study of sports movements: a review’,J. Sports Sci.,11, pp. 379–448
Clarys, J. P. (2000): ‘Electromyography in sports and occupational settings: an update of its limits and possibilities’,Ergonomics,43, pp. 1750–1762
Day, S. J., andHulliger, M. (2001): ‘Experimental simulation of cat electromyogram: evidence for algebraic summation of motor-unit action-potential trains’,J. Neurophysiol.86, pp. 2144–2158
De Luca, C. (1975): ‘A model for a motor unit train recorded during constant force isometric contractions’,Cybernetics,19, pp. 159–167
De Luca, C. J. (1979). ‘Physiology and mathematics of myoelectric signals’,IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.,26, pp. 313–325
De Luca, C. J. (1997): ‘The use of surface electromyography in biomechanics’,J. Appl. Biomech.,13, pp. 135–163
Dimitrov, G. V., andDimitrova, N. A. (1998): ‘Precise and fast calculation of the motor unit potentials detected by a point and rectangular plate electrode’,Med. Eng. Phys.,20, pp. 374–380
Dimitrova, N. A. (1974): ‘Model of the extracellular potential field of a single striated muscle fiber’,Electromyogr. Clin. Neurophysiol.,14, pp. 53–66
Dimitrova, N. A., andDimitrov, G. V. (1998): ‘Precise and fast MUP calculation as a prerequisite for inverse EMG modeling’, inHermans, H., Stegeman, D., Blok, J., andFreriks, B. (Eds). ‘The state of the art on modeling methods for surface electromyography’ (Roessingh Research Development, Enschede, The Netherlands, 1998), pp. 45–60
Dimitrova, N. A., Dimitrov, D. V., andChikhman, V. N. (1999): ‘Effect of electrode dimensions on motor unit potentials’,Med. Eng. Biol. Phys.,21, pp. 479–486
Dimitrova, N. A., andDimitrov, G. V. (2003): ‘Interpretation of EMG changes with fatigue: facts, pitfalls, and fallacies’,J. Electromyogr. Kinesol.,13, pp. 13–36
Ding, J., Wexler, A. S., andBinder-Macleod, S. A. (2000): ‘Development of a mathematical model that predicts optimal muscle activation patterns by using brief trains’,J. Appl. Physiol.,88, pp. 917–925
Disslehorst-Klug, C., Silny, J., andRau, G. (1997): ‘Improvement of spatial resolution in surface-EMG: a theoretical and experimental comparison of different spatial filters’,IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.,44, pp. 567–574
Disslehorst-Klug, C., Silny, J., andRau, G. (1997): ‘Estimation of the relationship between the noninvasively detected activity of single motor units and their characteristic pathological changes by modelling’,J. Electromyogr. Kinesiol.,8, pp. 325–335
Dowling, J. J. (1997): ‘The use of electromyography for the noninvasive prediction of muscle forces. Current issues’,Sports Med.,24, pp. 82–96
Duchêne, J., andHogrel, J.-Y. (2000): ‘A model of EMG generation’,IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.,47, pp. 192–201
Dumitru, D., King, J. C., andRogers, W. E. (1999): ‘Motor unit action potential components and physiologic duration’,Muscle Nerve,22, pp. 733–741
Enoka, R. M. (1995): ‘Morphological features and activation patterns of motor units’,J. Clin. Neurophysiol.,12, pp. 538–559
Enoka, R. M., andFuglevand, A. J. (2001): ‘Motor unit physiology: some unresolved issues,”Muscle Nerve,24, pp. 4–17
Farina, D., andRainoldi, A. (1999): ‘Compensation of the effect of sub-cutaneous tissue layers on surface EMG: a simulation study’,Med. Eng. Phys.,21, pp. 487–496
Farina, D., andMerletti, R. (2001): ‘A novel approach for precise simulation of the EMG signal detected by surface electrodes’,IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.,48, pp. 637–646
Farina, D., Fattorini, L., Felici, F., andFilligoi, G. (2002a): ‘Nonlinear surface EMG analysis to detect changes of motor unit conduction velocity and synchronization’,J. Appl. Physiol.93, pp. 1753–1763
Farina, D., Merletti, R., Indino, B., Nazzaro, M., andPozzo, M. (2002b). ‘Surface EMG crosstalk between knee extensor muscles: experimental and model results’,Muscle Nerve,26, pp. 681–695
Farina, D., Fosci, M., andMerletti, R. (2002c): ‘Motor unit recruitment strategies investigated by surface EMG variables’,J. Appl. Physiol.,92, pp. 235–247
Farina, D., Arendt-Nielsen, L., Merletti, R., Indino, B., andGraven-Nielsen, T. (2003). ‘Selectivity of spatial filters for surface EMG detection from the tibialis anterior muscle’,IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.,50, pp. 354–364
Ferdjallah, M., Wertsch, J. J., andHarris, G. F. (1999): ‘Effects of surface electrode size on computer simulated surface motor unit potentials’,Electromyogr. Clin. Neurophysiol.,39, pp. 259–265
Fuglevand, A. J., Winter, D. A., andPatla, A. E. (1995): ‘Models of recruitment and rate coding organization in motor-unit pools’,J. Neurophysiol.,70, pp. 2470–2488
Gootzen, T. H., Stegeman, D. F., andVan Oosterom, A. (1991): ‘Finite limb dimensions and finite muscle length in a model for the generation of electromyographic signals’,Electroencephalogr. Clin. Neurophysiol.81, pp. 152–162
Griep, P. A., Boon, K. L., andStegeman, D. F. (1978): ‘A study of the motor unit action potential by means of computer simulation’,Biol. Cybern.,30, pp. 221–230
Griep, P. A., Gielen, F. L., Boom, H. B., Boon, K. L., Hoogstraten, L. L., Pool, C. W., andWallinga-De Jonge, W. (1982): ‘Calculation and registration of the same motor unit action potential’,Electroenceph. Clin. Neurophysiol.,53, pp. 388–404
Guha, S. K., andAnand, S. (1979): ‘Simulation linking EMG power spectra to recruitment and rate coding’,Comput. Biol. Med.,9, pp. 213–221
Gydikov, A., andKosarov, D. (1972): ‘Volume conduction of the potentials from separate motor units in human muscle’,Electromyogr. Clin. Neurophysiol.,12, pp 127–147
Hägg, G. M. (1992): ‘Interpretation of EMG spectral alterations and alteration indexes at sustained contraction’,J. Appl. Physiol.,73, pp. 1211–1217
Hägg, G. M., Luttmann, A., andJäger, M. (2000): ‘Methodologies for evaluating electromyographic field data in ergonomics’,J. Electromyogr. Kinesiol.,10, pp. 301–312
Heckman, C. J., andBinder, M. D. (1991): ‘Computer simulation of the steady-state input-output function of the cat medial gastrocnemius motoneuron pool’,J. Neurophysiol.,65, pp. 952–967
Hefftner, G., Zucchini, W., andJaros, G. G. (1988): ‘The electromyogram (EMG) as a control signal for functional neuromuscular stimulation—Part I: autoregressive modeling as a means of EMG signature discrimination’,IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.,35, pp. 230–237
Helal, J. N., andBouissou, P. (1992): ‘The spatial integration effect of surface electrode detecting myoelectric signal’,IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.,39, pp. 1161–1167
Henneman, E., andMendell, L. M. (1981) ‘Functional organization of motoneuron pool and its inputs’ in ‘Handbook of physiology. The nervous system. Motor control’, Section I, Vol. II, Part 1 (Am. Physiol. Soc., Bethesda, MD, 1981), pp. 423–507
Hermans, H., Stegeman, D., Blok, J., andFreriks, B. (Eds) (1998). ‘The state of the art on modeling methods for surface electromyography’ (Roessingh Research & Development, Enschede, The Netherlands, 1998)
Hof, A. L., andVan Den Berg, J. (1981): ‘EMG to force processing—I: An electrical analogue of the Hill muscle model’,J. Biomech.,14, pp. 747–758
Hof, A. L. (1997): ‘The relationship between electromyogram and muscle force’,Sportverletz Sportschaden,11, pp. 79–86
Hogan, N., andMann, R. W. (1980): ‘Myoelectric signal processing: optimal estimation applied to electromyography—Part I: derivation of the optimal myoprocessor’,IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.,27, pp. 382–395
Hogrel, J.-Y. (2003): ‘Use of surface EMG for studying motor unit recruitment during isometric linear force ramp’,J. Electromyogr. Kinesiol.,13, pp. 417–423
Hornby, T. G., McDonagh, J. C., Reinking, R. M., andStuart, D. G. (2002): ‘Moteneurons: a preferred firing range across vertebrate species’,Muscle Nerve,25, pp. 632–648
Ince, L. P., Leon, M. S., andChristidis, D. (1985): ‘EMG biofeedback with upper extremity musculature for relaxation training: a critical review of the literature’,J. Behav. Ther. Exp. Psychiatry,16, pp. 133–137
Kanosue, K., Yoshida, M., Akazawa, K., andFujii, K. (1979): ‘The number of active motor units and their firing rates in voluntary contractions of human brachialis muscle’,Jap. J. Physiol.,29, pp. 427–443
Karlsson, S., andYu, J. (2000): ‘Estimation of surface electromyogram spectral alteration using reduced-order autoregressive model’,Med. Biol. Eng. Comput.,38, pp. 520–527
Kiryu, T., Saitoh, Y., andIshioka, K. (1992): ‘Investigation on parametric analysis of dynamic EMG signals by a muscle-structured simulation model’,IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.,39, pp. 280–288
Kiryu, T., De Luca, C. J., andSaitoh, Y. (1994): ‘AR modeling of myoelectric interference signals during a ramp contraction’,IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.,41, pp. 1031–1038
Kleine, B. U., Stegeman, D. F., Mund, D., andAnders, C. (2001): ‘Influence of motoneuron firing synchronization on SEMG characteristics in dependence of electrode position’,J. Appl. Physiol.,91, pp. 1588–1599
Kleinpenning, P. H., Gootzen, T. H., Van Oosterom, A., andStegeman, D. F. (1990): ‘The equivalent source description representing the extinction of an action potential at a muscle fiber ending’,Math. Biosci.,101, pp. 41–61
Kleissen, R. F. M., Buurke, J. H., Harlaar, J., andZilvold, G. (1998): ‘Electromyography in the biomechanical analysis of human movement and its clinical application’,Gait Posture,8, pp. 143–158
Kukulka, C. G., andClamann, H. P. (1981): ‘Comparison of the recruitment and discharge properties of motor units in human brachial biceps and adductor pollicis during isometric contractions’,Brain Res.,219, pp. 45–55
Lago, P., andJones, N. B. (1977): ‘Effect of motor-unit firing time statistics on e.m.g. spectra’,Med. Biol. Eng. Comput.,15, pp. 648–655
Lateva, Z. C., Dimitrova, N. A., andDimitrov, G. V. (1993): ‘Effect of recording electrode position along a muscle fibre on surface potential power spectrum’,J. Electromyogr. Kinesiol.,3, 195–204
Lateva, Z. C., McGill, K. C., andBurgar, C. R. (1996): ‘Anatomical and electrophysiological determinants of the human thenar compound muscle action potential’,Muscle Nerve,19, pp. 1457–1468
Lindström, L. H., andMagnusson, R. I. (1977): ‘Interpretation of myoelectric power spectra: a model and its applications’,Proc. IEEE,65, pp. 653–662
Lowery, M. M., Vaughan, C. L., Nolan, P. J., andO'Malley M. J. (2000): ‘Spectral compression of the electromyographic signal due to decreasing muscle fiber conduction velocity’,IEEE Trans. Rehab. Eng.,8, pp. 353–361
Lowery, M. M., Stoykov, N. S., Taflove, A., andKuiken, T. A. (2002): ‘A multiple-layer finite-element model of the surface EMG signal’,IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.,49, pp. 446–454
Lowery, M. M., andO'Malley, M. J. (2003): ‘Analysis and simulation of changes in EMG amplitude during high-level fatiguing contractions’,IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.,50, pp. 1052–1062
Lowery, M. M., Stoykov, N. S., andKuiken, T. A. (2003): ‘Independence of myoelectric control signals examined using a surface EMG model’,IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.,50, pp. 789–793
Lowery, M. M., andO'Malley, M. J. (2003): ‘Analysis and simulation of changes in EMG amplitude during high-level fatiguing contractions’,IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.,50, pp. 1052–1062
Maclsaac, D. T., Parker, P. A., Scott, R. N., Englehart, K. B., andDuffley, C. (2001): ‘Influences of dynamic factors on myoelectric parameters’,IEEE Eng. Med. Biol. Mag.,20, pp. 82–89
Mattson, J. P., Miller, T. A., Poole, D. C., andDelp, M. D. (2002): ‘Fiber composition and oxidative capacity of hamster skeletal muscle’,J. Histochem. Cytochem.,50, pp. 1685–1692
McGill, K. C., Lateva, Z. C., andXiao, S. (2001): ‘A model of the muscle action potential for describing the leading edge, terminal wave, and slow afterwave’,IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.,48, pp. 1357–1365
McGill, K. C., andLateva, Z. C. (2001): ‘A model of the muscle-fiber intracellular action potential waveform, including the slow repolarization phase’,IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.,48, pp. 1480–1483
Meijers, L. M. M., Teulings, J. L. H. M., andEijkman, E. G. J. (1976): ‘Model of the electromyographic activity during brief isometric contractions’,Biol. Cybern.,25, pp. 7–16
Merletti, R., Lo Conte, L., Avignone, E. andGuglielminotti, P. (1999a): ‘Modeling of surface myoelectric signals—Part I: model implementation’,IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.,46, pp. 810–820
Merletti, R., Roy, S. H., Kupa, E., Roatta, S., andGranata, A. (1999b): ‘Modeling of surface myoelectric signals—Part II: model-based signal interpretation’,IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.,46, pp. 821–829
Merlo, A., Farina, D., andMerletti, R. (2003): ‘A fast and reliable technique for muscle activity detection from surface EMG signal’,IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.,50, pp. 316–323
Milner-Brown, H. S., andStein, R. B. (1975): ‘The relation between the surface electromyogram and muscular force’,J. Physiol. (Lond).,246, pp. 549–569
Nandedkar, S. D., Stålberg, E., andSanders, D. S. (1985): ‘Simulation techniques in electromyography’,IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.,32, pp. 775–785
Paiss, O., andInbar, G. F. (1987): ‘Autoregressive modeling of surface EMG and its spectrum with application to fatigue’,IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.,34, pp. 761–770
Pan, Z. S., Zhang, Y., andParker, P. A. (1989): ‘Motor unit power spectrum and firing rate’,Med. Biol. Eng. Comput.,27, pp. 14–18
Parker, P. A., andScott, R. N. (1986): ‘Myoelectric control of prostheses’,Crit. Rev. Biomed. Eng.,13, pp. 283–310
Perry, J., andBekey, G. A. (1981): ‘EMG-force relationships in skeletal muscle’,Crit. Rev. Biomed. Eng.,7, pp. 1–22
Plonsey, R. (1974): ‘The active fiber in a volume conductor’,IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.,21, pp. 371–381
Pollak, V. (1980: ‘Surface EMG and muscle force at low force levels’,Am. J. Phys. Med.,59, pp. 126–141
Rainoldi, A., Nazzaro, M., Merletti, R., Farina, D., Caruso, I., andGaudenti, S. (2000): ‘Geometrical factors in surface EMG of the vastus medialis and lateralis muscles’,J. Kinesiol. Electromyogr.,10, pp. 327–336
Roeleveld, K., Blok, J. H., Stegeman, D. F. andVan Oosterom, A. (1997a). ‘Volume conduction models for surface EMG; confrontation with measurements’,J. Electromyogr. Kinesiol.,7, pp. 221–232
Roeleveld, K., Stegeman, D. F., Vingerhoets, H. M., andVan Oosterom, A. (1997b): ‘Motor unit potential contribution to surface electromyography’,Acta Physiol. Scand.,160, pp. 175–183
Roeleveld, K., Stegeman, D. F., Vingerhoets, H. M., andVan Oosterom, A. (1997c): ‘The motor unit potential distribution over the skin surface and its use in estimating the motor unit location’,Acta Physiol. Scand.,161, pp. 465–472
Rosenfalck, P. (1969): ‘Intra- and extracellular potential fields of active nerve and muscle fibres’,Acta Physiol. Scand.,321, pp. 1–168
Roth, B. J., Gielen, F. L. H., andWikswo, J. P. (1988): ‘Spatial and temporal frequency-dependent conductivities in volume conduction calculations of skeletal muscle’,Math. Biosci.,88, pp. 159–189
Rutten, W. L., van Veen, B. K., Stroeve, S. H., Boom, H. B., andWallinga, W. (1997): ‘Influence of inhomogeneities in muscle tissue on single-fibre action potentials: a model study’,Med. Biol. Eng. Comput.,35, pp. 91–95
Schneider, J., Silny, J., andRau, G. (1991): ‘Influence of tissue inhomogeneities on noninvasive muscle fiber conduction velocity measurements-investigated by physical and numerical modeling’,IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.,38, pp. 851–860
Shwedyk, E., Balasubramanian, R., andScott, R. N. (1977): ‘A nonstationary model for the electromyogram’,IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.,24, pp. 417–424
Solomonow, M., Baratta, R., Zhou, B. H., Shoji, H., andD'Ambrosia, R. (1986). ‘Historical update and new developments on the EMG-force relationships of skeletal muscles’,Orthopedics,9, pp. 1541–1543
Stashuk, D. W. (1993): ‘Simulation of electromyographic signals’,J. Electromyogr. Kinesol.,3, pp. 157–173
Staude, G., andWolf, W. (1999): ‘Objective motor response onset detection in surface myoelectric signals’,Med. Eng. Phys.,21, pp. 449–467
Stegeman, D. F., andLinssen, W. H. J. P. (1992): ‘Muscle fiber action potential changes and surface EMG: a simulation study’,J. Electromyogr. Kinesol.,2, pp. 130–140
Stegeman, D. F., Dumitru, D., King, J. C., andRoeleveld, K. (1997): ‘Near- and far-fields: source characteristics and the conducting medium in neurophysiology’,J. Clin. Neurophysiol.,14, pp. 429–442
Stegeman, D. F., Blok, J. H., Hermens, H. J., andRoelevled, K. (2000): ‘Surface EMG models: properties and applications’,J. Electromyogr. Kinesiol.,10, pp. 313–326
Stoykov, N. S., Lowery, M. M., Taflove, A., andKuiken, T. A. (2002): ‘Frequency- and time-domain FEM models of EMG: capacitive effects and aspects of dispersion’,IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.,49, pp. 763–772
Studer, L. M., Ruegg, D. G., andGabriel, J.-P. (1999): ‘A model for steady isometric muscle activation’,Biol. Cybern.,80, pp. 339–355
Stulen, F. B., andDe Luca, C. J., (1981): ‘Frequency parameters of the myoelectric signal as a measure of muscle conduction velocity’,IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.,28, pp. 515–523
Sutherland, D. H. (2001): ‘The evolution of clinical gait analysis. Part 1: kinesiological EMG’,Gait Posture,14, pp. 61–70
Tansey, K. E., andBotterman, B. R. (1996): ‘Activation of typeidentified motor units during centrally evoked contractions in the cat medial gastrocnemius muscle. II. Motoneuron firing-rate modulation’,J. Neurophysiol.,75, pp. 38–50
van Oosterom, A. (1991): ‘History and evolution of methods for solving the inverse problem’,J. Clin. Neurophysiol.8, pp. 371–380
van Veen, B. K., Rijkhoff, N. J., Rutten, W. L., Wallinga, W., andBoom, H. B. (1992): ‘Potential distribution and single-fibre action potentials in a radially bounded muscle model’,Med. Biol. Eng. Comput.,30, pp. 303–310
van Veen, B. K., Wolters, H., Wallinga, W., Rutten, W. L., andBoom, H. B. (1993): ‘The bioelectrical source in computing single muscle fiber action potentials’,Biophys. J.,64, pp. 1492–1498
Woods, J. J., andBigland-Ritchie, B. (1983): ‘Linear and nonlinear surface emg/force relationships in human muscles. An anatomical/functional argument for the existence of both’,Am. J. Phys. Med.,62, pp. 287–299
Yana, K., Mizuta, H., andKajiyama, R. (1995): ‘Surface electromyogram recruitment analysis using higher order spectrum’. Proc. IEEE 17th Ann. Conf. Eng. Med. Biol. Soc.,2, pp. 1345–1346
Yao, W., Fuglevand, A. J., andEnoka, R. M. (2000): ‘Motor-unit synchronization increases EMG amplitude and decreases force steadiness of simulated contractions’,J. Neurophysiol.,83, pp. 441–452
Zajac, F. E., Neptune, R. R., andKautz, S. A. (2003): ‘Biomechanics and muscle coordination of human walking: Part II: lessons from dynamical simulations and clinical implications’,Gait Posture,17, pp. 1–17
Zwarts, M. J., andStegeman, D. F. (2003): ‘Multichannel surface EMG: basic aspects and clinical utility’,Muscle Nerve,28, pp. 1–17
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
McGill, K.C. Surface electromyogram signal modelling. Med. Biol. Eng. Comput. 42, 446–454 (2004). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02350985
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02350985